The Action Logic of ValueOriented Collective Action: A Case Analysis of the SS Incident
Zhang Jinghong,Department of Sociology,Peking University;School of Philosophy,Zhongnan University of Economics and Law
Zhang Jinghong,Department of Sociology,Peking University;School of Philosophy,Zhongnan University of Economics and Law
Online:2011-03-21
Published:2011-03-21
Contact:
Zhang Jinghong,Department of Sociology,Peking University;School of Philosophy,Zhongnan University of Economics and Law
E-mail:zhangjinghong.good@gmail.com
About author:Zhang Jinghong,Department of Sociology,Peking University;School of Philosophy,Zhongnan University of Economics and Law
Supported by:
Project supported by Humanities and Social Sciences Fund of Ministry of Education: Research of the ValueOrientation Collective Action in China [10YJC810057].
Bernstein, Thomas P. and Xiaobo Lü. 2003. 〖WTB4X〗Taxation Without Representation in Contemporary Rural China〖WTB4〗. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Blumer, Herbert. 1946. “Elementary Collective Behavior.” In 〖WTB4X〗New Outline of the Principles of Sociology〖WTB4〗, edited by Alfred McClung Lee New York: Free Press.
Cai, Yongshun. 2003. “Collective Ownership or Cadres’ Ownership? The NonAgricultural Use of Farmland in China.” The China Quarterly (175): 662〖CD*2〗680.
Chen Feng. 2006. “Privatization and Its Discontents in Chinese Factories.” 〖WTB4X〗The China Quarterly〖WTB4〗 185: 42〖CD*2〗60.
陈鹏. 2010. 当代中国城市业主的法权抗争——关于业主维权活动的一个分析框架[J]. 社会学研究(1).[Chen Peng. 2010. “Urban Homeowners’ Legal Rights Activism in Contemporary China: An Analytical Framework for Homeowners’ Rights Protection Activities.” 〖WTB4X〗Sociological Studies〖WTB4〗 (1). (in Chinese)]
陈映芳.2010. 行动者的道德资源动员与中国社会兴起的逻辑[J]. 社会学研究(4).[ Chen Yingfang .2010. “Moral Resource Mobilization and the Logic of a Rising Society in China.” 〖WTB4X〗Sociological Studies〖WTB4〗 (4).(in Chinese)]
Cohen, Jean. 1985. “Strategy or Identity: New Theoretical Paradigms and Contemporary Social Movements.” 〖WTB4X〗Social Research〖WTB4〗 (52): 663〖CD*2〗716.
Costain, Anne N. and Andrew S. McFarland (eds.). 1998. 〖WTB4X〗Social Movements and American Political Institutions〖WTB4〗. Lanham, MD.: Bowman and Littlefield.
克罗齐耶, 米歇尔、费埃德伯格. [1977]2007. 行动者与系统——集体行动的政治学[M]. 张月, 等, 译. 上海人民出版社.[Crozier, Michel and Erhard Friedberg. (1977)2007. 〖WTB4X〗L’Acteur et le Système: Les Contraintes de I’Action Collective〖WTB4〗, translated by Zhang Yue 〖WTB4X〗et al〖WTB4〗. Shanghai People’s Publishing House. ]
董海军. 2008. “作为武器的弱者身份:农民维权抗争的底层政治[J]. 社会(4).[Dong Haijun. 2008. “The Weak Identity as a Weapon: Subaltern Politics of the Peasant Resistance for Rights.” 〖WTB4X〗Society〖WTB4〗 (〖WTB4X〗CJS〖WTB4〗) (4).(in Chinese)]
〖JP2〗道格,麦克亚当、西德尼·塔罗、查尔斯·蒂利. [2001]2006. 斗争的动力[M]. 李义平,等,译. 上海:译林出版社.[Doug, McAdam, Sidey Tarrow and Charles Tilly. (2001)2006. 〖WTB4X〗Dynamics of Contention〖WTB4〗, translated by Li Yiping. Shanghai: Yilin Press.]〖JP〗
冯仕政. 2007. 沉默的大多数:差序格局与环境抗争[J]. 中国人民大学学报(3). [Feng Shizheng. 2007. “The Silent Majority: 〖WTB4X〗Chaxu Geju〖WTB4〗 and Environmental Action in Urban China.” 〖WTB4X〗Journal of Renmin University of China〖WTB4〗 (3).(in Chinese)]
费埃德伯格,埃哈尔. [1993] 2008. 权力与规则——组织行动的动力 [M]. 张月,等,译. 上海人民出版社.[Friedberg, Erhard. (1993) 2008. 〖WTB4X〗Le Pouvoir et la Rèle: Dynamiques de l’Action Organisée〖WTB4〗, translated by Zhang Yue 〖WTB4X〗et al〖WTB4〗. Shanghai: Shanghai People’s Publishing House.]
