社会杂志

• 论文 • 上一篇    下一篇

税费改革后中西部地区乡镇政权自主空间的营造:以河北Y县为例

杨善华;宋倩   

  1. 杨善华,北京大学社会学系; 宋倩,美国纽约州立大学奥本尼分校
  • 收稿日期:1900-01-01 修回日期:1900-01-01 出版日期:2008-07-20 发布日期:2008-07-20

The Creation of AutonomicSpace by the Township Governments in Western and Central China after the Tax Reform: A Case Study of County Y in Hebei Province

Yang Shanhua & Song Qian   

  • Received:1900-01-01 Revised:1900-01-01 Online:2008-07-20 Published:2008-07-20

摘要:

税费改革之后,我国中西部地区乡镇政权的财政收入大多采用转移支付的形式实现,乡镇政权的一些职能也被上收到了上级职能部门。这对于以前主要靠农业提取作为其主要财政收入来源的中西部乡镇政权来说,意味着极大地收缩了他们工作的自主空间。但是,在压力型体制下,在这样的财政和职能困境中,他们仍然要完成上级下达的任务,这就使得他们必须去寻求自主空间的拓展。笔者根据对河北省Y县乡镇干部的访谈,试图解释中西部部分地区的乡镇政权是如何在夹缝中寻求自我空间的。在调查中,我们发现,工作做得比较优秀的乡镇政权基本都有这样的特点:乡镇干部了解如何有选择地做事,以缩小贯彻上级意志的工作范围;在与县级政权的以依赖与软性反抗为特征的关系互动中,营造基层政权的自主空间;在与基层村民的关系中,调动各种权力技术,权宜地运用权力与村民进行互动,扩大自主空间;同时有些地方在组织上还形成了一套积极和高效的体系、甚至机关文化,以保证在上级政府的考核中获取优胜。

关键词: 自主空间, 中西部乡镇政权, 权力技术

Abstract: After the Tax Reform in China, the income of the township governments in Western and Central China (TGWCs) relies mostly on budgetary transactions and their power has been partially taken back by their authorities. These measures have greatly shrunken the autonomicspace of these TGWCs, whose previous primary income source was agricultural revenues. Even under such institutional pressure and in such difficult financial and administrative situations, TGWCs are still expected to accomplish the goals set by their superiorities. Thus, TGWCs inevitably have to create an autonomicspace for themselves. According to the author’s indepth interviews with some township government officials in County Y, Hebei Province, this paper describes how some of the TGWCs in Western and Central China have tried to establish their autonomicspace within the “sandwiches”. The investigation has revealed the following common features of successful TGWCs: the township government officials’ informed selectivity; reduced job scopes; autonomicspace creation in the interactive relationships to the governments at the county level (characterized of both dependency and soft resistance); autonomicspace expansion in the interactive relationships to the villagers at the grass roots when strategically mobilizing and utilizing all types of powers; and formation of an active and effective system, and even an office culture, to ensure a success in the assessment by their authorities. Thus, TGWCs’ autonomicspace is created.

Key words: autonomicspace, tactics of power, township governments in Western and Central China (TGWCs)