自我组织与遵纪守法：工人依法维权的集体行动策略——以上海SNS企业工人抗争为例

Abstract

Abstract: In the Chinese institutional context， workers must weigh economic costs and political risks when fighting for their legal rights； thus， they have to come up with some “safe”， “effective”， and “sustainable” protesting means． This paper analyzes two rightdefending events by the workers in a manufacturing enterprise in Shanghai． The workers’ “selforganizing” and “law abiding” strategies not only provided them with organizational protection but also the legitimacy of action． The paper concludes with a discussion of this kind of protest strategies with the background of macrolevel social transition in China．

Key words: defending rights according to the law , selforganizing , observing the law and regulations , protest strategies

Wu Tong；Wen Jun，.
SelfOrganizing and Law Abiding： Workers’ Collective Action Strategies to Defend Rights： A Case Study of Enterprise SNS in Shanghai[J]. Chinese Journal of Sociology, 2010, 30(5): 121-141.

References

参考文献（References）
Chan， Anita and Hongzen， Wang． 2004/2005． “The Impact of the State on Workers’ Conditions： Comparing Taiwanese Factories in China and Vietnam．” Pacific Affairs （77）．

Chan， Anita and Hongzen，Wang．2006． “Organizing WalMart： The Chinese Trade Union at a Crossroads．” Japan Focus． http：∥www．japanfocus．org/products/details/2217．

常凯． 2002．论罢工权立法［G］∥全球化与劳动权益和劳工政策国际研讨会论文集．［Chang Kai． 2002． “On Legislation of the Right to Strike．” in Collected Papers of the International Workshop on the Globalization， Labour Rights and Labour Policies．］

Chen， Feng〖KG-*9〗． 2000． “Subsistence Crisis， Managerial Corruption and Labor Protest in China．” The China Journal （44）．

Chen， Feng． 2003． “Industrial Restructuring and Workers’ Resistance in China．” Modern China（29）．

Chen， Feng． 2004． “Legal Mobilization by Trade Unions： the Case of Shanghai．” The China Journal （52）．

范战江．2003．中国劳动立法现状与发展［D］．香港中文大学中国研究服务中心． http：∥www．usc．cuhk．edu．hk/wk_wzdetails．asp?id=3290．［Fan Zhanjiang． 2003． “The Present Legislation Situation and Development of Labour Laws in China．” Papers on the Website of Universities Service Center for China Studies． http：∥www．usc．cuhk．edu．hk/wk_wzdetails．asp?id=3290．］

冯仕政． 2006．单位分割与集体抗争［J］．社会学研究（3）．［Feng Shizheng． 2006． “Protest Mobilization Under Danwei System in China．” Sociological Studies （3）．（in Chinese）］

郭于华． 2002． “弱者的武器”与“隐藏的文本”——研究农民反抗的底层视角［J］．读书（7）．［Guo Yuhua． 2002． “‘Weapon of the Weak’ and ‘Hidden Transcript’：the Perspective of Bottom Society on the Protests of Peasents．” Dushu （7）．（in Chinese）］

黄岩． 2008．代工产业中的劳工团结——以兴达公司员工委员会实验为例［J］．社会（4）．［Huang Yan． 2008． “Labor Solidarity in Contract Manufacturing：the Staff Committee Experiment in Xinda Company as an Example．” Society（4）．（in Chinese）］

Jenkins， J． Craig and Charles Perrow． 1977． “Insurgency of the Powerless： Farm Workers’ Movements， 1946-1972．” American Sociological Review 42．

Lee， Ching Kwan． 1998． “The Labor Politics of Market Socialism： Collective Inaction and Class Experience among State Workers in Guangzhou．”Modern China （24）1．

Lee， Ching Kwan． 1999． “From Organized Dependence to Disorganized Despotism： Changing Labour Regimes in Chinese Factories．” The China Quarterly （157）．

Lee， Ching Kwan． 2002a． “Three Patterns of WorkingClass Transitions in China．” in Francoise Mengin and JeanLouis Rocca （eds．）．Politics in China： Moving Frontiers． New York ：Palgrave Macmillan． 

Lee， Ching Kwan． 2002b． “From the Spectre of Mao to the Spirit of Law： Labor Insurgency in China．”Theory and Society （31）．

刘爱玉． 2003．国有企业制度变革过程中工人的行动选择——一项关于无集体行动的经验研究［J］．社会学研究（6）．［Liu Aiyu． 2003． “Workers’ Action Choices in the Process of Institutional Transformation of StateOwned Enterprises： An Empirical Research of Collective in Action．” Sociological Studies （6）．（in Chinese）］

刘岚．最高人民法院出台一系列应对金融危机司法意见回顾［N］．人民法院报，2009-8-17．［Liu Lan． “The Review of the Series of Advices on Financial Crisis by Supreme People’s Court．” People’s Court Daily． 17 August 2009．］

刘能． 2004．怨恨解释、动员结构和理性选择——有关中国都市地区集体行动发生可能性的分析［J］．开放时代（4）．［Liu Neng． 2004． “Interpretation of Resentment， Mobilization Structure and Rational Choice： An Analysis of the Possibility of Collective Behavior in China’s Urban Areas．” Open Times （4）．（in Chinese）］

