2018 Vol.38

    Please wait a minute...
    For Selected: Toggle Thumbnails
    Everyday Life Logic in Field Research: Experience, Theory, and Method
    ZHE Xiaoye
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (1): 1-29.  
    Abstract1884)   HTML    PDF(pc) (775KB)(1205)       Save

    The author's many years of field research provide the base for the sociological discussion in this paper about the relationship between field research and everyday life logic as well as the relationship between theory and method. The study finds that there is an intermediate stage between experience and theory, namely, the everyday life logic that calls for an in-depth investigation.The logic of daily lives is a kind of "accumulated foundation" that is hidden in the details of everyday life and can only be uncovered by immersing oneself into the field. Steps such as from observing to understanding, from speculating to questioning, from predisposition to analysis, from techniques to social process, from tale-telling to facts finding, are suggested as desirable research methods. Individual case study and multi-case comparative study have different effects on research. While there is an increasing and interrelated relationship between the two, the difference exists in their focal points in different phases. Individual case study, with its focus on questioning, observing and interpreting, can provide evidence to test hypothesis and find the typical institutional logic in everyday life. Multi-case comparative study compensates the deficiency of individual case study by either expanding investigation ormaking comparison among different cases. This type of reasoning is an analytic reasoning, a form of inducing general conclusions from multi-case comparison. It contributes to the formation of a theoretical prototype.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    “The Imagination of Fieldwork”: Between Science and Art-a Study of Petitions and Power: The Story of the Migrants of a Dam in China
    YING Xing
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (1): 30-53.  
    Abstract1383)   HTML    PDF(pc) (881KB)(969)       Save

    Fieldwork has the dual characteristics of empirical work and humanistic nature. The so-called "the imagination of fieldwork" is something between scientific investigation and artistic imagination that closely combines accurate observation with imaginative reproduction. This study examines the fieldwork involving in writing Petitions and Power:The Story of the Migrants of a Dam in China, an investigative report that demonstrates"the imagination of fieldwork". From the perspective of the relationship between fieldwork and theory, the basic issuesin field research are neither generated directly from empirical reality nor deduced from middle range theory. The sphere of "the imagination of fieldwork" is defined within the domain of classical theory, whichis a significant source to field studies. However, in practice, theory must be integrated completely with empirical reality. From the perspective of the relationship between micro and macro level, neither representativeness nor typicality,but complexity is the basic characteristic of "the imagination of fieldwork." This complexity is manifested in many ways such asreflection on the natural legitimacy of "hometown sociology"; the breakthrough on the conformability, systematicness and organicity of the functionalist paradigm; taking the analysis of actors rather than structures as the focus of fieldwork; bringing the historical perspective into fieldwork, and so on. Complexity in fieldwork is not entirely a result of some artificial designsbut rather oftenan outcome of the unexpected. "The imagination of fieldwork" has the characteristics of handcraft. Its cultivation needs special patience and requires not only a great deal of effort on classical theory by taking no easy path, but also constant reflection and careful examinationin the pursuit of complexity.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    The Structure and Meaning of Everyday Life: A Sociological Study of Qu Li from the Book of Rites
    WU Liucai
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (1): 54-80.  
    Abstract1645)   HTML    PDF(pc) (1002KB)(586)       Save

    The study of rituals from the perspective of social anthropology helps us to comprehend our everyday life and deepen our understanding of social structure because the process of rites emphasized by this approach triggers the practical subjectivity of people in social interaction. Rituals connect the institution and the mind, so the study of rituals helps us to understand the composition of the social world,as well as the heart and spirit underneath the institution and the structure. Through a social anthropological interpretation of Qu Li from the Book of Rites, this paper finds that everyday life possesses basic elements such as social structure and time. Rituals contain complicated structures of human relations and the relationship between heaven and man, and rich experiences of time. The social world in Chinese rituals is a world of ghosts and gods,and of the five cardinal relations generated and sustained overtime. The ritual system is not only a secular social structure but a system of cosmology. The study of Qu Li shows that our everyday life does not exist in ourselves but in our integration with the outside world. When humans practice rituals, he/she find the meaning of life in social life. This paper holds that the emotion and the meaning embodied in rites are the source of the sacred sense of social life, and rituals are the means and the process of bringing people and society into this realm. Such an interpretation places traditional rituals under the scope of sociology, contributing to the development of Chinese social theory.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Fire Administration of Wuzhou and Regional Social Transformation During Ming and Qing
    MAI Sijie
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (1): 81-103.  
    Abstract1280)   HTML    PDF(pc) (959KB)(328)       Save

    Fire administration is one of the important city affairs in imperial China and it often reveals regional social transformation at the time. During Ming and Qing, the social transition occurred the Xijiang region transformed Wuzhou from a military fortress to a key market town. This transformation was clearly reflected on the fire administration of the town. The Ming government established an important military base in Wuzhou during its suppression of Yao ethnic rebellion in the region. In the post-rebellion years, the town's military function gradually disappeared. Different social groups began to reorganize social order around the fire administration. Officials, military households and local ethnic people all attempted to promote their own interests through the fire administration. Fire God worship religious rites evolved into a system of elaborated symbols representing diverse discourses. Furthermore, the arrival of salt merchants from Guangdong further complicated the fire religious practice. By Qing dynasty, many former soldiers became gentry through the Imperial Examination. The gentry played an active role in public life through construction and maintenance of the Fire God temples and became an important force in urban social life. Meanwhile, the development of rice trade brought a large number of Guangdong traders to Wuzhou. These merchants engaged in the local social life by building the Northern God temple. Thus, there were two traditions of Fire God and Northern God in the fire administration of Wuzhou in Qing dynasty. The integration of the local gentry and traders led to the merger of the two traditions and eventually a reconstructed fire worship religious system in Wuzhou.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    The Society-Culture Paradigm in Memory Study: An Interpretation of the Halbwachs-Assmann Research Tradition
    LIU Yaqiu
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (1): 104-133.  
    Abstract1361)   HTML    PDF(pc) (825KB)(533)       Save

    The societal and cultural concepts in Halbwachs-Assmann research tradition offers us a society-culture paradigm that remedies what is absent in the existing memory study. The paradigm is presented through concepts that are closely related to sacred memories, such as the social framework of memory, social quality and the Canon, myths, festivals, and etc. For sociology, the social power that stimulates people's memories comes from the so-called "Sacred Society" described by Durkheim. Halbwachs' collective memory theory is rooted deeply in sociological tradition. Concepts such as social framework and social quality are at the core of Durkheim's social ontology. They helped Halbwachs formulate his sacred memory theory. Likewise, Jan Assmann's cultural memory theory continues Halbwachs' study of sacred memory by supplementing a new dimension of cultural memory. This relationship forms the foundation of the society-culture paradigm in the memory study. Taking the meaning of cultural rules in history as its core, the paradigm emphasizes the combination of social and cultural dimensions in memory and provides a systematic analysis of how historical society becomes possible. To change the social memory study from "orientation discussion" to "paradigm analysis" can be beneficial to the development of the social memory research tradition.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Factions and Their Govermance: A Perspective of Hume's Social and Political Theory
    XU Zhiguo
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (1): 134-159.  
    Abstract1126)   HTML    PDF(pc) (702KB)(381)       Save