Gamson, William A. and Meyer David S. 1996. “Framing Political Opportunity.” In 〖WTB4X〗Comparative Perspectives on Social Movements〖WTB4〗, edited by Doug McAdam, John D. McCarthy and Mayer N. Zald. New York: Cambridge University Press: 275〖CD*2〗290.
Gurr, Ted. 1970. 〖WTB4X〗Why Men Rebel〖WTB4〗. Princeton, N. J.: Princeton University Press.
哈贝马斯, 尤尔根. [1973]2000. 合法化危机[M]. 刘北成, 等, 译.上海人民出版社.[Habermas, Jurgen. (1973)2000. 〖WTB4X〗Legitimationsproblem im〖WTB4〗 Sptkapitalismus, translated by Liu Beicheng 〖WTB4X〗et al〖WTB4〗. Shanghai: Shanghai People’s Publishing House. ]
Hechter, Michael and Christine Horne. 2003. 〖WTB4X〗Theories Social Order〖WTB4〗. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press.
〖JP2〗Ho, Peter. [2000]2003. “Contesting Rural Spaces: Land Disputes, Customary Tenure and the State.” in 〖WTB4X〗Chinese Society:Change, Conflict and Resistance〖WTB4〗, 2nd edition. edited by Elizabeth J. Perry and Mark Selden. London and NewYork: Routledge Curzon.〖JP〗
亨廷顿, 塞缪尔. [1968] 1988. 变革社会中的政治秩序[M]. 李盛平, 等, 译. 北京:华夏出版社.[Huntington, Samuel P. (1968) 1988. 〖WTB4X〗Political Order in Changing Societies〖WTB4〗, translated by Li Shengping. 〖WTB4X〗et al〖WTB4〗. Beijing: Huaxia Publishing House.]
Inglehart, Ronald. 1990. 〖WTB4X〗Culture Shift in Advanced Industrial Society〖WTB4〗. Princeton, N. J.: Princeton University Press.
勒庞,古斯塔夫. [1895]2007. 乌合之众:大众心理研究 [M]. 冯克利, 译. 桂林:广西师范大学出版社.[LeBon, Gustave. (1895)2007. 〖WTB4X〗The Crowd〖WTB4〗, translated by Feng Keli. Guilin: Guangxi Normal University Press.]
Lee, Ching Kwan. 1998. “The Labor Politics of Market Socialism: Collective Inaction and Class Experiences among State.” 〖WTB4X〗Modern China〖WTB4〗 24(1): 3〖CD*2〗33.