裴宜理． 2001．上海罢工：中国工人政治研究［M］．刘平，译．南京：江苏人民出版社．［Perry， Isabelle． 2001． Shanghai on Strike， translated by Liu Ping． Nanjing： Jiangsu People’s Press．］

沈原． 2008．又一个三十年？转型社会学视野下的社会建设［J］．社会（3）．［Shen Yuan． 2008． “Another 30 Years ? The Social Construction Under the Perspective of Transformative Sociology．” Society （3）．（in Chinese）］

孙立平、郭于华． 2000．“软硬兼施”：正式权力非正式运作的过程分析——华北B镇收粮的个案研究［J］．清华社会学评论．［Sun Liping and Guo Yuhua． 2000． The Stick and the Carrot： Analyse on the Process of the Informal Functioning of Formal Power． Tsinghua Sociological Review．（in Chinese）］

Tarrow， Sidney． 1983．Struggling to Reform：Social Movements and Policy Change during Cycles of Protest． Ithaca， N．Y．： Western Societies Program， Cornell University．

佟新． 2005．能动的行动者：B企业的工会实践［G］ ∥冯同庆，主编．中国经验：转型社会的企业治理与职工民主参与．北京：社会科学文献出版社．［Tong Xin． 2005． “An Active Actor： An Enterprise Trade Union in Operation，” in Feng Tongqing （ed．），China’s Experience ： Workplace Governance and Workers Democratic Participation in Transitional Economy． Beijing： Social Science Academic Press．］

汪居扬． 2005．业主维权和社区权力结构的变迁——对社区纠纷的一项个案研究［D］．华东师范大学硕士论文．［Wang Juyang． 2005． “Safeguard the Rights of Property Owners and the Change of Community Power Structure：A Case Study of Community Dispute．” Master Thesis of East China Normal University．］

韦黎兵．一个基层工会如何与沃尔玛斗法［N］．南方周末，2008-9-17．［Wei Libin． “A Grassroots Union’s Struggle with WalMart．” Southern Weekend，2008-9-17］

吴清军． 2007．国企改制与传统产业工人的转型［D］．清华大学社会学系博士论文．［Wu Qingjun． 2007． Reform of StateOwned Enterprises and Transition of Old Industrial Workers． Sociological Dissertation of Tsinghua University．］

〖JP2〗吴清军．2008．市场转型时期国企工人的群体认同与阶级意识［J］．社会学研究（6）．［Wu Qingjun． 2008． “Workers’ Collective Identity and Class Consciousness in StateOwned Enterprises in the Times of Market Transformation．” Sociological Studies （6）．（in Chinese）］

应星． 2001．大河移民上访的故事［M］．北京：三联书店．［Ying Xing〖KG-*9〗． 2001． A Story of Shangfang in a Hydroelectric Station Area． Beijing： SDX Joint Publishing Company．］

于建嵘．2007．中国的骚乱事件和管制危机——2007年10月30日于美国加州大学伯克利分校的演讲［C］．http：∥www．chinaelections．org/NewsInfo．asp?NewsID=118361．［Yu， Jianrong． 2008． “The Riots and Crisis of Regulation in China—The Lecture in University of California–Berkeley on 30 October 2007．” http：∥www．chinaelections．org/NewsInfo．asp?NewsID=118361．］

于建嵘．2008．中国农民工的依法维权［J］．云南财经大学学报（6）．［Yu Jianrong〖KG-*9〗． 2008． “Peasant Workers in China Protecting Their Rights by Law．” Journal of Yunnan University of Financial and Economics（6）．（in Chinese）］

Yu Xiaomin． 2004． “StateIntervened Legal Activism： Case Studies of Labor Unrest at Foreign Invested Enterprises in South China．” Papers on the Website of Universities Service Center for China Studies． http：∥www．usc．cuhk．edu．hk/wk_wzdetails．asp?id=3299．

张静． 2001．利益组织化单位：企业职代会案例研究［M］．北京：社会科学文献出版社．［Zhang Jing．2001．The Unit of Organized Interests．Beijing：Social Science Academic Press．］

折晓叶． 2008．合作与非对抗性抵制——弱者的“韧武器”［J］．社会学研究（3）．［Zhe Xiaoye． 2008． “Cooperation and Unconfrontational Resistance：Tenacious Weapons of the Weak．” Sociological Studies （3）．（in Chinese）］

朱晓阳． 2005． “误读”法律与秩序建成：国有企业改制的案例研究［G］∥冯同庆，主编．中国经验：转型社会的企业治理与职工民主参与．北京：社会科学文献出版社．［Zhu Xiaoyang． 2005． “Misreading Laws and the ‘Imagined Homeland’： A Case Study of a StateOwned Factory in Transitional Economy．” in Feng Tongqin （ed．），China’s Experience： Workplace Governance and Workers Democratic Participation in Transitional Economy． Beijing： Social Science Academic Press．］
责任编辑：田青

SelfOrganizing and Law Abiding： Workers’ Collective Action Strategies to Defend Rights： A Case Study of Enterprise SNS in Shanghai

PDF

Knowledge

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

References

Related Articles 0

Recommended Articles

Metrics

Comments