维权行动和基层民主参与——以B市商品房业主为例

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

本文将讨论公民维权活动和基层民主的关系。现有文献认为，对居民来说，居委会选举通常没有太大的实际意义。然而作者在田野调查中发现，在住房市场化改革中成长起来的商品房业主阶层，在产权利益经常遭受侵犯的情况下，会想尽一切办法来保护自己的权益。参选居委会成为业主保护权益的一种方式，尤其是当基层政府和居委会对业主的维权进行干涉的时候。〖JP2〗本文将简要介绍作者通过滚雪球方式调查的19个小区的整体情况和一般性的趋势，并通过3个案例来具体讨论商品房业主制度性参与的维权方式，展现其内在的机制。笔者认为，业主的制度性参与，一方面有利于业主维权，另一方面也使居委会选举变得更具实际意义，有可能促进基层政府依法办事。

关键词: 业主 , 维权 , 基层民主 , 居委会 , 业委会

Abstract:

This paper discusses the relationship between citizens’ rightsprotecting actions and grassroots political participation． In the existing literature， most scholars do not believe that the election of the residents’ committee is important to urban residents． However， in the field study， the author has found that the homeowners who have gone through the marketoriented reform in the real estate sector have frequently experienced threats to their home ownership will try every means to protect their rights and interests． Participating in the residents’ committee election is one such means， especially when the local government and the residents’ committee try to interfere with their efforts to protect their property rights． The paper first briefly describes the overall situation and the general trend in the 19 residential communities reached by the author with the snowball method． Then， three cases are selected to illustrate the homeowners’ institutional participation as a means to protect their rights and to dispose its inherent mechanism． The author thinks that such participation is good to protect the homeowners’ rights． Furthermore， it helps make the election of the residents’ committee meaningful． This may pressure the local government to adhere to the regulations in their actions．

Key words: homeowner , rights protection , grassroots democracy , residents’ committee , homeowners’ committee

管兵 . 维权行动和基层民主参与——以B市商品房业主为例[J]. 社会杂志, 2010, 30(5): 46-74.

Guan Bing. [J]. Chinese Journal of Sociology, 2010, 30(5): 46-74.