    The faction conflict and its harm are one of the chronic problems plaguing the ancient Western republican government. The construction of a civilized political order must meet the challenges of factionalism. Based on the observation of the history and the times in the West, Hume started from his empiricist theory of human nature and regarded "factionalism" and its governance as the core contents of social and political theory. Hume believes that factions are rooted in human nature, people's emotional orientation and diversity of beliefs is the underlying reason. Although factionalism can't be completely eliminated, one can rely on the inherent principles of the development of affairs, make the use of various forces and design corresponding systems to control the harms of the factional factions. Hume suggested that factional governance can proceed from three paths:First, the development of commerce, science and the arts can improve people's rationality and mutual sympathy among the people so as to eliminate people's extreme beliefs and promote social solidarity. Secondly, civilized Political order should not rely on civil virtue, but should establish mutual checks and balances between factions. Thirdly, the extremeness of religious factions is a major threat to the construction of social order. In order to maintain the stability of social order, religious tolerance must be advocated on the one hand, On the other hand, we must also establish a system of secular government control over religion. Hume's factional governance theory has a modern vision based on a commercial society. It surpasses thinkers such as Machiavelli and Hobbes. While building social order, On the one hand Hume is committed to weakening and eliminating the destruction of social order by extremist factions. On the other hand, moderate factions become the driving force for social prosperity and development. Hume's theory on factional governance has an important impact on the constitutionalism of the United States and still has important implications for the factional governance in today's society.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    The Power of Co-optation: Party, Political Capital and the Development of NGOs: A Comparative Case Study in H city, Z Province
    LI Shuoyan
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (1): 160-185.  
    Abstract1308)   HTML    PDF(pc) (897KB)(655)       Save

    In recent years, there has been a growing number of publications focusing on the state-NGOs relationship in China. However, most of the studies regard the state as "the government" and neglect the role of the Party, a key player, in shaping the state-NGOs relationship, as well as the difference between the government and the Party. As a ruling party, the CCP exercises tremendous influence on people's daily life.Current studies indicate that the government tend to use a strategy of categorization to control NGOs. What remains unclear, however, is whether the Party has a different impact on NGOs than the government and how it influences the relationship between the government and NGOs. This paper examines the emerging role of the Party since the policy implementation of "Strengthening the Party Organization in NGOs" in 2015, which requires all NGOs to establish CCP branch units. Two environmental grassroots NGOs are selected for the comparative case study in this paper to examine the different mechanism through which the Party makes its impact on NGOs. The finding indicates that only the Party is able to co-opt the leaders of NGOs and give them political credentials and capitals that help expanding NGOs'social networks and creating a hospitable regulative environment for growth. The finding suggests that a close tie with the state does not necessarily mean a loss of autonomy. This study is by no mean a comprehensive discussion of the impact of the Party on NGOs. Further research is needed to study the actual impact of this relationship on public governance.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Political Trust,Social Network and Protest Potential: An Empirical Comparison of Fifty-Three Countries and Regions around the World
    CHEN Xingying, WANG Heng
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (1): 186-214.  
    Abstract1671)   HTML    PDF(pc) (845KB)(720)       Save

    Based on the data from the World Values Survey(WVS) wave 6 (2010~2014),this article applies the multilevel mixed-effects logistic regression model to explore the influence factors of protest potential. An analysis of more than 70 000 samples from 53 countries and regions around the world indicates that individual protest potential is determined by both micro-level and macro-level variables. On micro-level,personal social network and political trust have an effect on individual protest tendency. The quantitative analysis shows strong positive correlation between social network and protest potential,while the effect of political trust on protest potential is not definitive. The finding supports resource mobilization theory in organizational sociology that provides a better explanation of protest potential in comparison to collective behavior theory in social psychology. On macro-level,polity type exerts impact on individual protest potential. Citizens under democratic regimes are more prone to protest than those under authoritarian regimes. In authoritarian countries,the group with strong social networks and low political trust exhibits the highest probability of protesting,while in democracies,those with strong social networks and high political trust are most likely to protest. It is a clear indication that regime type inserts influence on micro-level factors affecting protest potential. In conclusion,in democracies,political trust promotes people's engagement in protests,and social protests demonstrate institutionalized characteristics of high density with low intensity. In authoritarian countries,people resort to protest mainly because of their distrust in the authority,therefore social protests have non-institutionalized characteristics of low density with high intensity.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Chinese People's Perceptions about Meritocracy
    LI Zhonglu
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (1): 215-237.  
    Abstract1857)   HTML    PDF(pc) (725KB)(1019)       Save

    The allocation of occupational positions and economic wealth based primarily on merits has been widely accepted as a principle of economic justice in modern societies. However,relatively few studies have empirically examined ordinary Chinese people's perceptions of the meritocratic allocation of social rewards. To extend our knowledge about public attitudes towards mobility opportunities,this paper seeks to examine ordinary people's beliefs about determinants of getting ahead through analyzing the recently national representative data from China Family Panel Studies (CFPS2010). Empirical results show that:Firstly,about 60 percent of Chinese people tend to believe that individual education and hard work are more important than family origins for economic wealth and success. Secondly,Chinese people's perceptions of meritocracy are closely related to their objective status,and people with a higher socioeconomic status tend to more believe in meritocracy than their lower-status counterparts. Thirdly,young adults growing up in the market reform era are more likely to hold stronger meritocratic beliefs than their counterparts who have experienced the planned economy. Finally,the income inequality at county level has significantly negative effects on public perceptions of meritocracy;especially for those with lower socioeconomic status. This paper extends our understanding of the reasons for Chinese citizens' increasing tolerance of inequality against the sharp rise in income discrepancies in the reform era,because that most of Chinese people hold strong belief that merits are playing a more important role than family origin in socioeconomic advancement in modern China. However,it should be noted that Chinese people's perceptions about meritocracy are highly related to their socioeconomic status.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (1): 242-.  
    Abstract515)   HTML    PDF(pc) (18830KB)(136)       Save
    Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    “Bureaucratic & Economic Markets” and China's Growth Story
    ZHOU Li
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (2): 1-45.  
    Abstract1936)   HTML    PDF(pc) (991KB)(1385)       Save

