行业协会的组织自主性研究——以广东省级行业协会为例

Chinese Journal of Sociology ›› 2010, Vol. 30 ›› Issue (5): 75-95.

• Articles • Previous Articles Next Articles

A Study on the Autonomy of Business Associations： ProvinceLevel Business Associations in Guangdong

Author1：Zhang Qinjie， The Department of Sociology，College of Public Management，South China Agriculture University；Author2：Wang Jianping， Department of Sociology，College of Public Management， South China Agriculture University

Author1：Zhang Qinjie， The Department of Sociology，College of Public Management，South China Agriculture University；Author2：Wang Jianping， Department of Sociology，College of Public Management， South China Agriculture University)

Online:2010-09-20 Published:2010-09-20
Contact: Author1：Zhang Qinjie， The Department of Sociology，College of Public Management，South China Agriculture University E-mail:lindalion@scau.edu.cn
About author:Author1：Zhang Qinjie， The Department of Sociology，College of Public Management，South China Agriculture University；Author2：Wang Jianping， Department of Sociology，College of Public Management， South China Agriculture University
Supported by:
This research was supported by the President Foundation of South China Agriculture University：“Study on Autonomy of the Guangdong ProvinceLevel Business Association”（7700K08003），and the “11th Fiveyear Plan” research topics of Philosophy Social Science Planning of Guangdong： “The Motivation， Influence and Balance of the RightsDefending Movement of Civic Proprietors in Pearl River Delta”（07H05）．

Abstract

Abstract:

Focusing on the provincelevel business associations in Guangdong， this study assessed the associations’ autonomy and summarized the theories of organizational autonomy and its influencing factors． The study did an empirical analysis of the influences of two variables on the autonomy of these associations： associationstate relational strength and organizational size． The first variable was found to be negatively correlated with associations’ total autonomy， tangible human resources and finance， and cognitive autonomy， but not with activity autonomy． There was no correlation between organizational size and total or specific autonomy．

Key words: business association , organizational autonomy , group relationships , organizational size , Guangdong

