“主体间性—干预行动”框架:质性研究的反思谱系

社会杂志

• 论文 • 上一篇

“主体间性—干预行动”框架:质性研究的反思谱系

郑庆杰上海大学社会学系.

郑庆杰上海大学社会学系.

出版日期:2011-05-20 发布日期:2011-05-20
通讯作者: 郑庆杰上海大学社会学系 E-mail:gsls54@163.com
作者简介:郑庆杰上海大学社会学系(Author: Zheng Qingjie, Department of Sociology, Shanghai University)〓Email:gsls54@163.com 
基金资助:
本研究得到上海大学研究生创新基金(编号：SHUCX101096)的资助.

“IntersubjectivityIntervent Action” Frame：Reflection Spectrum in Qualitative Research

Zheng Qingjie, Department of Sociology, Shanghai University.


Qingjie, Department of Sociology, Shanghai University.

Online:2011-05-20 Published:2011-05-20
Contact: Zheng Qingjie, Department of Sociology, Shanghai University E-mail:gsls54@163.com
About author:郑庆杰上海大学社会学系(Author: Zheng Qingjie, Department of Sociology, Shanghai University)〓Email:gsls54@163.com 
Supported by:
This research was supported by Graduate lnnovation Fund of SHanghai University ［No. SHUCX101096］

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

质性研究中存在三种困境：主体间性、表述政治、参与行动。前两者是认识论意义上的困境，后者是解放政治和行动意义上的困境。他们在反思广度、深度、力度方面层层递进、步步深入。从对对象的反思到将研究作为反思对象，从认知研究到行动研究，共同构成了质性研究的“主体间性-干预行动”反思谱系。

关键词: 质性研究, 主体间性, 表述政治, 干预行动, 反思

Abstract:

Qualitative research has three dilemmas: intersubjectivity, political representation, and participatory action. The former two are epistemological dilemmas, whereas the last is dilemmas in Emancipatory Politics and action. The journey of scholars’ reflections upon these three dilemmas has gone through, step by step, their breadth, depth, and intensity. A series of reflections, including those first on the object and now on the research itself and then on the cognitive research and now on the action research, have converged to form the “intersubjectivityintervent action” reflection spectrum in qualitative research. This paper provides a systematic, theoretical review in this regard.

Key words: qualitative research， intersubjectivity， political representation， intervent action， reflection

郑庆杰. “主体间性—干预行动”框架:质性研究的反思谱系[J]. 社会杂志.

Zheng Qingjie. “IntersubjectivityIntervent Action” Frame：Reflection Spectrum in Qualitative Research [J]. Chinese Journal of Sociology.