    This paper extends the theory of "bureaucratic & economic markets" and reinterprets the unique growth mechanism of the Chinese economy and the intriguing interaction between government and market. In China we observe an interesting "mutual embededness" of bureaucratic markets for local officials and economic markets for firms across jurisdictions:local leaders compete in bureaucratic markets where their promotion is closely linked with economic performance of firms in their jurisdictions, and in the meantime, firms compete in economic markets and receive critical support for their respective jurisdictional governments. The performance-based bureaucratic competition motivates local leaders to help local firms grow and win the economic competition, and the interregional mobility of physical and human capital limits the tendency of local leaders to predate or grab local firms. The economic performance of firms in market competition provides feedback and is an ultimate test of the effectiveness of government-business cooperation and local industrial policies. The extended theory of "bureaucratic & economic markets" contributes to the existing literature by highlighting three critical preconditions for effective government-market cooperation:providing political incentives to ensure bureaucrats "do things in the right way", external market constraints to "prevent bureaucrats from doing evil", and necessary information feedback to guide bureaucrats to "do the right thing". For any country or region, its ability to satisfy these three conditions becomes critical for fostering an effective interaction between government and market and sustaining economic growth. In the past decades China has shaped a growth model based on the interplay of "bureaucratic & economic markets" which generally satisfied the three preconditions and laid the institutional foundation for China's economic miracle. This dual-markets model has resulted in friendly handshaking between political and private entrepreneurs, productive cooperation between political and economic elites, and a remarkable combination of China's time-honored heritage of strong bureaucracy with the western tradition of market economy. The dual-markets model also has its limitations, especially in the sphere of provision of public services, which exactly explains various "government failures" associated with China's high economic growth in the past 40 years.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Financial Globalization and the Transnational Diffusion of Shareholder-Oriented Corporate Governance Institutions: A Sociological Analysis of Corporate Governance Reform in China
    YANG Dian
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (2): 46-83.  
    Abstract1103)   HTML    PDF(pc) (1083KB)(431)       Save

    Since the rise of financial globalization and American "shareholder capitalism"in the 1980s, the shareholder-oriented corporate governance model has become more and more prevalent around the world. It was widely perceived as the "best" corporate governance model or "international best practices", which has not only impacted the stakeholder-oriented corporate governance model of Germany and Japan, but also shaped corporate governance reform of developing countries and transitional countries like China. The author argues that the adoption of shareholder-oriented corporate governance institutions in China was mainly driven by two endogenous and exogenous factors,and diffused through three mechanisms in two phases. In the first phase, at the transnational level (from America to China), mimetic isomorphism and normative isomorphism are at play. In the second stage, at the domestic firm-level, the government requires companies to adopt new corporate governance institutions through laws, regulations and policies, that is,the mechanism of "coercive isomorphism" has played a leading role. This paper contributes to organizational theory and economic sociology theory by extending the basic postulates of the new institutionalism to the study of international diffusion and isomorphism of organizational practices. While the importance of imitation among network members in the diffusion of organizational practices has often been shown at the interpersonal and inter-organizational (firm) levels,this research offers support for a similar mechanism operating at the international level. Taken together, the findings demonstrate the importance of power (vs. efficiency) in the adoption of organizational practices in general, and the role of the state (vs. financial market) in the international diffusion of American corporate governance practices in particular.Furthermore, the sociological analysis of China's corporate governance reform in this paper is helpful for us to deepen our understanding of China's financial market and listed companies,providing a new perspective different from that given by Economics and Management Science. The analysis has important theoretical and practical significance in reflecting the Western neo-liberal enterprise model and constructing a "modern enterprise system" with Chinese characteristics.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    The History and Future of Kham: Perspectives Based on the Historical Anthropological Reading of Alai's Four Novels
    ZHENG Shaoxiong
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (2): 84-110.  
    Abstract1153)   HTML    PDF(pc) (908KB)(358)       Save

    Up to present the distinguished Tibetan writer Alai has published four full-length novels, namely, King Gesar, Nyarong (Zhandui), Red Poppies, and the Hollow Mountain series, which have, to a great extent, shaped outsiders' impressions of Kham, or Eastern Tibet, one of the three traditional divisions of "cultural Tibet" or "ethnographical Tibet". Based on historical anthropological perspectives, this article examines the spatial and temporal dimensions of Kham history reflected from these four novels. On the one hand, it shows that the native Khampa's senses of space referring to surrounding political entities has changed from an ancient model of "four regimes at four directions," to a dual model related to central and the local Tibetan polities in late Imperial China and the Republican Period, and finally to the unitary model of a single central government in the contemporary period. On the other hand, this article also points out, Khampa have experienced a changing sense of time from circulatory Tibetan Buddhist time to the dynastic time-scale of Chinese Empires and finally to a modern linear time-scale. Beyond revealing the transformations in the spatial and temporary senses of Khampa people, Alai also implicitly demonstrates alternative models in Sino-Tibetan relations, as both historical reality and ideality:Spatially, the process of forced integration of Han Chinese and Tibetan people has simultaneously preserved a dialectical distinction, this distinction has been buffered and connected through the medium of the Khampa. Temporally, free borderland markets, acting the role of historical transcendence, have been protective and under control, especially for the sake of Tibetans.
    The above narratives consist of both the empirical facts and Alai's expectations and constructions. On the one hand, as an ethnic-minority writer and native speaker of Tibetan dialect, Alai loves his siblings and tends to understand the conditions of the Tibetans from the bottom up, on the other hand, raised at a peripheral Tibetan village near the Han area, educated in a modern Mandarin-language schools and college, and not able to write in his mother tongue, Alai's conception of history has been from above to below. It is easy to understand that when faced with issues of frontiers and ethnic minorities, native elites like Alai are quite likely to develop a historical construction of literary complexity. This complexity further diversifies the impressions of Tibet for outsiders.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Buddhism in the Shang Chuan Nan Region and Local Society in the Ming Dynasty
    CHEN Zhigang
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (2): 111-133.  
    Abstract854)   HTML    PDF(pc) (933KB)(345)       Save

    In the Ming dynasty the Shang Chuan Nan region close to the Tibet was the only road by which foreign envoys could carry out trade and bring tributes. Lizhou, Yazhou and Diaomen were the three important tea and horse trading sites, and the tributary trade practiced there stimulated the long-distance tea trade along the upper and middle Yangtze River. During the Longqing period, the trade volume of tea reached 3 million jin per annum from 1567 to 1572, and a tributary route took shape called the "Yangtze-Grand Canal". The collaborative relationship between the Tibetan and the Han ethnicities became intimate. Tibetan Buddhism and Han Buddhism could be practiced without conflict, Han and Tibetan society and the Chinese society were well integrated. The Buddhist monks and the Confucian scholars reconciled the Confucian ideological principles of "Shan" (goodness) and "Yi" (righteousness). The Buddhism temple offered birthday congratulations to the emperor, prayed for longevity for the emperor, prayed for the peace and stability of the state, prayed for good weather for the crops, and so on. Buddhists invited the Confucian scholars to inscribe the record of events on temple tablets, while Confucian scholars retreated within the beautiful scenery of Buddhist temples to prepare for the imperial examination. Buddhist temples also cooperated with the needs of local governments, and local officials would often retreat to Buddhist temples in times of drought to pray for rain. Buddhism and Confucianism had broad contact with society, causing Confucian scholars to come into close contact with Buddhist beliefs and lifestyle. The local government exercised the imperial court's ceremonies and held royal celebrations in Buddhist temples. Because Buddhist rites could help villagers deal with the problem of death, the descendants of layman in order to fulfill their filial piety asked Buddhist yogi to release their ancestors from the cycle of samsara. Local families relied on Buddhist rites to sacrifice their ancestors and hold together the family clan. By means of donating tea plantations and land to Buddhist temples, the big local families set up local positions of authority. Buddhism cultivated a social atmosphere which commended charitable deeds and developed a united spirit, where local groups enjoyed authority, so that the locals of the Shang Chuan Nan region could defend themselves during a period of enormous turbulence in the late Ming. Buddhism was an important contributor to social stabilization and continuity during the late Ming's Dynasty's period of unrest.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    State-Building and the Changes of Urban Land Property Rights in Guangzhou during the Republic of China Era (1911-1935)
    HUANG Sujuan
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (2): 134-153.  
    Abstract1252)   HTML    PDF(pc) (703KB)(342)       Save

