单位团体献血运作的过程与机制:以北京市T大学为个案

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

本文在中国社会结构转型和血液制度变迁的背景下，以T大学的一次“女生节”献血活动为关键案例，应用集体行动的有关理论，分析单位团体献血的运作过程和运作机制。本文认为自愿无偿献血的运作过程是一个意义框架建构和延伸的过程。无偿并非没有任何激励，只是淡化物质激励，更多地强调象征激励，即对符号、话语、意义、价值等的突出，这不仅表达了对献血者的尊重，也促进了献血框架的再生产。单位团体献血的有效运作有赖于单位内部的结构易得性，由于高校具有更强的结构易得性，自然成为团体献血的主体。

关键词: 劳工NGO, 社会网络分析, 大数据, 话题模型, 互动社群, 单位团体献血 , 框架建构 , 象征激励 , 结构易得性 , 集体行为

Abstract:

In the transformational context of China’s social structure and blood system， this paper takes the “Girl’s Day” blood donation activity of University T as a critical case to apply collective action theories to the analysis of the operation process of group blood donation in Danwei． The operation process of voluntary blood donation without compensation is actually a process of constructing and extending the meaning frame． Providing no compensation does not mean free of incentives． It is to downplay material incentives but to promote symbolic incentives by highlighting symbols， discourses， significances， and values． This not only displays high regard for the blood donators but also reproduces frames for blood donation． Group blood donation in Danweirelies on structural accessibility inside Danwei． With such accessibility high in universities， universities have naturally become the main body for group blood donation．

Key words: topic model, big data, interaction communities, social network analysis, labor NGO, collective behavior , frame construction , group blood donation in Danwei , structural accessibility , symbolic incentive

余成普. 单位团体献血运作的过程与机制:以北京市T大学为个案[J]. 社会杂志, 2010, 30(2): 116-143.

Yu Chengpu. The Operation Process and Mechanism of Group Blood Donation in Danwei： A Case Study of University T in Beijing[J]. Chinese Journal of Sociology, 2010, 30(2): 116-143.

