Where Efficiency Comes from： An Examination of the Development of PrivatelyOwned Enterprises in Wenzhou

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

本文的关注点在于，改革开放以来，“温州模式”下民营企业的效率机制产生的来源是什么。关于企业的效率机制历来存在两种解释路径：来自企业内部的制度优化和由地方政府及地方市场提供的支持资源。本文考察了这两种解释路径在不同规模企业里的适用性，并提出两种解释路径不是相互竞争的关系，它们对不同规模的企业有着不一样的适用性。文章对制度化产权和家族管理模式、理性化的企业运作、源自政府的支持对企业效率的实际影响提出了一些新的思考。

关键词: 温州模式 , 民营企业 , 效率机制

Abstract:

This paper focuses on the origin of the mechanism for the efficiency in running the privatelyowned enterprises that are after the “Wenzhou Model” since the inception of the open policy and reform. There have been two explanations for that—the organization’s internal management policy improvement or the supportive resources provided by the local 〖JP2〗government and the local market. This paper examines the power of each explanation in the enterprises of different sizes， and sees no competition between the two. Their respective applicability varies with varying sizes of the organizations. The paper also reports some new insights upon the property relationship of institutionalism， familymodel business management， rational business operation， and the actual impact of governmental support on the enterprises.

Key words: Wenzhou model , privatelyowned enterprises , mechanism for efficiency

李沛. Where Efficiency Comes from： An Examination of the Development of PrivatelyOwned Enterprises in Wenzhou[J]. 社会杂志.

Li Pei. Where Efficiency Comes from： An Examination of the Development of PrivatelyOwned Enterprises in Wenzhou[J]. Chinese Journal of Sociology.