    This paper took the change of urban land property rights in Guangzhou during the Republic of China as an example to investigate how the modern national government using new legal provisions, tax systems, administrative management and other measures to set up a "New Management" system of urban land property rights. The paper also tried to explore the mechanism of the urban land property rights system in the specific time and space of modern China, and how the modern government achieves the shift from local land to land with public functions.After the Revolution of 1911, the Guangdong military government classified "public property" or "official property" by legislation. The modern government made efforts to draw a precise line of demarcation between "public" and "private" land in the city. The emergence of many cases of "private houses constructed on official land" and "unlawful auction of private property" showed that there was no sharp demarcation between the ownership of public and private land. It's too difficult to solve with a single piece of legislation. After the establishment of the Guangzhou Municipality, the Municipality used the name "municipal property" to divide the scope of jurisdiction of provincial and municipal governments in fiscal taxation. In this way, the Municipality also accomplished the purpose of managing public land in the city. The excessive expansion of "municipal property" further confused the unclear demarcation line between public and private property rights, sparking massive protests. The appearance of a "private property guarantee" was a compromise between the government and the people on the boundary of public and private property rights. In addition to setting boundaries between public and private land ownership, modern state governments had tried to eliminate double ownership of shops. However, the government's efforts to expand the power of administration were opposed by the majority of business people, led by the General Chamber of Commerce. The compromise between the government and business people resulted in the implementation of the registration of the rights to rent a shop. In this way, the government indirectly implemented part of the management of private property rights. After the Guangzhou Municipality reorganized into a committee system in 1925, the government set up a land bureau to carry out land survey and land registration, which met with some resistance. It was not carried out in Guangzhou until the end of 1927. Through land surveying and land registration, the government solved the problem of the recognition of land property rights, and then linked the recognized property to specific tax obligations. It meant that private property rights were recognized and protected by the government by paying land tax. To this extent, the modern government and the people had come to a new agreement of financial relationships in land affairs. The basics of the urban land property management system had been established.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Science and the Movements to Directional Values: The Centennial of Max Weber's Wissenschaft als Beruf
    TIAN Geng
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (2): 154-187.  
    Abstract1800)   HTML    PDF(pc) (853KB)(422)       Save

    The meaning of "Science as Vocation", this paper argues, in Max Weber's lecture on Wissenschaft als Beruf (1917) goes beyond the conventional understanding of "science for its own sake", and is about how actions that bear the ultimate values of the actors can be possible. In Weber's Wissenschaftslehre, such actions can come only after the process of value rationalization which transfers our initial personal feelings of value to real belief in the validity of values. Without such a process, actors don't even know what they need to defend or strive for as consistent social beings. The process of value rationalization, however, for Weber is only driven by the willingness to truth, not any primordial attachment to any convention or cultural heritage that is assumed as self--evidently or naturally valid by other theorists. Thus, the value rationalization that Weber conceptualizes leaves one critical question for modern social theory to answer:how should we theoretically think about the human groups which are supposed to live their cultural values (i.e.the idea of Gemeinschaftsschicksale)?

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    “From Ignorance to Guilt”: The Triple Interweaving of Knowledge-Power in Foucault's Analysis of Oedipus the King
    ZHU Wencheng
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (2): 188-212.  
    Abstract1374)   HTML    PDF(pc) (793KB)(486)       Save

    The thematic relationship between knowledge and power is of great importance through the whole of Foucault's theoretical thought. Thus his interpretation of the Greek tragedy Oedipus the King should not be neglected, because it can be treated as a supplement to his early writing on this "knowledge-power" relationship. In his analysis of Oedipus the King, Foucault introduces the concept of will to know. Through that concept, he attempts to replace the traditional causal chain, which is prima facie natural, between knowledge and the will to know, with a more complicated relationship between knowledge and power so as to account for the birth of modern systematized institutions of true discourse. Foucault's begins his own interpretation with a critique of Freud. He argues that, though Freud's psychological interpretation of Oedipus the King breaks off the traditional understanding of universal form of desire, it has overvalued the status of sexuality in human culture. On the contrary, what Oedipus the King exactly shows, according to Foucault, is the manifestation of truth and the operation of power institutions in discursive knowledge. Foucault establishes his "Oedipal Knowledge" in three levels. On the first level, the Oedipus fable reveals how some certain types of self-knowledge come into being, and how these different types of knowledge confront each other and finally fit together. On the second level, the Oedipus complex is not about sex, but the complicated interweaving of power-knowledge relation linked with Oedipus's identity:he is both at the same time a king, a criminal and incestuous. On the third and the last, the fable manifests a particular kind of juridical form of truth which originated in ancient times, and figures out how this juridical form of knowledge operates in the modern. Finally, I argue that Foucault's multi-level analysis of Oedipus the King suggests a transition of his research interest, which shifts from investigations of specific institutions of power to ancient thoughts on power.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    College Major Choice and Gender Difference in Entering Male-Dominated Occupations: Evidence from Beijing College Student Panel Survey
    HE Guangye
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (2): 213-241.  
    Abstract1376)   HTML    PDF(pc) (876KB)(656)       Save

    The 1990s has witnessed a dramatic expansion in Chinese higher education. Educational gender gap converges over time,and moreover,with respect to college enrollment,young women have even surpassed men nowadays. Horizontal stratification in education becomes far more substantial in understanding gender inequality in China's urban labor market. Drawing the data from Beijing College Student Panel Survey(BCSPS),this research attempts to investigate distribution pattern of college majors between men and women,and how the gender differences in majors have led to the gender differences in entering male-dominated occupations. Results have shown a great gender disparity in college majors. Men are over-represented in the subjects such as,science and engineering,whereas women are concentrated in literature,history and arts. The differences in major choices can largely explain the gender differences in the attainment of first occupation,especially the chances of entering male-dominated occupations. Compared with men,women are less likely to enter male-dominated occupations. However,after controlling for college majors,women's disadvantages are largely decreased. The non-linear Blinder-Oaxaca decomposition results further suggest that if men and women have the same major distribution,gender difference in entering male-dominated occupations would decrease by 40%~50%. Thus,gender differences in college major provide one potential explanation for the persisting occupational gender segregation among the highly educated in China's urban labor market.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (2): 242-.  
    Abstract468)   HTML    PDF(pc) (28143KB)(139)       Save
    Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Stratified Mobility in Chinese Bureaucracy: A Model and Empirical Evidence
    ZHOU Xueguang, AI Yun, GE Jianhua, GU Huijun, LI Lan, LU Qinglian, ZHAO Wei, ZHU Ling
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (3): 1-45.  
    Abstract2096)   HTML    PDF(pc) (5046KB)(950)       Save