参考文献

Alessandrini，M．2007． “Community Volunteerism and Blood Donation： Altruism as a Lifestyle Choice．” Transfusion Medicine Reviews（4）．
安晓东．2007．日照市街头无偿献血者知识与行为调查［J］．临床输血与检验（3）．［An Xiaodong． 2007． “Knowledge and Practice Research of Blood Donor in Street of Rizhao City．” Journal of Clinic Transfusion and Lab Medicine（3）．（in Chinese）］
Benford，R．D． and David A． Snow．2000． “Framing Processes and Social Movements： An Overview and Assessment．” Annual Review of Sociology（26）． 
Callero，P． L．1985． “ RoleIdentity Salience．” Social Psychology Quarterly（3）．
Callero，P．L．， Judith A．Howard， and Jane A．Piliavin．1987． “Helping Behavior as Role Behavior： Disclosing Social Structure and History in the Analysis of Prosocial Action．” Social Psychology Quarterly（3）．
陈潭．2007．单位身份的松动：中国人事档案制度研究［M］．南京大学出版社．［Chen Tan． 2007． The Loose of Danwei Identity：A Research on Personnel Files of China． Nanjing University Press．］
Elster，J．1990． “Selfishness and Altruism．” InBeyond Selfinterest， edited by Jane，J． Mansbridge． Chicago： University of Chicago Press．
Erwin，K．2006． “The Circulatory System： Blood Procurement， AIDS， and the Social Body in China．” Medical Anthropology Quarterly（2）．
高东英、梁万年，等．2007．开展团体无偿献血的必要性［J］．临床输血与检验（3）．［Gao Dongying and Liang Wannian， et al． 2007． “The Necessity of Group Blood Donation．” Journal of Clinic Transfusion and Lab Medicine（3）．（in Chinese）］
Goffman， E．1974． Frame Analysis． Cambridge： Harvard University Press．
宫伟、邱艳，等．2006．北京市无偿献血工作的现状和思考［J］．中国输血杂志（2）．［Gong Wei． and Qiu Yan， et al．2006． “The Actuality and Thinking on Blood Donation of Peking．” Chinese Journal of Blood Transfusion（2）．（in Chinese）］
郭于华、杨宜音、应星．1999．事业共同体：第三部门激励机制个案探索［M］．杭州：浙江人民出版社．［Guo Yuhua，Yang Yiyin， and Ying Xing．1999． Career Community： A Case Study of Incentive Mechanism in the Third Sections． Hangzhou： Zhejiang People’s Publishing House．］
Healy，K．J．2000． “Embedded Altruism：Blood Collection Regimes and the European Union’s Donor Population．” American Journal of Sociology（6）．
——．2001． Exchange in Blood and Organs． A Dissertation of Princeton University．
——．2004． “Altruism as an Organizational Problem： The Case of Organ Procurement．” American Sociological Review（3）．
——． 2006．Last Best Gifts： Altruism and the Market for Human Blood and Organs． Chicago： University of Chicago Press．
景军．2006．铁默斯预言：人血买卖与艾滋病的孪生关系［J］．开放时代（6）．［Jing Jun． 2006． “Titmuss’ Prediction：The Twinborn Relationship between Human Blood Dealing and AIDS．” Open Times（6）．（in Chinese）］
Lee，L．，Jane A．Piliavin， and Vaughn R．A．Call．1999．“Giving Time， Money， and Blood： Similarities and Differences．” Social Psychology Quarterly62（3）．
李汉林．2007．转型社会中的整合与控制［J］．吉林大学社会科学学报（4）．［Li Hanlin． 2007． “Integration and Control in a Transition Society．” Jilin University Journal Social Sciences Edition（4）．（in Chinese）］
李路路、李汉林．2000．中国的单位组织［M］．杭州：浙江人民出版社．［Li Lulu． and Li Hanlin．2000．Danwei Organizations in China． Hangzhou： Zhejiang People’s Publishing House．］
马凌诺斯基．［1922］2002．西太平洋的航海者［M］．梁永佳，等，译．北京：华夏出版社．［Malinowski，B．K．［1922］2002． Argonauts of the Western Pacific， translated by Liang Yongjia，et al．Peking： Huaxia Publishing House．］
莫斯．［1925］2002．论馈赠［M］．卢汇，译．北京：中央民族大学出版社．［Mauss，M．［1925］2002． The Gift， translated by Lu Hui．Peking： Minzu University of China Press．］
蒙长江．2005．中国传统慈善文化的历史沿革及现实挑战［J］．西南民族大学学报（人文社科版）（1）．［Meng Changjiang〖KG-*9〗． 2005． “History Evolution and Reality Challenge of Traditional Charity Culture in China．” Journal of Southwest University For Nationalities（1）．（in Chinese）］
默顿．［1982］2001．社会研究与社会政策［M］．林聚任，等，译．北京：三联书店．［Merton，R．K．［1982］2001． Social Research and Social Policy． translated by Lin Juren，et al．Beijing： SDX Joint Publishing Company．］
奥立佛、马维尔．［1992］2002．集体行动的动员技术［G］∥A．D．莫里斯，等，主编．社会运动理论的前沿领域．刘能，译．北京大学出版社．［Oliver，P．E．and Gerald Marwell．［1992］2002．“Mobilizing Technologies of Collective Action．” in Advanced Field of Social Movement Theories， A．D． Morris et al．（eds．） translated by Liu Neng． Beijing： Peking University Press．］