参考文献

Alchian, Armen A. and H. Demsetz. 1972.“Production, Information Costs, and Economic Organization”. 〖WT《XB》〗American Economic Review〖WT《B》〗, Vol. 62, No.5.
Burt, Ronald. 1992. 〖WT《XB》〗Stuctural Holes： The Social Structure of Competition. Cambridge〖WT《B》〗： Harvard University Press. 
Cao, Zhenghan. 2005. 〖WT《XB》〗How Do Concepts Shape the Institution〖WT《B》〗. Shanghai： Shanghai People’s Publishing House.［曹正汉． 2005．观念如何塑造制度［M］．上海：上海人民出版社．］
Chen, Ping〖KG-*9〗. 2007. 〖WT《XB》〗A Study on the Management Approach of Wenzhou’s PrivatelyOwned Enterprise〖WT《B》〗. Shanghai： Academia Press. ［陈平． 2007．温州民营企业管理模式研究［M］．上海：学林出版社．］
Coase, Ronald, et al. 1995. 〖WT《XB》〗Property Rights and Institutional Transition: Symposium on Property Rights 〖JP2〗and New Institutionalism Schools of Thought〖WT《B》〗. Shanghai： Shanghai People’s〖JP〗 Publishing House.［罗纳德·科斯等． 1995．财产权利与制度变迁——产权学派与新制度主义学派译文集［M］．上海：上海人民出版社．］
Grannovetter, Mark. 1985. “Economic Action and Social Structure： the Problem of Embeddedness”. 〖WT《XB》〗American Journal of Sociology,〖WT《B》〗 Vol.91, No.3. 
Grannovetter, Mark. 1992. “Economic Institutions as Social Constructions： A Framework for Analysis”. 〖WT《XB》〗Acta Sociologica,〖WT《B》〗 Vol.35, No.1.
Grannovetter, Mark. 2006. 〖WT《B》〗“A Theoretical Agenda for Economic Sociology”〖WT《B》〗, in 〖WT《XB》〗The New Economic Sociology： Developments in An Emerging Field〖WT《B》〗, edited by Mauro Guillen, et al. Beijing： Social Sciences Academic Press.［马克·格兰诺维特． 2006．经济社会学的理论日程［G］∥莫洛·纪廉等，编．新经济社会学：一门新兴学科的发展．北京：社会科学文献出版社．］
〖JP2〗Guillen, Mauro, et al. 2006. 〖WT《B》〗“The Revival of Economic Sociology〖WT《B》〗”， in 〖WT《XB》〗The New Economic Sociology： Developments in An Emerging Field〖WT《B》〗, edited by Mauro Guillen, et al. Beijing： Social Sciences Academic Press.［莫洛·纪廉等． 2006．经济社会学的复兴［G］∥莫洛·纪廉等，编．新经济社会学：一门新兴学科的发展．北京：社会科学文献出版社．］〖JP〗
Jin, Yongxing〖KG-*9〗. 1999. 〖WT《XB》〗A Study on the Development of Wenzhou’s Enterprise Groups〖WT《B》〗. Beijing： Social Sciences Academic Press.［金勇兴． 1999．温州企业集团发展研究［M］．北京：社会科学文献出版社．］
Li, Peilin. 2001. 〖WT《B》〗“China’s Countryside Industrialization Approach and Model over the Past 100 Years”〖WT《B》〗, in 〖WT《XB》〗China in the 20th Century： Academic and Society〖WT《B》〗 (Sociology Volume), edited by Li Peilin. Jinan： Shandong People’s Publishing House.［李培林． 2001．中国百年来乡村工业化的道路与模式［G］∥李培林，编． 20世纪的中国：学术与社会（社会学卷）．济南：山东人民出版社．］
Lin, Nan. 1995. “Local Market Socialism： Local Corporation in action in Rural China”. 〖WT《XB》〗Theory and Society〖WT《B》〗, Vol.24.
Lin, Yifu. 1994. 〖WT《XB》〗China’s Miracle： Development Strategies and Economic Reforms〖WT《B》〗. Shanghai： Shanghai People’s Publishing House.［林毅夫． 1994．中国的奇迹：发展战略与经济改革［M］．上海：上海人民出版社．］
Ma, Jinlong. 2001. “The Institutional and Managing Innovation in Wenzhou’s PrivatelyOwned Enterprises”. 〖WT《XB》〗Jiangnan Forum〖WT《B》〗 (2). （in Chinese）［马津龙．2001．温州民营企业的制度创新和管理创新［J］．江南论坛（2）．］
Miller, Gary. 2003. 〖WT《XB》〗Managerial Dilemmas： The Political Economy of Hierarchy〖WT《B》〗, translated by Wang Yong et al. Shanghai： Shanghai People’s Publishing House.［盖瑞·米勒． 2003．管理困境——科层的政治经济学［M］．王勇等，译．上海：上海人民出版社．］
Nee,Victor. 1989. “Theory of Market Transition： From Redistribution to Markets in State Socialism”, 〖WT《XB》〗American Sociological Review〖WT《B》〗, Vol.54.
North, Douglass.1999. 〖WT《XB》〗The Rise of the Western World〖WT《B》〗, translated by Li Yiping and Cai Lei.Beijing： Huaxia Publishing House.［道格拉斯·诺斯． 1999．西方世界的兴起［M］．厉以平、蔡磊，译．北京：华夏出版社．］
Oi， Jean C. 1992. “Fiscal Reform and the Economic Foundations of Local State Corporatism in China”.〖WT《XB》〗 World Politics〖WT《B》〗， Vol．45，No．1．
Pan, Wei. 2003. 〖WT《XB》〗Farmers and Markets〖WT《B》〗：〖WT《XB》〗China’s Grassroots Political Power and Rural Enterprises〖WT《B》〗. Beijing： The Commercial Press.［潘维． 2003．农民与市场: 中国基层政权与乡镇企业［M］．北京：商务印书馆．］