    Spatial mobility among officials has been an important mechanism of political control in China's governance. We propose a model of stratified mobility across administrative jurisdictions to explain patterns of spatial mobility in the Chinese bureaucracy, and develop related concepts, typologies, and measures for our empirical analyses. We illustrate our theoretical arguments using empirical findings of spatial mobility in a large bureaucracy-local governments in one province of China, from 1990 to 2008. This research contributes to the study of the Chinese bureaucracy by (1) providing baselines for the key empirical patterns of mobility among offices and across administrative levels; (2) developing a set of concepts, categories and related measurements for characterizing social network structures resulting from personnel flow across government offices.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    The Paradox of Technical Governance: A Public Opinion Survey's Political Process and Its Results
    PENG Yaping
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (3): 46-78.  
    Abstract1159)   HTML    PDF(pc) (994KB)(547)       Save

    The logic of technical governance goes as follows:the knowledge of society can be obtained by the state via technology and thus social problems are identified and resolution are found. Questions have been raised about whether technical governance would ever work. For many the answer is negative and doubtful. However,one defense remains:technical governance fails not because the idea is inherently flawed but because the technology is not good. Would technical governance succeed with better methodology and more technical rigor? In order to challenge this defense,this paper examines the operation of opinion polls-a form of technical governance supported by rigorous quantitative social research methodology-run by a sub-district government in the city "S". In particular,this paper asks whether it is possible for a government-run poll to reflect manipulated public opinions,despite the strictest compliance with quantitative polling methodology. The finding of this paper gives an affirmative answer. It argues that on the surface polls are statistic surveys but in actuality they are a political process controlled by the government despite their compliance with all statistical requirements. The power structure of the local government determines the questionnaire questions and their multiple-choice answers (the screening,compressing and quantifying of social scenarios),and the final make-up of public opinion index. The rigorousness of methodology does not guarantee the authenticity of "public opinion" in final poll figures. More likely the outcome is controlled by those who organize polls. Hence,quantifiable technical governance presents contradiction:the state manufactures biased public opinions precisely when it is looking for unbiased public opinions. In the end,the government constructs an image of society in its own reflection.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Multi-Process and Outcome Stratification: On the Equality of the Chinese University Schooling Process
    LI Ding
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (3): 79-104.  
    Abstract1265)   HTML    PDF(pc) (751KB)(516)       Save

    Chinese universities and college students have become increasingly differentiated. How do socioeconomic backgrounds affect student performance in school and outcomes after graduation? Based on data from the Beijing College Students Panel Survey (BCSPS), this paper examines the differences in schooling processes and outcomes among Chinese college students of different social origins. Results show that while students from rural and urban origins do not differ in academic performance,extra-curricular activities, and psychological traits, there are marked differences in cultural capital, expectations after graduation, and actual outcomes. Such differences vary by school types. While family economic capital benefits students from non-211 universities more than students from 211 universities in terms of school performance, family cultural capital seems to play an important role in affecting subjective wellbeing among students in 211 universities. As for placement after graduation, whether or not students continue domestic postgraduate education is determined primarily by students' academic and non-academic performance in school, however, family economic and cultural resources affect the likelihood of pursuing postgraduate degrees abroad. The boom of students studying abroad and their subsequent return home have profound implications on the equality of higher education and social stratification in contemporary China.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Gendered Pathways to Rural-to-Urban Hukou Conversion and Income Returns in Mainland China: An Analysis Based on CGSS2008-2013 Data
    GUO Wei, LU Jiaying
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (3): 105-135.  
    Abstract863)   HTML    PDF(pc) (1095KB)(339)       Save

    This study is a quantitative investigation of gendered pathways to rural-to-urban hukou conversion and income return using the Heckman selection model and multiple regression analysis with interaction terms based on the data from the CGSS(2008-2013). It attempts to help further understand the context of the ongoing household registration system reform in China. We use the 2008 purchasing power as a standardized measure for this study. The results indicate that men achieve the rural to urban hukou transition mainly through selective mobility tools such as education and job recruitment,while women depend more on policy programs such as land resettlement and marriage. However,the proportion of rural women who obtain urban hukou through selective mobility means increased significantly since China's reform. As for the income return of rural-urban hukou conversion,the study shows that within the group of conversion by selective mobility means,women score higher than men. In addition,the income return effect of rural-urban hukou conversion declines as time passes. A significant decline is especially noticed for men as the household registration reform deepens. Our study provides a systematic analysis of quantitative results through the lens of gender role changes in the modernization process of China,and discusses difficulties and potential conflicts facing the future reform of the Chinese household registration system.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    The Deconstruction of the Classical Family and the Sanctification of Marriage: Augustine's New Construction of the Basic Unit of the Society
    FENG Xiaomang
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (3): 136-169.  
    Abstract929)   HTML    PDF(pc) (879KB)(265)       Save

    Family, which is a construction based on and controlled by natural powers in the ancient times, is the basic unit of classical society. From the point of view of Christianity, Augustine dissociates the individual from secular communities and restores him to a purely spiritual entity, so as to establish a starting point for the Christian model of society. Meanwhile, the classical family, as the basic organizational form of community, is deconstructed by Augustine through denaturing its natural power. Augustine denies the virtuous and ultimate meaning of any secular communities. As a result, Augustine understands human society, in the framework of Christianity, as a "societas" based on the principle of equality and love. In this metaphysical society, marriage is established and sanctified on the same principle of equality and love, and so the hallowed marriage contract becomes the smallest basic organizational form of human society, instead of family in ancient times. Augustine thus creates a brand new model of society based on the marriage contract as its basic unit. Although this new model occupied the dominant position in medieval Europe, it has always had an inner tension between the ideal and the reality. With the collapse of Feudalism and Catholicism, this model began to disintegrate, but the principle of equality, love and contract remains. The Renaissance, the Reformation and the Enlightenment together emancipated the individual from the religious community and established the modern idea of individual as capable and deserving of "liberty and reason". On this basis, modern thinkers such as Hobbes and Hegel introduced the principle of equality, love and marriage contract as the organizational logic of the family, and then of the society. By this way, modern thinkers form a complete chain that starts from the atomic individual and ends with the whole of society so as to establish an entirely new pattern for the organization of human society. The family of this new type i.e., the "core family" based on the marriage system as T nnies and Durkheim suggest, becomes the basic unit of modern society.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Buddhist Temples and Ancestral Halls: The Reconstruction of Tusi's Ritual in Western Yunnan
    LIAN Ruizhi
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (3): 170-202.  
    Abstract1022)   HTML    PDF(pc) (1477KB)(182)       Save