参考文献

参考文献（References）

艾尔维森，马茨、卡伊·舍尔德贝里. 2009. 质性研究的理论视角［M］. 陈仁仁，译. 重庆大学出版社. ［Alvesson，Mats and Kaj Skoldberg. 2009.〖WTB4X〗Reflexive Methodology: New Vistas for Qualitative Research〖WTB4〗，translated by Chen Renren. Chongqing University Press.］
克利福德, 詹姆斯、乔治·E.马库斯，等，编. 2006.写文化［M］. 高丙中，等，译. 北京：商务印书馆。［Clifford，James， George E. Marcus, 〖WTB4X〗et al〖WTB4〗 (eds.)．2006.〖WTB4X〗 Writing Culture〖WTB4〗，translated by Gao Bingzhong 〖WTB4X〗et al〖WTB4〗. Beijing：The Commercial Press.］
邓金，诺曼·K.、冯伊曼·S.林肯. 2007.导论：定性研究的学科与实践［G］//定性研究（卷一）. 诺曼·K.邓金、冯伊曼·S.林肯, 主编. 重庆大学出版社.［Denzin，Norman K.and Yvonna S. Lincoln.2007.“Introductionn：The Discipline and Practice of Qualitiative Research. ”In 〖WTB4X〗Handbook of Qualitative Research〖WTB4〗 (first volumn)，edited by Norman K. Denzin and Yvonna S. Lincoln，translated by Feng Xiaotian 〖WTB4X〗et al〖WTB4〗. Chongqing University Press.］
法恩，米歇尔，等. 2007. 为了谁——定性研究、描述和责任［G］//定性研究（卷一）．诺曼·K.邓金、冯伊曼·S.林肯，主编. 重庆大学出版社.［Fine, M, 〖WTB4X〗et al〖WTB4〗．2000．“For Whom? Qualitative Research, Representations, and Social Responsibilities.”In 〖WTB4X〗Handbook of Qualitative Research〖WTB4〗 (first volumn)，edited by Norman K.Denzin and Yvonna S.Lincoln， translated by Feng Xiaotian 〖WTB4X〗et al〖WTB4〗. Chongqing University Press．］
范会芳. 2009. 舒茨现象学社会学［M］. 郑州大学出版社. ［Fan Huifang. 2009. 〖WTB4X〗Schutz’s Phenomenological Sociology 〖WTB4〗. Zhengzhou University Press.］
吉登斯. 1998. 现代性与自我认同［M］. 赵旭东、方文，译. 北京：三联书店. ［Giddens，Anthony. 1998. 〖WTB4X〗Modernity and Self Identity〖WTB4〗，translated by Zhao Xudong and Fang Wen. Beijing: SDX Joint Publishing Company.］
吉登斯. 2003. 社会学方法的新规则［M］. 田佑中、刘江涛，译. 北京：社会科学文献出版社. ［Giddens，Anthony. 2003. 〖WTB4X〗New Rules of Sociological Method〖WTB4〗，translated by Tian Yu and Liu Jiangtao. Beijing: Social Sciences Academic Press.］
格林伍德，戴维·J、默顿·勒温. 2007.通过行动研究重建大学和社会的关系［G］//定性研究（卷一）.诺曼·K.邓金、冯伊曼·S.林肯, 主编. 重庆大学出版社.［Greenwood，David J. and Merton Lewin. 2007. Restructing the Relationships Between Universites andd Society Through Actin Research.in Handbook of Qualitative Research (first volumn) edited by Norman K. Denzin. Yvonna S. Lincoln, translated by Feng Xiaotian 〖WTB4X〗et al.〖WTB4〗 Chongqing University Press.］
古哈. 2005. 论殖民地印度史编纂的若干问题［Ｇ］//庶民研究. 刘健芝、许兆麟，选编.北京:中央编译出版社. ［Guha, Ranajit. 2005. “Considering Some Problems In Making Colonial History of India. ”In 〖WTB4X〗Subaltern Studies〖WTB4〗，edited by Liu Jianzhi and Xu Zhaolin. Beijing: Central Compilation and Translation Press.］
胡塞尔.［1935〖CD*2〗1936］［1954］2001．王炳文，译. 欧洲科学的危机与超越论的现象学［M］.北京：商务印书馆.［Husserl, Edmund．（1935〖CD*2〗1936）（1954）2001．〖WTB4X〗Die Krisis der Europaischen Wissenschaften und die Transzendentale Phanomenologie，〖WTB4〗translated by Wang bingwen. Beijing: The Commercial Press.］
凯米斯，斯蒂芬、罗宾·麦克塔格特. 2007. 参与行动研究［G］//定性研究（卷二）. 诺曼·K.邓金、冯伊曼·S.林肯，主编. 重庆大学出版社. ［Kemmis, Stephen, and Robin? Mactaggart. 2007.“Participatory Action Research.”In 〖WTB4X〗Handbook of Qualitative Research〖WTB4〗 (first volumn) ,edited by Norman K. Denzin and Yvonna S. Lincoln，translated by Feng Xiaotian 〖WTB4X〗et al〖WTB4〗. Chongqing University Press.］
李应志. 2008. 解构的文化政治实践［M］. 上海三联书店. ［Li Yingchi. 2008. 〖WTB4X〗The Cultural and Political Practice in Deconstruction〖WTB4〗. Shanghai SDX Joint Publishing Company.］
马丹丹. 2010. 属下能说话吗？——“诉苦文类”的民族志批评［J］. 社会(5). ［Ma Dandan. 2010.“May the Subaltern Have a Voice: A Critical Review of the ‘Bitterness Expressing’Genre．”〖WTB4X〗Society〖WTB4〗（CJS）（1）．(in Chinese)］. 