Parish, W. and E. Michelson. 1996. “Politics and Markets： Dual Transformations”. 〖WT《XB》〗American Journal of Sociology〖WT《B》〗, Vol.101.
Polanyi, Karl. 2007. 〖WT《XB》〗The Great Transformation: The Political and Economic Origins of Our Time〖WT《B》〗, translated by Feng Gang and Liu Yang. Hangzhou： Zhejiang People’s Publishing House.［卡尔·波兰尼． 2007．大转型: 我们时代的政治和经济起源［M］．冯钢、刘阳，译．杭州：浙江人民出版社．］
RonaTas, A.1994. “The First Shall Be Last? Entrepreneurship and Communist Cadres in the Transition from Socialism”. 〖WT《XB》〗American Journal of Sociology〖WT《B》〗, Vol.100.
Scott, Richard. 2002. 〖WT《XB》〗Organizations〖WT《B》〗: 〖WT《XB》〗Rational Natural and Open Systems〖WT《B》〗, translated by Huang Yang〖KG-*9〗. Beijing： Huaxia Publishing House.［理查德·斯格特． 2002．组织理论［M］．黄洋，译．北京：华夏出版社．］
Shi， Jinchuan and Zhu Kangdui. 2002. “Wenzhou Model Study： Review and Outlook”. 〖WT《XB》〗Zhejiang Social Sciences〖WT《B》〗 (3). （in Chinese）［史晋川、朱康对． 2002．温州模式研究：回顾与展望［J］．浙江社会科学（3）．］
Shi， Jinchuan, et al. 2002. 〖WT《XB》〗Institutional Transition and Economic Development： The Study of Wenzhou Model〖WT《B》〗. Hangzhou： Zhejiang University Press. ［史晋川，等． 2002．制度变迁与经济发展：温州模式研究［M］．杭州：浙江大学出版社．］
Swedberg, Richard. 2005. 〖WT《XB》〗Principles of Economic Sociology〖WT《B》〗, translated by Zhou Changcheng. Beijing： China Renmin University Press.［理查德·斯威德伯格． 2005．经济社会学原理［M］．北京：中国人民大学出版社．］
Uzzi, Brian. 2008. 〖WT《B》〗“Embeddedness in the Making of Financial Capital： How Social Relations and Networks Benefit Firms Seeking Finance”〖WT《B》〗, in 〖WT《XB》〗Organizational Management and Organizational Innovation〖WT《B》〗. Shanghai： Shanghai People’s Publishing House.［布兰·乌兹． 2008．金融资本获得中的嵌入性：社会关系和网络如何令公司在金融资本寻求中获益［G］∥李友梅等, 编．组织管理与组织创新．上海：上海人民出版社．］
Walder, Andrew. 1995, “Local Governments as Industrial Firms： An Organizational Analysis of China’s Transitional Economy ”. 〖WT《XB》〗American Journal of Sociology〖WT《B》〗, Vol.101.
〖JP2〗Wang, Hansheng 〖WT《XB》〗et al〖WT《B》〗. 1990. “Industrialization and Social Differentiation： China’s Countryside Social Transition since Reforms”. 〖WT《XB》〗Observations on China’s Countryside〖WT《B》〗 (4). （in Chinese）［王汉生等． 1990．工业化与社会分化：改革以来中国农村的社会变迁［J］．农村经济与社会（4）．］〖JP〗
Wang， Xiaoyi. 1996. “Family System and Rural Industrial DevelopmentA Comparative Study on Rural Areas of Guangdong and Wenzhou”. 〖WT《XB》〗China Social Sciences Quarterly〖WT《B》〗（Autumn volume）. (in Chinese) ［王晓毅． 1996．家族制度与乡村工业发展——广东和温州两地农村的比较研究［J］．中国社会科学季刊（香港·秋季卷）．］
Wenzhou Municipal Bureau of Statistics. 2006. 〖WT《XB》〗Wenzhou Statistical Yearbook (2005)〖WT《B》〗. Beijing: China Statistics Press.［温州市统计局． 2006．温州统计年鉴（2005）［M］．北京：中国统计出版社．］
White, Harrison. 1981. “Where Do Markets Come From?”. 〖WT《XB》〗American Journal of Sociology〖WT《B》〗, Vol.87.
Williamson, Oliver. 2006. 〖WT《B》〗“Transaction Cost Economics： The Governance of Contractual Relations〖WT《B》〗”, in 〖WT《XB》〗Enterprise Systems and Market Organizations〖WT《B》〗, edited by Chen Yu. Shanghai： Shanghai People’s Publishing House.［奥利弗·威廉姆森． 2006．交易费用经济学：契约关系的规制［G］∥陈郁，编．企业制度与市场组织．上海：上海人民出版社．］
Zhang, Renshou & Li Hong〖KG-*9〗. 1990. 〖WT《XB》〗The Study of Wenzhou Model〖WT《B》〗. Beijing： China Social Sciences Press.［张仁寿、李红． 1990．温州模式研究［M］．北京：中国社会科学出版社．］
Zhang， Renshou, 2000. “PrivatelyOwned Enterprises Need Further Innovation”. 〖WT《XB》〗Chinese Rural Economy〖WT《B》〗 (8). (in Chinese) ［张仁寿． 2000．民营企业需要再创新［J］．中国农村经济（8）．］
Zhou, Xinghong〖KG-*9〗. 2001. “Wenzhou Local Government’s Functional Innovations”, in 〖WT《XB》〗Institutional Transition and Economic Development： The Study of Wenzhou Model〖WT《B》〗, edited by Shi Jinchuan, et al. Hangzhou： Zhejiang University Press.［周星宏． 2001．温州地方政府的职能创新［G］∥史晋川等，编. 制度变迁与经济发展：温州模式研究．杭州：浙江大学出版社．］
Zhu, Kangdui. 1997. “Alternative Rural Culture and Wenzhou’s Rural Household Economy”. 〖WT《XB》〗Zhejiang Social Sciences〖WT《B》〗 (5). (in Chinese) ［朱康对． 1997．小农家文化与温州农村家庭经济［J］．浙江社会科学（5）．］

责任编辑：田青
英文编校：Seneca Goodman