刘能. 2009. 当代中国转型社会中的集体行动:对过去三十年间三次集体行动浪潮的一个回顾[J]. 学海(4).[Liu Neng. 2009. “Collective Actions in Contemporary China: A Review of Three Waves over Past Thirty Years.” 〖WTB4X〗Academia Bimestris〖WTB4〗(4). (in Chinese)]〖JP〗
刘玉照. 2006. 遭遇修路事件的村庄选举双重选择的集体行动[J]. 社会(5).[Liu Yuzhao. 2006. “Village Election Encountered in a Road Construction Event: A Collective Action with Dual Decision Making.” 〖WTB4X〗Society〖WTB4〗 (〖WTB4X〗CJS〖WTB4〗) (5). (in Chinese)]
McAdam, Doug. 1982. 〖WTB4X〗Political Process and the Development of Black Insurgency〖WTB4〗, 1930〖CD*2〗1970. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
McCarthy, John D. and Mayer N. Zald、 1973. 〖WTB4X〗The Trend of Social Movements in America: Professionalization and Resource Mobilization〖WTB4〗. Morristown, N.J.: General Learning Corporation.
Melucci, Alberto. 1989. 〖WTB4X〗Nomads of the Present: Social Movements and Individual Needs in Contemporary Society〖WTB4〗. Philadephia: Temple University Press.
孟伟. 2005. 建构公民政治:业主集体行动策略及其逻辑[J]. 华中师范大学学报(人文社科版)(3).[Meng Wei. 2005. “Etablishing Civil Politics: The Strategies of the Collective Actions of Urban House Owners and the Logic of Their Actions.” 〖WTB4X〗Journal of Central China Normal University〖WTB4〗 (Humanities and Social Sciences)(3). (in Chinese) ]〖JP〗
Michelson, Ethan. 2007. “Climbing the Dispute Pagoda: Grievances and Appeals to the Official Justice System in Rural China.” 〖WTB4X〗American Sociological Review〖WTB4〗 72(3):459〖CD*2〗485.〖JP〗
莫里斯,艾尔东、卡洛尔·缪勒. [1992]2002. 社会运动理论的前沿领域[M]. 刘能,译. 北京大学出版社.[Morris, A.D. 〖WTB4X〗et al〖WTB4〗.(eds.) (1992)2002. 〖WTB4X〗Advanced Field of Social Movement Theories〖WTB4〗, translated by Liu Neng. Beijing: Peking University Press.]〖JP〗
O’Brien, Kevin J. and Lianjiang Li. 1996. “Villagers and Popular Resistance in Contemporary China.” 〖WTB4X〗Modern China〖WTB4〗 22(1): 28〖CD*2〗61.
O’Brien, Kevin J. and Lianjiang Li. 2006. 〖WTB4X〗Rightful Resistance in Rural China〖WTB4〗. New York and Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
〖JP2〗奥尔森. [1965]1995. 集体行动的逻辑[M]. 陈郁, 等, 译. 上海人民出版社.[Olson Mancur, (1965)1995. 〖WTB4X〗The Logic of Collcetive Action: Public Goods and the Theory of Groups〖WTB4〗, translated by Chen Yu 〖WTB4X〗et al〖WTB4〗. Shanghai People’s Publishing House.]〖JP〗
Perry, Elizabeth J. 1985. “Rural Violence in Socialist China.” 〖WTB4X〗The China Quarterly〖WTB4〗 (103): 414〖CD*2〗440.
裴宜理.2008.底层社会与抗争性政治 [J]. 阎小骏,译. 东南学术(3).[Perry, Elizabeth J. 2008. “Subaltern Society and Contentious Politics.” Translated by Yan Xiaojun. 〖WTB4X〗Southeast Academic Research〖WTB4〗 (3). (in Chinese)]
Read, Benjamin L. 2003. “Democratizing the Neighbourhood? New Private Housing and HomeOwner SelfOrganization in Urban China.” 〖WTB4X〗The China Journal〖WTB4〗 49:31〖CD*2〗59.
单光鼐. 2009. 2009年群体性事件新特点[J]. 瞭望(50).[Shan Guangnai. 2009. “New Characters of Popular Protest in 2009.”〖WTB4X〗Outlook〖WTB4〗(50). (in Chinese) ]
Smelser, Neil. 1962. 〖WTB4X〗Theory of Collective Behavior〖WTB4〗. New York: Free Press.
