社会杂志 ›› 2013, Vol. 33 ›› Issue (5): 88-117.
黄荣贵,桂勇
出版日期:
2013-09-20
发布日期:
2013-09-20
通讯作者:
黄荣贵 rghuang@fudan.edu.cn
E-mail:rghuang@fudan.edu.cn
作者简介:
黄荣贵 复旦大学社会学系
HUANG Ronggui,GUI Yong
Online:
2013-09-20
Published:
2013-09-20
Contact:
HUANG Ronggui Department of Sociology,Fudan University
E-mail:rghuang@fudan.edu.cn
摘要: 本文结合社会运动联盟理论和城市治理理论,比较了上海和广州两个城市跨小区的业主组织联盟形态,提出一个基于治理结构与政治机会(威胁)的比较分析框架来理解两个城市业主组织联盟形态的差异。研究发现,与广州相比,上海的物业管理制度更加完善,基层治理组织架构也更加健全,体制内支持者相对缺乏,从而降低了社会冲突发生以及冲突激化为社会性公共议题的可能性。考虑到都市抗争的反应性特征以及中国社会管理体制所具有的社会控制和利益表达双重功能,都市抗争研究应该具体分析行动限制的制度根源、国家在预防社会抗争出现以及在抗争过程中的多重角色。
黄荣贵,桂勇. 为什么跨小区的业主组织联盟存在差异 ——一项基于治理结构与政治机会(威胁)的城市比较分析[J]. 社会杂志, 2013, 33(5): 88-117.
HUANG Ronggui,GUI Yong. Why Does Homeowners’ CrossNeighborhood Organizational Coalition in Shanghai Differ from That in Guangzhou? A CityLevel Comparative Analysis of the Governance Structures and Political Opportunities (Threats)[J]. Chinese Journal of Sociology, 2013, 33(5): 88-117.
陈鹏. 2010.当代中国城市业主的法权抗争——关于业主维权活动的一个分析框架[J].社会学研究(1):1-30.陈晓运. 2012. 去组织化:业主集体行动的策略——以G市反对垃圾焚烧厂建设事件为例[J].公共管理学报(2):67-75.冯仕政. 2006. 单位分割与集体抗争[J].社会学研究(3):98-134.管兵. 2010. 维权行动和基层民主参与:以B市商品房业主为例[J].社会30(5):46-74.桂勇. 2001. 略论城市基层民主发展的可能及其实现途径──以上海市为例[J]. 华中科技大学学报(社会科学版)(1):24-27.桂勇. 2007. 邻里政治:城市基层的权力操作策略与国家社会的粘连模式[J].社会27(6):102-126.郭巍青、陈晓运. 2011. 风险社会的环境异议——以广州市民反对垃圾焚烧厂建设为例[J]. 公共行政评论(1):95-121.何艳玲. 2007. 街区组织与街区事件——后单位制时期中国街区权力结构分析框架的建立[J].中山大学学报(社会科学版)(4):66-70.黄荣贵、桂勇. 2009. 互联网与业主集体抗争:一项基于定性比较分析方法的研究[J]. 社会学研究(5):29-56.黄荣贵、张涛甫、桂勇. 2011.抗争信息在互联网上的传播结构及其影响因素——基于业主论坛的经验研究[J]. 新闻与传播研究(2):89-112.刘爱玉. 2011.劳动权益受损与行动选择研究:两代农民工的比较[J].江苏行政学院学报(1):66-73.刘能. 2004. 怨恨解释、动员结构和理性选择——有关中国都市地区集体行动发生可能性的分析[J]. 开放时代(4):57-70.刘能. 2008. 当代中国群体性集体行动的几点理论思考——建立在经验案例之上的观察[J].开放时代(3):110-123.刘能. 2009. 当代中国转型社会中的集体行动:对过去三十年间三次集体行动浪潮的一个回顾[J].学海(4):146-152.茅茂春. 2012. 物业管理大调解机制的上海模式[J].城市开发(9):34-36.唐娟. 2006. 月亮湾的业主维权新模式[J].现代物业(3):5-7.唐军. 2006. 生存资源剥夺与传统体制依赖:当代中国工人集体行动的逻辑——对河南省Z市Z厂兼并事件的个案研究[J].江苏社会科学(6):174-183.汤艳文. 2004. 不完全契约形态:转型社会的社区治理结构——以上海康健地区业主委员会的发展为例[J]. 上海行政学院学报(2):68-78.佟新. 2006. 延续的社会主义文化传统——一起国有企业工人集体行动的个案分析[J].社会学研究(1):59-76.童志锋. 2009. 动员结构与自然保育运动的发展——以怒江反坝运动为例[J].开放时代(9):116-132.王汉生、吴莹. 2011. 基层社会中“看得见”与“看不见”的国家——发生在一个商品房小区中的几个故事[J]. 社会学研究(1):63-95.夏建中. 2003. 中国公民社会的先声:以业主委员会为例[J]. 文史哲(3):115-121.应星. 2007.草根动员与农民群体利益的表达机制——四个个案的比较研究[J]. 社会学研究(2):1-23.于建嵘. 2004. 当前农民维权活动的一个解释框架[J].社会学研究(4):49-55.俞志元. 2012. 集体性抗争行动结果的影响因素——一项基于三个集体性抗争行动的比较研究[J].社会学研究(3):90-112.曾文慧. 2002. 社区自治:冲突与回应——一个业主委员会的成长历程[J].社会22(2):54-57.张建. 2010. 招投标市场的“四个一”——上海物业管理招投标市场发展回顾与展望[J].中国物业管理(2):56-57.张紧跟、庄文嘉. 2008. 非正式政治:一个草根NGO的行动策略——以广州业主委员会联谊会筹备委员会为例[J].社会学研究(2):133-150.张磊. 2005. 业主维权运动:产生原因及动员机制——对北京市几个小区个案的考查[J]. 社会学研究(6):1-39.赵珍珍、布莱登. 2010. 业主维权过程中的行动策略与权力结构——基于广州市两个居住小区的比较[J]. 