马尔库斯，乔治·E．、米凯尔·M.费彻尔. 1998. 作为文化批评的人类学［M］. 王铭铭、蓝达居，译. 北京：三联书店. ［Marcus, George.E. and Michael M.Fischer. 1998.〖WTB4X〗Anthropology as Cultural Critique〖WTB4〗，translated by Wang Mingming and Lan Daju. Beijing: SDX Joint Publishing Company.］
马克思.［1851〖CD*2〗1852］1977.路易·波拿巴的雾月十八日［G］//马克思恩格斯选集（第一卷）．北京：人民出版社．［Marx，Karl. ( 1851〖CD*2〗1852)1977.“The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte．” In Selected Works of K. Marx and F. Engels(first volumn)，translated by Central Compilation & Translation Bureau.Beijing: People’s Publishing House.］
米德, 乔治·H.［1932］1992. 心灵、自我与社会.［M］赵月瑟，译. 上海译文出版社. ［Mead，George H. (1932)1992. 〖WTB4X〗Mind, Self and Society〖WTB4〗,translated by Zhao Yuese. Shanghai Translation Publishing House.］
米尔斯、霍布尔曼. 2008. 质性资料的分析：方法与实践［M］. 张芬芬，译.重庆大学出版社. ［Miles，Matthew B.，Matthew B.，and Michael Huberman.2008. 〖WTB4X〗Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook〖WTB4〗，translated by Zhang Fenfen. Chongqing University Press.］
倪梁康.1994.现象学及其效应.［M］. 北京：三联书店.［Ni Liangkang. 1994. 〖WTB4X〗Phenomenon and Its Effects〖WTB4〗. Beijing: SDX Joint Publishing Company.］.
许茨，阿尔弗雷德. 2001. 社会实在问题［M］. 霍桂桓，译. 北京：华夏出版社. ［Schutz, Alfred. 2001. 〖WTB4X〗The Problem of Social Reality, 〖WTB4〗 translated by Huo Guihuan.Beijing: HuaXia Press.］
沈原. 2006. “强干预”与“若干预”：社会学干预的两条途径［J］，社会学研究（5）. ［Shen Yuan. 2006. “‘Strong Intervention’ and ‘Weak Intervention’: Sociological Intervention in Two Ways．” 〖WTB4X〗Sociological Studies〖WTB4〗(5). (in Chinese)］.
斯皮瓦克. 2007a. 底层人能说话吗? ［G］//从解构到全球化批判：斯皮瓦克读本. 陈永国、赖立里、郭英剑，主编. 北京大学出版社. ［Spivak, Gayatri C. 2007.“Can the Subaltern Speak?”In〖WTB4X〗 Deconstruction to the Critique of Globalization: A Spivak Reader〖WTB4〗, edited by Chen Yongguo,Lai Lili,and Guo Yingjian．Beijing: Peking University Press.］
斯皮瓦克. 2007b．解构历史编撰［G］// 从解构到全球化批判：斯皮瓦克读本. 陈永国、赖立里、郭英剑，主编. 北京大学出版社. ［Spivak, Gayatri C. 2005.“Subaltern Studies: Deconstructing Historiography.” In〖WTB4X〗 Deconstruction to the Critique of Globalization: A Spivak Reader〖WTB4〗,edited by Chen Yongguo,Lai Lili,and Guo Yingjian.Beijing: Peking University Press.］
泰德洛克，巴巴拉．2007．民族志和民族志描述［G］//定性研究（卷二）. 诺曼·K.邓金、冯伊曼·S.林肯，主编. 风笑天，等，译. 重庆大学出版社．［Tedlock，Barbara. 2007.“Ethnography and ethnographic represention. ”In 〖WTB4X〗Handbook of Qualitative Research〖WTB4〗 (Second volumn)，edited by Norman K. Denzin and Yvonna S. Lincoln, translated by Feng Xiaotian 〖WTB4X〗et al〖WTB4〗. Chongqing University Press.］
图海纳, 阿兰．［1984］2008．行动者的归来［M］．舒诗伟，等，译．北京：商务印书馆．［Touraine，Alain. （1984）2008. 〖WTB4X〗Return of the Actor: Social Theory in Postindustrial Society〖WTB4〗， translated by Shu Shiwei 〖WTB4X〗et al〖WTB4〗.Beijing: The Commercial Press.］
杨善华、孙飞宇. 2005. 作为意义的深度访谈［J］. 社会学研究（5）. ［Yang Shanhua and Sun Feiyu. 2005. “DepthInterviewing as Meaning Exploring.”〖WTB4X〗Sociological Studies 〖WTB4〗(5). (in Chinese)］.
张佩国. 2010〖CD*2〗03〖CD*2〗02．口述史——社会记忆与表述的政治［N］. 中国社会科学报（67）.［Zhang Peiguo. 2010〖CD*2〗03〖CD*2〗02. “Oral History ：Social Memory and the Politics of Presentation．”〖WTB4X〗 Chinese Social Sciences Today〖WTB4〗（67）. (in Chinese)］.
郑庆杰. 2011.生活世界与行动意义研究的可能性［J］.前沿（1）［Zheng QingJie.2011.“LifeWorld and Possibility of Meaning of Action.”〖WTB4X〗 Forward Position〖WTB4〗(1).］

责任编辑：路英浩

[1]	罗祎楠. 思想史视野中的质性研究:以方法意涵的构建为例[J]. 社会杂志, 2019, 39(1): 98-128.
[2]	孙飞宇. 方法论与生活世界舒茨主体间性理论再讨论[J]. 社会杂志, 2013, 33(1): 38-74.
[3]	赵万里\| 赵超. 生成图式与反思理性——解析布迪厄的知识社会学理论[J]. 社会杂志, 2012, 32(2): 33-50.
[4]	路英浩. 在回顾和反思中把握“社会学中国化”[J]. 社会杂志, 2006, 26(6): 19-19 .

“主体间性—干预行动”框架:质性研究的反思谱系

“IntersubjectivityIntervent Action” Frame：Reflection Spectrum in Qualitative Research

PDF

可视化

摘要/Abstract

引用本文

使用本文

参考文献

相关文章 4

编辑推荐

Metrics

本文评价