References

参考文献（References）

Baker， Hugh P． 1926．“Practical Problem of Trade Association， Proceedings of the Academy of Political Science in the City of New York．” Trade Associations and Business Combinations 11（4）：77-91．
Becker．Willam H． 1971．“American Wholesale Hardware Trade Associations， 1870-1900．”The Business History Review 45（2）：179-200． 
Bell， Stephen．1995． “Between the Market and the State： The Role of Australian Business Association in Public Policy．” Comparative Police 28（1）：25-53．
Brock， David M． 2003．“Autonomy of Individuals and Organizations： Towards a Strategy Research Agenda．”International Journal of Business and Economics 2（1）：57-73．
Boyd， Brian ．1990． “Corporate Linkages and Organizational Environment： A Test of the Resource Dependence Model．” Strategic Management Journal11（6）： 419-430．
Burt，Ronald S． 1980． “Autonomy in a Social Topology．” The American Journal of Sociology 85（4）：892-925．
陈健民、丘海雄．2002．广州的民间社会组织：生存与依附［M］．香港：香港中文大学．［Chan Kinman and Qiu Haixiong． 2002． NGO in Guangzhou： Survival and Dependence． HK： The Chinese University of Hong Kong．］
Compton， Wilson and Myron W． Watkins， et al． 1926． “Trade Association： Discussion．”American Economic Review． Supplement， Papers and Proceedings of the Thirtyeighth Annual Meeting of the American Economic Association 16（1）：227-239．
Coleman，W． D． 1985． “Analyzing the Associative Action of Businesses： Policy Advocacy and Policy Participation．” Canadian Public Administration（28）：413-433．
Coleman， W．D．1990． “State Traditions and Comprehensive Business Associations： A Comparative Structural Analysis．” Political Studies （38）：231-252．
Crittenden， Jack． 1993． “The Social Nature of Autonomy．” The Review of Politics 55（1）：35-65．
Cook， K． S． 1977． “Exchange and Power in Networks of Interorganizational Relations．” The Sociological Quarterly 18：62-82．
Christensen， J．1999． “Bureaucratic Autonomy as A Political Asset．” Presented at the workshop “Politicians， Bureaucrats， and Institutional Reform．” ECPR Joint Sessions of Workshops， Mannheim：26-31．
邓正来、J．C．亚历山大，编．2002．国家与市民社会．北京：中央编译出版社．［Deng Zhenglai and J．C． Alexander （edited）．2002．State and Civil Society． Beijing： Central Compilation & Translation Press．］ 
Doner Richard， F． and Ben Ross Schneider． 2000． “Business Association and Economic Development： Why Some Associations Contribute More than Others？” Business and Politics 2（3）：261〖CD*2〗288．
Gilardi， Fabrizio．2002．“Policy Credibility and Delegation to Independent Regulatory Agencies：A Comparative Empirical Analysis．”Journal of European Public Policy 9（6）：873-893．
Greif， Avner． 1994． “Cultural Beliefs and the Organization of Society： A Historical and Theoretical Reflection on Collectivist and Individualist Societies．” Journal of Political Economy102（5）： 912-950．
Greif， Avner，Paul Milegrom， and Barry R． Weingast． 1994． “Coordination， Commitment and Enforcement： The Case of the Merchant Gild．” Journal of Political Economy 102（4）：745-776．
杰克布斯，布鲁斯．J． 2004．中国政治联盟特殊关系的初步模式：台湾乡镇中的人情和关系［G］∥ 面子：中国人的权力游戏．黄光国，著．北京：中国人民大学出版社．［Jacobs， Bruce J．2004． “A Preliminary Model of Particularistic Ties in Chinese Political Alliances： Kanching and Kuanhis in a Rural Taiwanese Township．”from Face ： Power Game of Chinese People． by Hwang kwangkuo． Beijing： China Renmin University Press．］
McMillan， John and Christopher Woodruff． 2000． “Private Order under Dysfunctional Public Order．” Michigan Law Review98（8）：2421-2458．
Jones， Franklin D．1919．“The Trade Association as a Factor in Reconstruction， Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science．” Industries in Readjustment 82：159〖CD*2〗169．
Koen， Verhoest， B． Guy Peters， Geert Bouckaert， and Bram verschuere． 2004． “The Study of Organizational Autonomy： A Conceptual Review．” Public Administration． Dev． 24：101-118．
Oliver，Christine． 1991． “Network Relations and Loss of Organizational Autonomy．”Human Relations 44（9）：943-961．
Provan， K．G． 1982． “InterOrganizational Linkages and Influence over Decisions．” Academy of Management Journa 25（2）：443-451．
Pfeffer， J． and G． Salancik． 1978．The External Control of Organizations： A Resource Dependence Perspective． New York： Harper & Row：47，48，94．
PerezAleman， Paola ．2003． “A LearningCentered View of Business Associations： Building BusinessGovernment Relations for Development．” Business and Politics 5（2）：193-213．
Rademakers， Martyn F． L． 2000． “Agents of Trust： Business Associations in AgriFood Supply Systems．” International Food and Agribusiness Management Review． Issue 3：139-153．
harfman， I．L． 1926． “The Trade Association Movement．” The American Economic Review， Supplement， Papers and Proceedings of the Thirtyeighth Annual Meeting of the American Economic Association 16（1）：203-218．
Simpson， Richard L．1955．“Review Author［s］，Conflict and the Web of Group Affiliations： Kurt H． Wolff， Reinhard Bendix， Georg Simmel．” Social Forces 34（2）：183-184．
Streeck，W． and Philippe C． Schmitter． 1985．“Community， Market， State and Associations? The Prospective Contribution of Interest Governance to Social Order．” European Sociological Review 1（2）： 119-138． 
王毅、折晓叶、孙炳耀．1993．社会中间层——改革与中国的社团组织［M］．北京：中国发展出版社．［Wang Yi， Zhe Xiaoye， and Sun Bingyao．1993．Social Intermediate Level． Beijing： China Development Press：71-75．］
韦伯，马克斯．［1921］1997．经济与社会（上）［M］．林荣远，译，北京：商务印书馆．［Weber， Max． 1997．Economy and Society， translated by Lin Rongyuan． Beijing： The Commercial Press．］
余晖．2002．协会及其在中国的发展：理论与案例［M］．北京：经济管理出版社．［Yu Hui．2002．Trade Associations and their Development in China： Theory and Cases． Beijing： Economy and Management Press．］
张沁洁．2007．参与合作：行业协会的运作逻辑［J］．广州：广东社会科学（2）．［Zhang Qinjie．2007． “Participation and Cooperation is the Operation Logic of Trade Associations．” Guangzhou： Guangdong Social Sciences（2）．（in chinese）］

责任编辑：李聆

A Study on the Autonomy of Business Associations： ProvinceLevel Business Associations in Guangdong

PDF

Knowledge

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

References

Related Articles 0

Recommended Articles

Metrics

Comments