战略决策研究(5):74-90.朱健刚. 2002. 国与家之间:上海邻里的市民团体与社区运动的民族志[D].香港中文大学人类学系博士学位论文.庄文嘉. 2011. 跨越国家赋予的权利? 对广州市业主抗争的个案研究[J]. 社会31(3):88-113.Banazak,Lee Ann. 2005.“Inside and Outside the State:Movement insider Status,Tactics,and Public Policy Achievements.”In Routing the Opposition:Social Movements,Public Policy,and Democracy,edited by David S. Meyer,Valerie Jenness, and Helen Ingram.Minneapolis,Minn:University of Minnesota Press:149-176.Borland,Elizabeth. 2008. “Social Movement Organizations and Coalitions:Comparisons from the Women’s Movement in Buenos Aires,Argentina.”In Research in Social Movements, Conflicts and Change(Vol.28). Emerald Group Publishing Limited:83-112.Cai,Yongshun. 2005. “China’s Moderate Middle Class:The Case of Homeowners’ Resistance.”Asian Survey 45(5):777-799.Caramani,Daniele. 2009. Introduction to the Comparative Method with Boolean Algebra. Los Angeles:Sage.Chang,Paul Y. 2008.“Unintended Consequences of Repression:Alliance Formation in South Korea’s Democracy Movement (1970-1979).”Social Forces 87(2):651-677.Chung,Yousun. 2008. “PropertyOwning Socialism in a New StateSociety Relationship:Housing Reform in Urban China.”Ph.D.Thesis,University of WisconsinMadison.George,Alexander and Andrew Bennett. 2004. Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences. Cambridge:MIT Press.Gerring,John. 2006. Case Study Research: Principles and Practices. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.Gui,Yong,Weihong Ma,and Klaus Mühlhahnc. 2009. “Grassroots Transformation in Contemporary China.”Journal of Contemporary Asia 39(3):400-423.Haydu,Jeffrey. 2012. “Frame Brokerage in the Pure Food Movement,1879-1906.”Social Movement Studies 11(1):97-112.Ho,Peter. 2007.“Embedded Activism and Political Change in a Semiauthoritarian Context.”China Information 21(2):187-209.Huang,Ronggui. 2010.“Housing Activism in Shanghai:Opportunities and Constraints.”Ph.D. Thesis, City University of Hong Kong.Huang,Ronggui and Ngaiming Yip. 2012.“Internet and Activism in Urban China:A Case Study of Protests in Xiamen and Panyu.”Journal of Comparative Asia Development 11(2):201-223.Huang,Youqin and Leiwen Jiang. 2009. “Housing Inequality in Transitional Beijing.”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 33(4):936-956.Hurst,William. 2004. “Understanding Contentious Collective Action by Chinese LaidOff Workers:The Importance of Regional Political Economy.”Studies in Comparative International Development 39(2):94-120.Logan,John R.,Yiping Fang,and Zhanxin Zhang. 2010.“The Winners in China’s Urban Housing Reform.”Housing Studies 25(1):101-117.Mayer,Brian. 2009.“CrossMovement Coalition Formation:Bridging the LaborEnvironment Divide.”Sociological Inquiry 79(2):219-239.McAdam,Doug and Hilary Schaffer Boudet. 