    In imperial China, abolishing tusi (native official) offices was always justified as retaliation for disobeying the orthodoxy of the Chinese state. For example, in the early Ming period, the Heqing tusi was abolished and the chieftaincy's domain put under imperial official's direct control following such a false accusation. Next, the imperial officials constructed Confucian schools and sought to restrict Buddhist temples and beliefs, and advocated orthodox ritual among the local elite by prohibiting heterodox temples and encouraging them to revise their history. At the same time, some tusi consciously engaged in the work of establish their own proper rituals based on the Canonized Chinese Classics. In this paper, I focus on two cases, the tusis of Lijiang and Monghua, discussing how native officials rebuilt their rituals according to the standards set for the feudal lords of ancient China and utilized three strategies to declare their noble status in the eyes of the Chinese state. The first strategy was building a patrilineal ancestral hall. Second, to strengthen their superiority, they constructed written genealogies which included an origin myth and common ancestor, connecting legendary ancestors to the inherited tusi title. Third, under the feudal political system, they legitimized and promoted Buddhist temples as historical heritage to ensure claims to their territory. In Lijiang tusi's case, the paper explains the making of written genealogy not only confirmed Mu tusi's leading position among tribal society by transcript oral mythical figure into ancestor, but also legitimizing their alliance with Guzhong and Bai politics according to their brotherhood-originated story. At the same time, they built an ancestral hall as a legal institution to claim their status as Chinese ancient feudal lord, which implied they could rule their territory properly. In the other case, Monghua tusi was under maternal alliance's support, tracing their ancestor to Nanchao King. As they became the descendant of ancient king, they renovated ancient Buddhist temples and took over inherited ritual status in the native society. Through these arrangements, we can clearly observe the tusi, as the agent in border area, was able to take advantage of their historical capital to consolidate their local interests.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Three Faces of the Online Leftists: An Exploratory Study Based on Case Observation and Big Data Analysis
    GUI Yong, HUANG Ronggui, DING Yi
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (3): 203-239.  
    Abstract2000)   HTML    PDF(pc) (1955KB)(612)       Save

    Leftist social thought is not a unitary and coherent system of thought and left-wingers are made up of divergent groups. In this study, we propose a theoretical typology of two dimensions of theoretical resource and ideological orientation to analyze left-wing social thought in online space. A combination of case observations and big data analyses of Weibo tweets is applied to investigate the three types of leftist social thought online, identified as state-centered leftism, populist leftism, and liberal leftism. State-centered leftism features a strong support of the state and the current regime and a negative attitude towards the West. Populist leftism is characterized by the unequivocal affirmation of revolutionary legacies and support of grassroots movements for disadvantaged population. Liberal leftism maintains a grassroots position and a decided affirmation of individual rights. In addition, supervised machine learning and social network analysis techniques are used to identify online communities of the three types of leftist social thought and analyze the interaction patterns within and across the communities as well as the evolution of community structures. This study found that during the period of 2012-2014,the camp of liberal leftist gradually decreased in numbers and the corresponding communities dissolved while the interaction between populist leftist and state-centered leftist camps intensified and the opinion differences between the two increased online confrontations. This article demonstrates that the mixed approach of combining traditional methods with big data analysis has enormous potential in the sub-discipline of digital sociology.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (3): 242-.  
    Abstract546)   HTML    PDF(pc) (19205KB)(122)       Save
    Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Between Nations and the World: Marcel Mauss's Conceptualization of Civilization and Envisioning of Human Science
    WANG Mingming
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (4): 1-53.  
    Abstract1121)   HTML    PDF(pc) (1170KB)(195)       Save

    Between 1913 and 1930, Marcel Mauss worked to re-define civilizations in terms of material, institutional, and spiritual entities and moral vitalities between the nations and the world. This paper makes an inquiry of the historical origin of Mauss's project, its intellectual and political pertinence, as well as its contemporary implications. Mauss's project of human science of civilizations was envisaged during the time of rupture between the two world wars, a period of tensions and self-contradictory syntheses between the rationalist notions of civilization and the nationalist notions of culture. The former was founded upon both religious and scientific bases and the latter took extremism in the late 19th century. The struggle of the two caused serious problems in Europe as well as other parts of the world. In his study of the "phenomena of civilization," Mauss conceptualized civilization as the in-between hyper-social spaces between the national borders. He examined the forms and geographic patterns of the spread of the phenomena and argued that for human science-in particular, ethnology and sociology-to be truer to societies and cultures, such phenomena should be systematically studied sociologically. Mauss also believed that a holistic human science would not be possible unless such civilizational phenomena were taken into account by the sociologist. Critiquing the existing territorial boundedness of sociology and the ethical indifference of ethnology, Mauss insisted on the combination of the two subjects-the ethnological sociology of the hyper-sociality, or "moral miliu" of the relation between societies. This study argues that what Mauss envisaged a century ago is still relevant to today's world. Considering that social sciences (including the post-war American sciences of "area studies") today are often constrained by the division of "specialized" and "general" fields, it is important to renew Mauss's open mindedness to see civilizations as the "intermediaries" of social existence encompassing a certain number of nations, each national culture being only a form of the whole.The introductory section here reflects on the dominance of the model of "the world of the nations" in social science, which has resulted in the unfortunate disremembering of Durkheimian sociology of civilizations. It follows with the discussion of the subject of civilizations in the life and work of Mauss. The core parts of this study outline the history of the nationalization and civilization of Annee Sociologique, offer a review of Mauss's critique of nationalism and narratives of civilization, as well as a summary of his models of forms, contents, and regions of civilizations. In the concluding remarks, the discussion of Annee Sociologique on civilizations is related to the early 20th century Chinese intellectual thinking regarding national polities and cosmopolitanism.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Buddha-King versus Emperor: Ethnic Mobilization among Mountain Communities and the Decline of Silver Mining Industry in the Yunnan and Burma Border Region
    MA Jianxiong
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (4): 54-99.  
    Abstract838)   HTML    PDF(pc) (1172KB)(123)       Save