参考文献

参考文献（References）

Bernstein， Thomas P．and Xiaobo Lü．2003．Taxtion without Representation in Contemporary Rural China．Cambridge University Press．
Cai，Yongshun．2002．“The Resistance of Chinese Laidoff Workers in the Reform Period．”The China Quarterly 170：327-344．
Cai，Yongshun．2004．“Managed Participation in China．”Political Science Quarterly119（3）：425-451．
Cai，Yongshun．2005．“China’s Moderate Middle Class： The Case of Homeowners’ Resistance．”Asian Survey，45（5）：777-799．
Cai，Yongshun．2006．State and LaidOff Workers in Reform China．London and New York， Routledge．
Cai，Yongshun．2008a．“Local Governments and the Suppression of Popular Resistance in China．” China Quarterly193：24-42．
Cai，Yongshun．2008b．“Power Structure and Regime Resilience： Contentious Politics in China．”British Journal of Political Science 38：411-432．
Cai，Yongshun．2010．Collective Resistance in China： Why Popular Protests Succeed or Fail．Stanford，California：Stanford University Press．
Chan， Anita．2008“China’s Trade Unions in Corporatist Transition．”in Associations and the Chinese State： Contested Spaces，edited by Jonathan Unger．Armonk，NY：M． E． Sharpe：69-85．
Chan，Sylvia．1998．“Research Notes on Villagers’Committee Election： Chinese Style Democracy．”Journal of Contemporary China 7（19）：507-21．
Chen， Feng．2006．“Privatization and Its Discontents in Chinese Factories．”The China Quarterly 185：42-60．
陈鹏．2009．从“产权”走向“公民权”——当前中国城市业主维权研究［J］．开放时代（4）．［Chen Peng． 2009． “From Property Right to Citizen Right： Urban Homeowners’ Rights Protection Studies in Modern China．” Open Times （4）．（in Chinese）］
Galanter，Marc．1974．“Why the ‘Haves’ Come Out Ahead： Speculations on the Limits of Legal Change．”Law and Society Review 9：95-160．
顾昕、王旭．2005．从国家主义到法团主义——中国市场转型过程中国家与专业团体关系的演变［J］．社会学研究（2）．［Gu Xin and Wang Xu． 2005． “From Statism to Corporatism： Changes in the Elationship between the State and Professional Sssociations in the Transition to Market Economic in China．” Sociological Studies（2）．（in Chinese）］
He，Xin．2005．“Why Do They Not Comply with the Law? Illegality and SemiLegality among RuralUrban Migrant Entrepreneurs in Beijing．”Law and Society Review 39（3）：527-562．
Jennings，M． Kent．1997．“Political Participation in the Chinese Countryside．”The American Political Science Review 91（2）：361-372．
Li，Lianjiang．2003．“The Empowering Effect of Village Elections in China．”Asian Survey 43（4）：648-662．
Lieberthal，Kenneth G．1992．“Introduction： The ‘Fragmented Authoritarianism’ Model and Its Limitations．” in Bureaucracy， Politics， and Decision Making in PostMao China，edited by Kenneth G． Lberthal and David M． Lampton．Berkeley，Los Angeles，Oxford：University of California Press：1-33．
Lieberthal， Kenneth G． and Michel Oksenberg． 1988． Policy Making in China Leaders， Structures， and Processes．Princeton： Princeton University Press．
马卫红、黄沁蕾、桂勇．2000．上海市居民社区参与意愿影响因素分析［J］．社会（6）．［Ma Weihong，and Huang Qinlei， and Gui Yong． 2000 “An Aalysis on the Intention of Residents to Participate in Community Activities in Shanghai．”Society（6）．（in Chinese）］
敬乂嘉、刘春荣．2007．居委会直选与城市基层治理——对2006年上海市居委会直接选举的分析［J］．复旦学报（社会科学版）（1）．［Jing Yijia and Liu Chunrong．2007． “The Direct Election of the Urban Residents’ Committee and the Urban Grassroots Governance．” Fudan Journal （Social Sciences）（1）．（in Chinese）］
康晓光、韩恒．2005．分类控制：当前中国大陆国家与社会关系研究［J］．社会学研究（6）．［Kang Xiaoguang and Han Heng． 2005． “The System of Differential Controls： A Study of the StateSociety Relationship in Contemporary China．” Sociological Studies（6）．（in Chinese）］
李浩明．对京沪穗三地的一项调查表明：九成公众不满物业管理［J］．文汇报，2002-02-28．［Li Haoming．“ A Survey from Beijing， Shanghai， and Guangzhou Shows that 90 per cent Homeowners are not Content with Property Management Companies．” Wenhuibao． 2002 2-28．］ 
McAdam，Doug．1982．Political Process and the Development of Black Insurgency 1930-1970．Chicago and London：The University of Chicago Press．
McCarthy， John D．and Mayer N． Zald．1973．The Trend of Social Movements in America： Professionalization and Resource Mobilization．Morristown， N．J：General Learning Press．
McCarthy， John D．and Mayer N． Zald．1977．“Resource Mobilization and Social Movements： A Partial Theory．”The American Journal of Sociology 82（6）：1212-1241．
Mertha， Andrew C．2008．China’s Water Warrior．Ithaca & London：Cornell University Press．
O’Brien，Kevin J．1994．“Implementing Political Reform in China’s Villages．”Australian Journal of Chinese Affairs（32）：33-59．
O’Brien，Kevin J．1996．“Rightful Resistance．”World Politics 49（1）：31-55．
O’Brien， Kevin J． and Lianjiang Li．1999．“Selective Policy Implementation in Rural China．”Comparative Politics 31（2）：167-186．
O’Brien， Kevin J． and Lianjiang Li．2000．“Accommodating ‘Democracy’ in a OneParty State： Introducing Village Elections in China．”The China Quarterly （162）：465-489．
O’Brien， Kevin J． and Lianjiang Li．2005．“Suing the Local State： Administrative Litigation in Rural China．”in Engaging the Law in China： State， Society， and Possibilities for Justice，edited by Diamant， Lubman and O’Brien．Stanford：Stanford University Press：31-53．