2012. Putting Social Movements in their Place? Explaining Opposition to Energy Projects in the United States,2000-2005. New York:Cambridge University Press.McCammon,Holly J. and Karen E. Campbell. 2002. “Allies On the Road to Victory:Coalition Formation Between the Suffragists and the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union.”Mobilization:An International Quarterly 7(3):231-251.McCammon,Holly J. and Nella Van Dyke. 2010. “Applying Qualitative Comparative Analysis to Empirical Studies of Social Movement Coalition Formation.”In Strategic Alliances:Coalition Building and Social Movements,edited by Nella Van Dyke and Holly J. McCammon. Minneapolis:University of Minnesota Press:292-315.O’Brien,Kevin J. and Lianjiang Li. 2006. Rightful Resistance in Rural China. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Perry,Elizabeth J. 1994. “Trends in the Study of Chinese Politics:StateSociety Relations.”The China Quarterly (139):704-713.Read,Benjamin L. 2003a. “Democratizing the Neighbourhood? New Private Housing and HomeOwner SelfOrganization in Urban China.”The China Journal (49):31-59.Read,Benjamin L. 2003b. “State,Social Networks and Citizens in China’s Urban Neighborhoods.”Ph. D. Dissertation,Harvard University Department of Government. Read,Benjamin L. 2007.“Inadvertent Political Reform via Private Assoications:Assessing Homeowners’ Groups in New Neighborhood.”In Grassroots Political Reform in Contemporary China,edited by Elizabeth J. Perry and Merle Goldman.Cambridge:Harvard University Press:149-173.Read,Benjamin L. 2008. “Assessing Variation in Civil Society Organizations:China’s Homeowner Associations in Comparative Perspective.”Comparative Political Studies 41(9):1240-1265.Rohlinger,Deana A. 2006. “Friends and Foes:Media,Politics,and Tactics in the Abortion War.”Social Problems 53(4):537-561.Rucht,Dieter. 2004. “Movement Allies,Adversaries,and Third Parties.”In The Blackwell Companion to Social Movements,edited by David A. Snow,Sarah A. Soule,and Hanspeter Kriesi.Oxford:Blackwell Publishing:197-216.Shaffer,Martin B. 2000.“Coalition Work among Environmental Groups Who Participates?”In Research in Social Movements,Conflicts,and Change(Vol.22).Emerald Group Publishing Limited:111-126. Shemtov,Ronit. 2003.“Social Networks and Sustained Activism in Local NIMBY Campaigns.”Sociological Forum 18 (2):215-244.Shi,Fayong. 2008. “Social Capital at Work:The Dynamics and Consequences of Grassroots Movements in Urban China.”Critical Asian Studies 40(2):233-262.Shi,Fayong and Yongshun Cai. 2006. “Disaggregating the State:Networks and Collective Resistance in Shanghai.”The China Quarterly 186(1):314-332.Snyder,Richard. 2001.