奥尔森．［1965］2003．集体行动的逻辑［M］．陈郁，等，译．上海：三联书店．［Olson，M．［1965］2003．The Logic of Collective Action， translated by Chen Yu，et al．Shanghai： SDX Joint Publishing Company．］
Oswalt，R．M．1977． “A Review of Blood Donor Motivation and Recruitment．” Transfusion（17）．
秦晖．1999．政府与企业以外的现代化：中西公益事业比较研究［M］．杭州：浙江人民出版社．［Qin Hui．1999． Modernization beyond Government and Corporation： A Comparative Research of Commonweal Enterprise between China and West． Hangzhou： Zhejiang People’s Publishing House．］
Simmons，R． G．1991． “Altruism and Sociology．” Sociological Quarterly（32）．
Snow，D．A．， et al． 1980．“Social Networks and Social Movement．” American Sociological Review（45）．
——． 1986． “Frame Alignment Processes， Micromobilization， and Movement Participation．” American Sociological Review（51）．
斯诺、本福特．［1992］2002．主框架与抗议周期［G］∥A．D．莫里斯，等，主编．社会运动理论的前沿领域．刘能，译．北京大学出版社．［Snow，D．A．and Robert D．Benford．［1992］2002．“Master Frames and Remonstration Period．” in Advanced Field of Social Movement Theories． A．D． Morris et al．（eds．） translated by Liu Neng． Beijing： Peking University Press．］
孙立平．2004．“单位制”及其变迁［G］∥转型与断裂：改革以来中国社会结构的变迁．北京：清华大学出版社．［Sun Liping． 2004． “Danwei Institution and its Transition．” In Transformation and Rupture： the Transition of China Social Structure form Reform． Beijing： Tsinghua University Press．］
唐丽．2003．网络的生产［J］．社会学研究（5）．［Tang Li． 2003． “Production of Social Network．”Sociological Studies（5）．（in Chinese）］
塔洛．［1992］2002．心智、政治文化和集体行动框架［G］∥A．D．莫里斯，等，主编．社会运动理论的前沿领域．刘能，译．北京大学出版社．［Tarrow，S．［1992］2002．“Mentality， Political Culture and Collective Action Frames．” in Advanced Field of Social Movement Theories． A．D． Morris et al．（eds．） translated by Liu Neng． Bejing： Peking University Press．］
Titmuss，R．M．1970． The Gift Relationship： From Human Blood to Social Policy． New York： A Division of Random House．
王宁．2007．个案研究的代表性问题与抽样逻辑［J］．甘肃社会科学（5）．［Wang Ning． 2007． “Representational Problem and Sample Logic of Case Study．” Social Sciences in Gansu（5）．（in Chinese）］
王巧玲．2002．中国血液安全问题的制度分析［D］．北京：中国人民大学硕士学位论文．［Wang Qiaoling． 2002． An Institution Analysis on China Blood Safety． Peking： A Dissertation of Renmin University of China．］
阎云翔．2000．礼物的流动［M］．李放春，等，译．上海人民出版社．［Yan Yunxiang． 2000． The Flow of Gifts． translated by Li Fangchun， et al． Shanghai： Shanghai People’s Publishing House．］
叶书来．2006．医科大学生无偿献血和捐献造血干细胞知识、态度及行为分析［J］．中国输血杂志（4）．［Ye shulai． 2006． “Knowledge， Attitude and Practice Analysis on Blood and Hemopoietic Stem Cell Donation of Medical Undergraduates．” Chinese Journal of Blood Transfusion（4）．（in Chinese）］
应星、晋军．2000．集体上访中的“问题化”过程［G］∥清华社会学评论（特辑）．厦门：鹭江出版社．［Ying Xing and Jin Jun． 2000．“Probleming Process in Collective Appeal．” In Tsinghua Sociological Review（Special Collection）． Xiamen： Lujiang Publishing House．］
应星．2007．草根动员与农民群体利益的表达机制［J］．社会学研究（2）．［Ying Xing． 2007． “Grassroots Mobilization and the Mechanism of Interest Expression of the Peasants Group．” Sociological Studies（2）．（in Chinese）］
Zaller，N．2006．To Donate or Not to Donate： An Analysis of Blood Donors and Blood Donation Kknowledge， Attitudes and Practices in Northwestern China． Ann Arbor， Mich．： UMI．
赵鼎新．2006．社会与政治运动讲义［M］．北京：社会科学文献出版社．［Zhao Dingxin． 2006． Teaching Materials on Social and Political Movement． Beijing： Social Sciences Academic Press．］
郑丽勇、施建军．2004．激励的结构：基于员工偏好的激励均衡模型［J］．南京社会科学（11）．［Zheng Liyong and Shi Jianjun． 2004．“The Structure of Encouragement： Balanced Encouragement Mode Based on Staffs’ Preference．” Social Sciences in Nanjing（11）．（in Chinese）］
周秋光、曾桂林．2007．中国慈善思想渊源探析［J］．湖南师范大学社会科学学报（3）．［Zhou Qiuguang．and Zeng Guilin．2007． “An Inquiry into the Source of Philanthropic Thoughts．” Journal of Social Science of Hunan Normal University（3）．（in Chinese）］

责任编辑：劳勤

[1]	桂勇, 黄荣贵, 丁昳. 网络左翼的三重面相:基于个案观察和大数据的探索性研究[J]. 社会杂志, 2018, 38(3): 203-239.
[2]	陈云松, 严飞. 网络舆情是否影响股市行情?基于新浪微博大数据的ARDL模型边限分析[J]. 社会杂志, 2017, 37(2): 51-73.
[3]	黄荣贵. 网络场域、文化认同与劳工关注社群:基于话题模型与社群侦测的大数据分析[J]. 社会杂志, 2017, 37(2): 26-50.
[4]	陈云松吴青熹张翼. 近三百年中国城市的国际知名度——基于大数据的描述与回归[J]. 社会杂志, 2015, 35(5): 60-77.
[5]	刘军. QAP：测量“关系”之间关系的一种方法 [J]. 社会杂志, 2007, 27(4): 164-164 .
[6]	刘　军. 法村社会支持网络的整体结构研究——块模型及其应用,[J]. 社会杂志, 2006, 26(3): 69-80.