    The development of silver mining industry between the Mekong River and the Salween River in the Yunnan and Burma border region and the political conflict between Qing and Burma gradually weakened native chieftains since the 17th century. The newly emerged Buddhist master Monk Tongjin exploited the secret societies of miners and the merchant network amongst mines and salt markets to seek his political rise between officials and chieftains in the mountainous area. The silver mining industry in the region began before the 16th century and peaked in the 18th century,and then declined in the early 19th century. The wars between Qing and Burma (1762-1769) bankrupted the local government in Yunnan because of the burden of transporting logistics for the war. To deal with the crisis by tightening local salt revenue,Emperor Jiaqing reign (1796-1820) made the salt trade,an important ingredient in silver smelting,between salt wells and the mines illegal,causing a jump in cost of silver production and eventually the demise of the silver mining industry. Depressed economy brought the expansion of secret societies among laid-off miners and affected villagers in the mountainous region. Monk Tongjin and his fellows became the core leadership that helped to reconstruct a new political institution to challenge the neighboring chieftains and county officials.Threatened by the movement,Emperor Jiaqing ordered the elimination of Monk Tongjin. This paper reviews historical events that led to the rise of Monk Tongjin as a Buddha-King among his people and a collaborator to local officials,but seen as a political threat by the emperor.It examines the relationship between the new political institution and its social agency with the states. In addition,the relationship between the stretch and limitation of the Qing imperial state on the frontier and the construction of ethnic identity of the Lahu is also investigated.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Why Has Social Work Moved Towards “De-Social Reform”? An Analysis of a Hundred Years' History of American Social Work
    LI Wei
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (4): 100-132.  
    Abstract1019)   HTML    PDF(pc) (1192KB)(183)       Save

    Social work always insists on the person-in-environment perspective, in which both client and environment are the goals of intervention.In other words, individual therapy and social reform are dual missions of social work and they should be equally important to the profession. However, in practice, social work field suffers so-called "de-social reform,"a phenomenon that individual services are accentuated and social reform agenda isneglected. A combination of internal factors such as professionalization of social work and external factors such as political conservatism, economic marketization and managerialism, and cultural individualism is responsible for the "de-social reform."These elements promote scientism, social control, profit and efficiency, and individual freedom and responsibility.As a result, social change is regarded as unscientific, risky to government, unprofitable, inefficient and inconsistent with individualism. America saw the prevalence of these elements and "de-social reform" in the 1920s, between the middle 1930s and the 1960s, as well as in the 1980s. It should be understood that "de-social reform" in social work is the product of these external factors, among which individualism plays a leading role.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    The Dilemma of Social Service in the Context of Transitional Governance in China: The Case Study of Social Work Service in Z City
    HUANG Xiaoxing, XIONG Huiling
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (4): 133-159.  
    Abstract730)   HTML    PDF(pc) (764KB)(196)       Save

    The development of social work has been an important part of social governance in the last ten years. Since its reintroduction in 1986, social work as a new profession has gone through a comprehensive development and today it is institutionalized in the governance system in China. Researches on social services in China are short of in-depth analysis of the service delivery process by social service organizations and the dilemma they encounter. Based on the case study of social service organizations in Z city, this paper introduces the concept of transitional governance and offers a comparison between the Chinese social work service and its Western counterparts through analyzing the dilemma between social service organizations' professional position and their social position in the communities. Social service is seen in the West as a "Third-Party Government" of government-nonprofit partnership in the face of government, market and voluntary failures. Western nonprofit organizations demonstrate great capacity to meet human needs, and the civil society is independent from the state. In China, social services are experimental, locally managed and risk-prevention focused. This, as the paper argues, caused the negative discretion and semi-professionalism in Chinese social services, leading to the tactics of "community activities" and "quota-filling," and dissatisfaction among providers and recipients. Such a quandary should be dealt with in a cooperative governance environment, under which local professional social workers are strengthened and the efficiency of third party social service delivery is enhanced.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Disability as Capability Limitation: Review and Reflection on the Existing Models of Disability Study
    YU Lian
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (4): 160-179.  
    Abstract897)   HTML    PDF(pc) (616KB)(196)       Save

    The discipline of disabilities studies has gone through a line of Personal Model to Medical Model to Social Model. All three models place their focus on the causes of disabilities and view them as the core of disabilities. Such a limitation reflects the conventional thought mode of cause-impact and can lead to stereotypes and labeling of disabled people. Researchers like Tom Shakespeare criticize the Social Model for its rigid dichotomy of impairment (bodily difference) and disability (social creation),as well as its dichotomy of social exclusion and social inclusion. This paper suggests that understanding the disability by focusing on impacts than on causes is a better approach. The capabilities approach frees us from competing claims on the causes of disabilities and channels our attention to capabilities and potentials of the person in a personal,ever-changing and holistic environment. This approach examines the abilities of an individual,not a labeled group,to tackle specific elements that make a situation disabling for a given person. Thus,the approach gives us a precise model of disabilities and a possibility to achieve a more comprehensive and effective response to the disabled.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Social Constitution of Recognition
    CHENG Tsuo
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (4): 180-211.  
    Abstract811)   HTML    PDF(pc) (958KB)(116)       Save

    Axel Honneth's theory of recognition plays a significant role in today's social theories. However, while theorizing the concept of recognition, Honneth neglects the category of social interaction as an important theoretical link. Due to this deficiency, the concept of recognition lacks a clear definition and as social theory it cannot be easily applied to sociological studies. This paper attempts to gain a better understanding of recognition theory by examining the origin of social interaction. It is suggested here that the concept of recognition can be sociologically defined as a reciprocally supportive interaction based on similar or commonly acceptable ideas and behaviors. Under this definition, Honneth's three forms of recognition are to be reformulated accordingly. Firstly, there is only one form of recognition defined as a reciprocally supportive social interaction, however, in different social spheres there are corresponding generalized symbolic mediums of social interaction such as love, law and social esteem, as well as money, power and religious belief etc. to generate possibility of recognition. Secondly, contempt (Mißachtung) is not an opposite form of recognition but a mean of anti-mediums that harms recognition. Thirdly, recognition can also be distorted by problematic mis-recognition. With the sociological reformulation, recognition theory might be able to provide an appropriate and distinct perspective for sociology.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    The Influencing Factors and Mechanism of Environmental Risk Perception: A Study on Public Nuclear Risk Perception
    WANG Gang, SONG Kaiye
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (4): 212-240.  
    Abstract847)   HTML    PDF(pc) (1486KB)(133)       Save

    Paying attention to the factors that affect the perception of environmental risks is not only an urgent need for effective environmental risk management but also a leading issue vital to social governance. This study puts forward a hypothesis of two-factor theory about public environmental risk perception and validates the hypothesis through quantitative research. Grounded theory is applied toidentify four dimensions that influence public environmental risk perception:environmental affinity, system trust, information richness and interest orientation. The first two deal with emotional factors and the latter two situational factors. These factors are quantitatively examined by using the structural equation model to determine whetherthey have a significant impact on the public environmental risk perception. The study yieldssome interesting findings. First, the four emotional and situational factors all affect environmental risk perception.Second, the impact of environmental affinity on public environmental risk perception is weak and its effect is often related to the environmental concerns of individuals.Third, system trust has a strong negative impact on environmental risk perception.Fourth, the correlation between information richness and environmental risk perception is not significant, however, once revised as "highly relevant," the impact of information richness on environmental risk perception becomes a nonlinear correlation, exercising strong influence on public environmental risk perception.Fifth, the recognition of self-interest is the decisive factor affecting public environmental risk perception.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (4): 242-.  
    Abstract500)   HTML    PDF(pc) (13604KB)(173)       Save
    Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Lost on the Bridge of Money: Simmel on Money and Experience of Modernity
    LI Lingjing
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (5): 1-40.  
    Abstract1102)   HTML    PDF(pc) (936KB)(201)       Save