宋维强. 2009. 社会转型期中国农民群体性事件研究[M]. 武汉:华中师范大学出版社.[Song Weiqiang. 2009. 〖WTB4X〗Mass Incidents of Peasants in Transforming China〖WTB4〗. Wuhan: Central China Normal University Publishing House. ]
孙立平.2010. “不稳定幻象”与维稳怪圈[J].人民论坛(13).[Sun Liping. 2010. “Unstable illusion and the Dilemma of Maintaining Stability.” 〖WTB4X〗People’s Tribune〖WTB4〗 (13). (in Chinese)]
Tarrow, 1996. “States and Opportunities: The Political Structuring of Social Movements.”Pp.41〖CD*2〗61. In 〖WTB4X〗Comparative Perspectives on Social Movements〖WTB4〗, edited by Doug McAdam, John D. McCarthy and Mayer N. Zald. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Tarrow, 1998. 〖WTB4X〗Power in Movement〖WTB4〗( 2nd ed.). New York: Cambridge University Press.
Tilly, Charles. 1978. 〖WTB4X〗From Mobilization to Revolution〖WTB4〗. New York: Random House.
蒂利,查尔斯. [2003]2006. 集体暴力的政治[M]. 谢岳, 译.上海人民出版社.[Tilly, Charles. (2003) 2006. 〖WTB4X〗The Politics of Collective Violence〖WTB4〗. translated by Xie Yue.Shanghai People’s Publishing House.]
蒂利,查尔斯. [2004]2008. 欧洲的抗争与民主(1650〖CD*2〗2000)[M]. 陈周旺,等,译.上海人民出版社. [Tilly, Charles.(2004) 2008. 〖WTB4X〗Contention and Democracy in Europe〖WTB4〗, 1650〖CD*2〗2000. translated by Chen Zhouwang 〖WTB4X〗et al〖WTB4〗. Shanghai People’s Publishing House.]
蒂利,查尔斯. [2004]2009. 社会运动,1768〖CD*2〗2004[M]. 胡位钧,译. 上海:世纪出版集团. [Tilly, Charles. (2004) 2009. 〖WTB4X〗Social Movements〖WTB4〗, 1768〖CD*2〗2004, translated by Hu Weijun. Shanghai People’s Publishing House.]
佟新. 2006. 延续的社会主义文化传统——一起国有企业工人集体行动的个案分析[J]. 社会学研究(1).[Tong Xin. 2006. “Continued Socialist Cultural Tradition: An Analysis of Collective Action of Workers at a StateOwned Enterprise.” 〖WTB4X〗Sociological Studies〖WTB4〗(1).(in Chinese)]
Touraine, Alain. 1971. 〖WTB4X〗The May Movement: Revolt and Reform〖WTB4〗. New York: Random House.〖JP〗
Walder, A. 2006. “Ambiguity and Choice in Political Movements: The Origins of Beijing Red Guard Factionalism.” 〖WTB4X〗American Journal of Sociology〖WTB4〗 112: 710〖CD*2〗750.