“Scaling Down:The Subnational Comparative Method.”Studies in Comparative International Development 36(1):93-110.Staggenborg,Suzanne. 1986. “Coalition Work in the ProChoice Movement:Organizational and Environmental Opportunities and Obstacles.”Social Problems 33(5):374-390.Sun,Yanfei and Dingxin Zhao. 2007.“Multifaceted State and Fragmented Society:Dynamics of Environmental Movement in China.”In Discontented Miracle: Growth,Conflict,and Institutional Adaptations in China,edited by Dali Yang.New Jersey:World Scientific Publisher:111-160.Tomba,Luigi. 2004. “Creating an Urban Middle Class: Social Engineering in Beijing.”The China Journal(51):1-26.Van Dyke,Nella. 2003. “Crossing Movement Boundaries:Factors that Facilitate Coalition Protest by American College Students, 1930-1990.”Social Problems 50(2):226-250.Van Dyke,Nella and Holly J. McCammon (eds.). 2010. Strategic Alliances:Coalition Building and Social Movements. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.Walder,Andrew. 2009. “Political Sociology and Social Movements.”Annual Review of Sociology(35):393-412.Yang,Guobin. 2009. The Power of the Internet in China:Citizen Activism Online. New York:Columbia University Press.Yip,Ngaiming and Yihong Jiang. 2011.“Homeowners United:The Attempt to Create Lateral Networks of Homeowners’ Associations in Urban China.”Journal of Contemporary China 20(72): 735-750.Zhao,Dingxin. 2010. “Authoritarian State and Contentious Politics.”In Handbook of Politics:State and Society in Global Perspective,edited by Kevin T. Leicht and J. Craig Jenkins.New York:Springer:459-476.责任编辑:张军 |
[1] | 陈型颖, 王衡. 政治信任、社会网络与抗争倾向:基于53个国家和地区的实证比较[J]. 社会杂志, 2018, 38(1): 186-214. |
[2] | 陶郁, 侯麟科, 刘明兴. 张弛有别:上级控制力、下级自主性和农村基层政令执行[J]. 社会杂志, 2016, 36(5): 107-130. |
[3] | 季程远, 王衡, 顾昕. 中国网民的政治价值观与网络抗争行为的限度[J]. 社会杂志, 2016, 36(5): 64-87. |
[4] | 孙小逸, 黄荣贵. 维权情境中的自发性认知解放——以业主积极分子的权利意识的演进为例[J]. 社会杂志, 2016, 36(3): 140-166. |
[5] | 管兵. 走向法庭还是走上街头:超越维权困境的一条行动路径[J]. 社会杂志, 2015, 35(6): 206-234. |
[6] | 曹正汉. 统治风险与地方分权——关于中国国家治理的三种理论及其比较[J]. 社会杂志, 2014, 34(6): 52-70. |
[7] | 魏伟. 街头·行为·艺术: 性别权利倡导和抗争行动形式库的创新[J]. 社会杂志, 2014, 34(2): 94-117. |
[8] | 覃琮. 农民维权活动的理法抗争及其理论解释——两起征地案例的启示[J]. 社会杂志, 2013, 33(6): 93-121. |
[9] | 吴长青. 英雄伦理与抗争行动的持续性——以鲁西农民抗争积极分子为例[J]. 社会杂志, 2013, 33(5): 204-205. |
[10] | 丁瑜 李会. 住院康复精神病人日常生活实践中的充权: 一个广州的个案研究 [J]. 社会杂志, 2013, 33(4): 117-146. |
[11] | 程秀英. 消散式遏制:中国劳工政治的比较个案研究[J]. 社会杂志, 2012, 32(5): 194-218. |
[12] | 吕德文. 媒介动员、钉子户与抗争政治——宜黄事件再分析[J]. 社会杂志, 2012, 32(3): 129-170. |
[13] | 黄荣贵 桂勇. 集体性社会资本对社区参与的影响——基于多层次数据的分析[J]. 社会杂志, 2011, 31(6): 1-21. |
[14] | 庄文嘉. 跨越国家赋予的权利?——对广州市业主抗争的个案研究[J]. 社会杂志, 2011, 31(3): 88-113. |
[15] | 朱健刚. 以理抗争:都市集体行动的策略——以广州南园的业主维权为例[J]. 社会杂志, 2011, 31(3): 24-41. |
阅读次数 | ||||||
全文 |
|
|||||
摘要 |
|
|||||