    The emphasis on the survival experience of modern individuals is an important feature of Simmel's thought on modernity. This, apart from continuing the tradition of aesthetic modernity and being influenced by “the mood of fin-de-siecle”, is very much related to Simmel's unique sociological interest. The maturity of monetary economy constitutes the historical root of our modernity experience. With the increasing dominance of monetary economy in modern society, money becomes part of human psyche, influences the behaviors of modern individuals and creates a unique experience of modernity. It can be said that the process of money becoming “Money” is the process that modern individuals acquire their modernity experience. Money plays the role of God in modern society, elevated from “absolute means” to “absolute purpose”. It erases the differences between objects, among people, and between people and objects. According to the Money logic, modern people can be readily labeled such as the greedy, the avaricious, the extravagant or the ascetic poverty, living in a state of cynicism or blasé.For urban life is the typical experience of modernity, urban people are “Unhappy Dwellers”. Their blasé attitude constitutes the core of the unhappiness of modern people. However, in the experience of adventurer and stranger, it is possible for modern individuals to maintain their unique personality and resist the logic of Money. Through money, Simmel reveals not only the plight of modern people but also the ultimate value of human being.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    “Vergesellschaftung” of Modern Life
    JI Yanru
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (5): 41-69.  
    Abstract1300)   HTML    PDF(pc) (786KB)(200)       Save

    For neo-Kantian sociologist Georg Simmel, the principal task of sociology is to answer the question of “how is society possible?”, a reference to Kant's question of “what is nature possible”. This paper explores Simmel's preoccupation with the problem of unity in modern fragmentary individuality. In examining how individuals interact with the surrounding modern world and form self-images, Simmel, in a Kantian tradition, views the world as representation of the subject and hence the subject matter of sociology shall be forms of socialization, or the so-called “formal sociology”. However, his sociological and philosophical inquiries not only go beyond the conventional Kantian understanding of forms but also repudiate Kant's intellectualistic outlook. The diverging point is that for Simmel, rather than rational cognition, “being” is of paramount importance. Influenced by Goethe's life and work, Simmel develops a life philosophy that converges the dichotomy between life and form, and between noumena and phenomena. His approach resides somewhere in between Kantian and Goethean worldview, providing a possibility for modern individuality to form profound bounds with the world yet to avoid being estranged by forms. This essay argues that Simmel's concept of life, i.e. the Individual Law demands the deepest unity of life and form to reconcile the dichotomy between the subjective and the external, and thus to overcome the strangeness and fragmentation of modern condition.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Party, Politics and Policy: The Multi-Logic of “Rich Peasants Problem” in the Early CCP Revolution
    MENG Qingyan
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (5): 70-105.  
    Abstract963)   HTML    PDF(pc) (955KB)(154)       Save

    “Rich Peasants” (Funong) is an important concept of class analysis of rural China during the early stage of the Chinese Communist Revolution. It is also a focal point of policy debates and shifts during the Land Reform. The Communist Party pivoted on the concept in its adaptation of Marxist and Leninist ideology for dealing with rural crisis in modern China. This article argues that, under specific local reality of complication and conflicts, the concept became “indigenized” and thus had the following implications:First, Funong transformed itself from an ideological concept in theory into a concrete target of revolution; second, it was also entangled with the struggles of the Communist Party and was later named as the “Route of Rich Peasants” for certain policy practice in the early revolution; third, the definition of “Rich Peasants” and the land policy based on it caused major policy problems during the land reform in the Soviet Areas. These three aspects together constituted a unique revolutionary power mechanism. By reviewing a large amount of historical materials from various sources, this study presents a detailed discussion of the complex historical process of “Rich Peasant” from concept to practice, identifying the internal connection between “Rich Peasants” and “local elites” from multiple perspectives of social history, political history and historical sociology and explaining the inner logic and social process of the concept as a revolutionary power mechanism.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    Civil and Military Examination Participation of the Que Lineage in Shicang Village in Qing Dynasty
    JIANG Qin
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (5): 106-125.  
    Abstract915)   HTML    PDF(pc) (1063KB)(140)       Save

    The literature on social stratification and mobility reveals that tracking is an important source of educational inequality. The imperial examination system in Ming and Qing China was structured with two tracks of civil (wen) and military (wu) exams. Most of the existing studies focused on the provincial and metropolitan levels of the system and little attention is paid to the lowest county level of shengyuan exam,-the starting point of the wen and wu tracking. This study looks into the accounts of the imperial participation in Shicang village in Songyang county, Zhejiang during Qing, specifically the examination records of the Que lineage. With a fortune made from iron business, the Ques purchased a studentship in imperial academy (jiansheng), and later married into local gentry families and began to participate in imperial exams. The Taiping rebellion brought high mortality to the region and thus increased the chance of success in the imperial wu tracking military exam. The Ques made the use of the opportunity and participated in both civil and military exams. This paper compares the two common motivations of examination takers:either for protecting family wealth and status or for pursuing the highest degree. It is shown that the two motivations resulted in quite different outcomes. Those who only interested in safeguarding and enhancing family wealth were able to keep a balance between degree pursue and family business, while those who aiming at the highest degree often fell into a trap of repeated attempts and an eventual bankruptcy. The dominance of the first motivation among ordinary Chinese demonstrates the self-adjustment of local society to the imperial examination tracking system.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0
    How to Measure Chinese Religiosity in a Social Survey?
    ZHANG Chunni, LU Yunfeng
    Chinese Journal of Sociology    2018, 38 (5): 126-157.  
    Abstract1190)   HTML    PDF(pc) (814KB)(189)       Save

    The debate on Chinese religiosity is not just a theoretical but also an empirical issue. Social survey as a standard and widely-applied way of data collection depicts a picture of Chinese religious landscape rather very differently from the field observation by social anthropologists. This raises the question of the validity of survey measurement on Chinese religiosity. How accurate can conventional social survey method measure Chinese people's religious beliefs and practices? Unlike in Western societies,Chinese religion has traditionally been non-congregational,non-exclusive,and infused. As a result,survey instruments based on denominational affiliation for measuring western religiosity become less valid when applied in China. To tackle this issue,we utilize three waves of longitudinal data from China Family Panel Studies (CFPS) and rephrase religious affiliation questions in various ways,as well as compare and evaluate questionnaires on religious affiliation,practice,and membership from different waves of the survey and from other survey projects. By demonstrating that changes in questionnaire items can noticeably alter survey outcomes,we argue that the standard Western survey method on religiosity fails to capture the unique Chinese understanding of religion. An alternative way of social survey on Chinese religiosity is therefore proposed.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics | Comments0