王国勤. 2007.“集体行动”研究中的概念谱系[J]. 华中师范大学学报(人文社科版)(5).[Wang Guoqin. 2007. “A Concept Pedigree in the Study on ‘Collective Action’.” 〖WTB4X〗Journal of Central China Normal University〖WTB4〗(Humanities and Social Sciences)(5). (in Chinese)]
Wilkinson, Steven I. 2009. “Riots.” 〖WTB4X〗Annual Review of Political Science〖WTB4〗 (12):329〖CD*2〗343.〖JP〗
吴长青.2010.从“策略”到“伦理”:对“依法抗争”的批评性讨论[J]. 社会(2). [Wu Changqing. 2010. “From Strategies to Ethics: A Critique of the ‘Rightful Resistance’.” 〖WTB4X〗Society〖WTB4〗 (〖WTB4X〗CJS〖WTB4〗) (2). (in Chinese)]
吴毅. 2007. “权力—利益的结构之网”与农民群体性利益的表达困境——对一起石场纠纷案例的分析[J]. 社会学研究(5).[Wu Yi. 2007. “‘Nets of the Power –Rights Structure’and Dilemma of Peasants GroupRights Expression: An Analysis of Gravel Pit Dispute.” 〖WTB4X〗Sociological Studies〖WTB4〗 (5). (in Chinese)]
肖唐镖. 2003. 二十余年来大陆农村的稳定状况——以农民行动的变化为视角[J]. 二十一世纪(香港)(4).[Xiao Tangbiao. 2003. “The Change of the Village Political Stability in Mainlang China in Recent 20 Years.” 21st 〖WTB4X〗Century〖WTB4〗 (4).(in Chinese)]
应星. 2007. 草根动员与农民群体利益的表达机制——四个案例的比较研究[J]. 社会学研究(2).[Ying Xing. 2007. “Grassroots Mobilization and the Mechanism of Interest Expression of the Peasants Group.” 〖WTB4X〗Sociological Studies〖WTB4〗 (2). (in Chinese)]
应星. 2009.“气场”与群体性事件的发生机制[J]. 社会学研究(6).[ Ying Xing. 2009. “‘Field of Qi’ and the Occurring Mechanism of Mass Disturbances: A Comparative Study of Two Cases.” 〖WTB4X〗Sociological Studies〖WTB4〗 (6). (in Chinese)]
游正林. 2006. 集体行动何以成为可能[J]. 学海(2).[You Zhenglin.2006. “How Can Collective Action be Possible.” 〖WTB4X〗Academia Bimestris〖WTB4〗 (2). (in Chinese)]
于建嵘. 2006. 集体行动的原动力和机制研究[J]. 学海(2).[Yu Jianrong. 2006. “The Dynamics and Mechanism of Collective Action .” 〖WTB4X〗Academia Bimestris〖WTB4〗 (2). (in Chinese)]〖JP〗
于建嵘. 2009. 当前我国群体性事件的主要类型及其特征[J]. 中国政法大学学报(6).[Yu Jianrong. 2009. “Major Types and Basic Characteristics of Group Event in Today’s China.” 〖WTB4X〗Journal of China University of Plitical Scieace and Law〖WTB4〗 (6). (in Chinese)]
张静. [2000]2007. 基层政权:乡村制度诸问题[M]. 上海人民出版社.[ Zhang Jing. (2000)2007. 〖WTB4X〗The Grassroots Regime: Issues on the Rural System〖WTB4〗. Shanghai People’s Publishing House.]
张静. 2010. 义乌外来工为什么愿意使用法律[J]. 江苏行政学院学报(3). [ Zhang Jing. 2010. “Why are the Migrant Laborers in Yiwu Willing to Resort to Law? ” 〖WTB4X〗Journal of Jiangsu Administration Institute〖WTB4〗(3). (in Chinese)]
张磊. 2005. 业主维权运动:产生原因及动员机制[J]. 社会学研究(6).[Zhang Lei. 2005. “Beijing House Owners’ Rights Protection Movement: Reason of Breakout and Mobilization Mechanism.” 〖WTB4X〗Sociological Studies〖WTB4〗 (6). (in Chinese)]
Zhao, Dingxin. 2001. 〖WTB4X〗The Power of Tiananmen: StateSociety Relations and the 1989 Beijing Student Movement〖WTB4〗. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
赵鼎新. 2006. 社会与政治运动讲义[M]. 北京:社会科学文献出版社.[Zhao Dingxin. 2006. 〖WTB4X〗Teaching Materials on Social and Political Movement〖WTB4〗. Beijing: Social Sciences Academic Press.]