社会杂志

• 宗教社会学研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

现代宗教是理性选择的吗:质疑宗教的理性选择研究范式

范丽珠   

  1. 复旦大学社会学系
  • 收稿日期:1900-01-01 修回日期:1900-01-01 出版日期:2008-11-20 发布日期:2008-11-20

Is Modern Religion by Rational Choice A Critique on the Rational Choice Theory of Religion

Fan Lizhu   

  • Received:1900-01-01 Revised:1900-01-01 Online:2008-11-20 Published:2008-11-20

摘要: 本文在关注宗教社会学理论如何给现代社会的宗教现象以合理的解释的同时,对运用理性选择理论解释现代宗教的取向提出商榷。尽管理性选择理论非常强势,号称有相当普遍的解释力,但本文还是试图对以理性选择理论来解释现代社会宗教的有效性提出质疑,认为 “宗教经济”范式中的宗教市场的“供方”与“求方”是理解宗教的错误逻辑,在工具理性和价值理性两个重要概念中有相互混淆和偷换之嫌。本文最后指出,目前仅以宗教市场理论研究中国宗教具有一定的危险性,必须谨慎地使用。

关键词: 宗教经济, 理性选择理论, 现代社会

Abstract: While this paper is concerned about how to use religious sociological theories to reasonably explain the religious phenomena in modern society, it questions the explanatory power of the rational choice theory of modern religion. Despite of its supposedly strong and comprehensive explanatory power, this paper still wants to criticize the usage of this rational choice theory to account for modern religion, arguing that it is a wrong logic to understand religion from the “supply” and “demand” of the religious market in the “religious economic model” because of the confusion or substitution between the two important concepts of instrumental rationality and value rationality. The paper finally warns the readers of the danger in using only the religious economic market theory to study religion in China and calls for cautious application.

Key words: modern society, religious economy, rational choice theory