O’Brien， Kevin J． and Lianjiang Li．2006．Rightful Resistance in Rural China．New York：Cambridge University Press．
Oi，Jean and Scott Rozelle．2000．“Election and Power： The Locus of DecisionMaking in Chinese Villages．” The China Quarterly（162）：513-539．
Pei，Minxi．1995．“Creeping Democratization in China．”Journal of Democracy，6（4）：65-79．
Read，Benjamin L．2000．“Revitalizing the State’s Urban ‘Nerve Tips’．”The China Quarterly（163）：806-820．
Read，Benjamin L．2003．“Democratizing the Neighbourhood? New Private Housing and HomeOwner SelfOrganization in Urban China．”The China Journal（49）：31-59．
Read，Benjamin L．2008．“Assessing Variation in Civil Society Organizations．”Comparative Political Studies 41（9）：1240-1265．
Shi，Farong and Yongshun Cai．2006．“Disaggregating the State： Networks and Collective Resistance in Shanghai．”The China Quarterly 186：314-332．
石发勇．2005．城市社区民主建设与制度性约束：上海市居委会改革个案研究［J］．社会（2）．［Shi Fayong． 2005． “On Practice of Democratization Construction and Institution Restriction in Urban Communities： Case Study on Reform of Resident Representation Committee from One Community in Shanghai．” Society （2）．（in Chinese）］
Shi，Tianjian．1999．“Village Committee Elections in China： Institutionalist Tactics for Democracy．”World Politics 51（3）：385-412．
中国社会调查所．2004．2004 中国“霸王现象”认知度调查报告［J］．经济参考报，2004-12-20．［Social Survey Institce of China （CCIC）．2004． “Survey Report on Commercial Overload Phenomena in 2004．”Economic Information Daily，2004-12-20．］
孙秀林．2009．村庄民主、村干部角色及其行为模式［J］．社会（1）．［Sun Xiulin． 2009． “Village Democracy，Roles of Village Cadres，and their Behavioral Strategies．” Society（1）．（in Chinese）．］ 
Sun， Yanfei and Dingxin Zhao．2008．“Environmental Campaigns．” in Popular Protest in China，edited by Kevin J． O’Brien．Cambridge，London：Harvard University Press：144-162．
Tsai，Lily．2007．“Solidary Groups， Informal Accountability， and Local Public Goods Provision in Rural China．”American Political Science Review〖WT《B》〗 101（2）：355〖CD*2〗372．
唐娟．2005．城市社区结构变迁中的冲突与治理［G］∥唐娟，主编．城市社区业主委员会发展研究．重庆出版社．［Tang Juan． 2005． “Conflicts and Governance in the Transitional Urban Communities．” In Tang Juan （ed．）． Studies on the Homeowners’ Committee in Cities． Chongqing Publishing House．］
Unger，Jonathan．2008．“Chinese Associations， Civil Society， and State Corporatism： Disputed Terrain．” in Associations and the Chinese State： Contested Spaces， edited by Jonathan Unger．Armonk：M．E． Sharpe：1-13．
Unger，Jonathan and Anita Chan．1995．“China，Corporatism，and the East Asian Model．”The Australian Journal of Chinese Affairs（33）：29-53．
Unger，Jonathan and Anita Chan．2008．“Associations in a Bind： The Rise of Political Corporatism in China．”in Associations and the Chinese State： Contested Spaces，edited by Jonathan Unger．Armonk， NY： M． E． Sharpe：48-68．
Wang， Ya Ping and Alan Murie．1999．“Commercial Housing Development in Urban China，” Urban Study， Vol．36． No．9： 1475-1494．
Wang， Zhenyao． 1998．“Village Committees： The Basis for China’s Democratization，” in Cooperative and Collective in China’s Rural Development between State and Private Interests， edited by Eduard B． Vermeer，Frank N． Pieke，and Woei Lien Chong．Armonk：N．Y．： M． E． Sharpe：239〖CD*2〗56．
吴毅．2007．“权力〖CD*2〗利益的结构之网”与农民群体性利益的表达困境——对一起石场纠纷案例的分析［J］．社会学研究（5）．［Wu Yi． 2007． “Nets of the PowerRights Structure’ and Dilemma of Peasants’ Group Rights Expression： Analysis of a Gravel Pit Dispute．” Sociological Studies （5）．（in Chinese）］
熊易寒．2008．社区选举：在政治冷漠与高投票率之间［J］．社会（3）．［Xiong Yihan． 2008． “The Paradox of Urban Community Elections： Between Political Apathy and High Turnout Rates．” Society （3）．（in Chinese ）］
应星．2001．大河移民上访的故事［M］．北京：三联书店．［Ying Xing． 2001． A Story of a Hydroelectric Station Area in Southwest in China． Beijing： SDX Joint Company．］
应星．2007．草根动员与农民群体利益的表达机制——四个个案的比较研究［J］．社会学研究（2）．［Ying Xing． 2007． “Grassroots Mobilization and the Mechanism of Interests Expression of the Peasant Group： Acomparative Study of Four Cases．”〖WT《XB》〗Sociological Studeis （2）．（in Chinese）］
于建嵘．2003．农民有组织抗争及其政治风险——湖南省H县调查［J］．战略与管理（3）．［Yu Jianrong． 2003． “Organizational Resistance of Peasants and Political Risks： A Survey in County H in Hunan Province．”Strategy and Management （3）．（in Chinese）］
张磊．2005．业主维权运动：产生原因及动员机制——对北京市几个小区个案的考查［J］．社会学研究（6）．［Zhang Lei． 2005． “Beijing House Owners’ Rights Protection Movement： Reason of Breakout and Mobilization Mechanism．” Sociological Studies （6）．（in Chinese）］
张亮．2001．上海社区建设面临困境：居民参与不足［J］．社会（1）．［Zhang Liang． 2001． “Community Building in Shanghai Faces Difficulties： Insufficient Participation of Residents．” Society （1）．（in Chinese）］
张铭宇．2005．社区居委会在为谁忙［J］．社区（12）．［Zhang Mingyu． 2005． “Cadres in Communities Work for Whom?”Community（12）．（in Chinese）］
郑广怀．2005．伤残农民工：无法被赋权的群体［J］．社会学研究（3）．［Zheng Guanghuai． 2005． “Injured Migrant Workers： A DePowered Social Group．” Sociological Studies（3）．（in Chinese）］
周雪光．2008．基层政府间的“共谋现象”——一个政府行为的制度逻辑［J］．社会学研究（6）．［Zhou Xueguang． 2008． “The Institutional Logic of Collusion among Local Governments in China．”Sociological Studies （6）．（in Chinese）］

责任编辑：路英浩