寻求变革还是安于现状：中产阶级社会政治态度测量

社会杂志 ›› 2011, Vol. 31 ›› Issue (2): 125-154.

寻求变革还是安于现状：中产阶级社会政治态度测量

李春玲中国社会科学院社会学研究所

李春玲中国社会科学院社会学研究所

出版日期:2011-03-21 发布日期:2011-03-21
通讯作者: 李春玲中国社会科学院社会学研究所 E-mail:licl@cass. org. cn
作者简介:李春玲中国社会科学院社会学研究所 
基金资助:
本研究受2010年度国家社会科学基金项目“中国社会中间阶层发展状况与趋势研究”（10BSH011）资助

Pursuing Change or Maintaining the Status Quo? Measurement of the Sociopolitical Attitudes of the Middle Class

Li Chunling, Institute of Sociology, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences

Li Chunling, Institute of Sociology, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences

Online:2011-03-21 Published:2011-03-21
Contact: Li Chunling, Institute of Sociology, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences E-mail:licl@cass. org. cn
About author:Li Chunling, Institute of Sociology, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences 
Supported by:
The research was supported by the project “Situation and Trend of Middle Cdass in Chinese Society” of National Social Sciences Foundation（10BSH011）.

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

本文试图探讨中产阶级的社会政治态度，并由此判断中产阶级的社会政治功能。基于一项2006年的全国调查数据，笔者设计了一套态度测量量表，区分政治保守主义与政治自由主义的态度特征，分析中产阶级的主要态度倾向。研究发现中国中产阶级内部存在着多种价值取向，既有保守主义的成份也有自由主义的成份，中产阶级在当前肯定是一种社会稳定力量，但其未来走向还存在一些不确定因素。

Abstract:

This paper is to examine the sociopolitical attitudes of the middle class in China and thereby predict the sociopolitical role of the middle class. The key issue is whether the emerging middle class in China is a stabilizer for or a threat to the existing social system. Using a national survey dataset of 2006, the author developed a set of attitude scales to differentiate the major attitudinal features of the political conservatives from those of the political liberals in the analysis of the attitudinal trend of the middle class. The study found diversity in the values of the middle class, showing a mixture of conservatism and liberalism. China’s middle class is certainly a stabilizing force at present but there are uncertain factors that may affect its future role. 

李春玲. 寻求变革还是安于现状：中产阶级社会政治态度测量[J]. 社会杂志, 2011, 31(2): 125-154.

Li Chunling. Pursuing Change or Maintaining the Status Quo? Measurement of the Sociopolitical Attitudes of the Middle Class [J]. Chinese Journal of Sociology, 2011, 31(2): 125-154.

参考文献（References）

Burkhart，Ross E． and Michael S． LewisBeck． 1994． “Comparative Democracy： The Economic Development Thesis．” 〖WTBX〗American Political Science Review 〖WTBZ〗（88）：903〖CD*2〗910．
Chen， Jie and Chunlong Lu． 2006． “Does China’s Middle Class Think and Act Democratically Attitudinal and Behavioral Orientations toward Urban SelfGovernment．” 〖WTBX〗Journal of Chinese Political Science〖WTBZ〗（11）：1〖CD*2〗20．
曹敏．2006．中产阶级的政治文化转型与政治稳定：韩国的视域［J］．广州社会主义学院学报（3）．［Cao Ming． 2006． “Political Culture Transformation of Middle Class and Political Stability： South Korea’s Perspectives．”〖WTBX〗Journal of Guangzhou Institute of Socialism 〖WTBZ〗（3）．（in Chinese）］
杜伟、唐丽霞．2004．析日本新中产阶级的形成与社会影响［J］．贵州师范大学学报（社会科学版）（3）．［Du Wei and Tang Lixia． 2004． “An Analysis on the Formation of Japan’s Middle Class and Its Impacts．” 〖WTBX〗Journal of Guizhou Normal University 〖WTBZ〗（Social Science Edition） 3．（in Chinese）］
Eccleshall， R． 1994．〖WTBX〗Political Ideologies： An Introduction．〖WTBZ〗 London： Routledge．
Eulau， Heinz． 1956． “Identification with Class and Political Perspective．” 〖WTBX〗Journal of Politics 〖WTBZ〗（18）：232〖CD*2〗53．
Glassman， Ronald M．1995．〖WTBX〗The Middle Class and Democracy in SocioHistorical Perspective. 〖WTBZ〗The Netherlands： E． J． Brill．〖WTBX〗 
〖WTBZ〗Glassman， Ronald M．1997．〖WTBX〗 The New Middle Class and Democracy in Global Perspective．〖WTBZ〗London： Macmillan Press．
Goldthorpe， John H． 1987．〖WTBX〗Social Mobility and Class Structure in Modern Britain〖WTBZ〗． Oxford： Clarendon Press．
Goodman， David S． G． (eds．) 2008．〖WTBX〗The New Rich in China． Future rulers， Present Lives〖WTBZ〗． London： Routledge．
郭继光．2000．浅析新加坡中产阶级［J］．东南亚研究（3）．［Gou Jiguang．2000． “An Preliminary Analysis of Middle Class of Singapore． ”〖WTBX〗 Southeast Asia Studies 〖WTBZ〗（3）．（in Chinese）］
何平立．2006．现实与神话：东亚中产阶级与政治转型［J］．上海大学学报（社会科学版）（2）．［He Pingli． 2006． “Reality and Myth： Middle Class of Eastern Asia and Political Transition．” 〖WTBX〗Journal of Shanghai University〖WTBZ〗（Social Science Edition）（2）．（in Chinese）］
Hsiao，HsinHuang Michael． 1999．〖WTBX〗East Asian Middle Classes in Comparative Perspective〖WTBZ〗． Taipei：Academia Sinica．
Hsiao，HsinHuang Michael． 2001．〖WTBX〗Exploration of the Middle Classes in Southeast Asia．〖WTBZ〗Taipei：Academia Sinica．
Hsiao，HsinHuang Michael． 2006．〖WTBX〗The Changing Faces of the Middle Classes in AsiaPacific〖WTBZ〗． Taipei：Academia Sinica．
Hsiao，HsinHuang and Alvin Y． So． 1999． “The Making of the East Asian Middle Classes．” In 〖WTBX〗East Asian Middle Classes in Comparative Perspective〖WTBZ〗， edited by HsinHuang〖WTBX〗〖WTBZ〗Michael〖WTBX〗〖WTBZ〗Hsiao． Taipei：Academia Sinica：3〖CD*2〗49．
Huntington， Samuel P．1991．〖WTBX〗The Third Wave： Democratization in the Late Twentieth Century．〖WTBZ〗Norman： University of Oklahoma Press．
Leach， R． 2002．〖WTBX〗Political Ideology in Britain．〖WTBZ〗 London： Palgrave．
李春玲．2005．断裂与碎片：当代中国社会阶层分化实证分析［M］．北京：社会科学文献出版社．〖JP2〗［Li Chunling． 2005．〖WTBX〗 Cleavage or Fragment： An Empirical Analysis on the Social Stratification of the Contemporary China．〖WTBZ〗 Beijing： Social Science Academic Press．］〖JP〗
李春玲，主编．2009．比较视野下的中产阶级形成：过程、影响以及社会经济后果［M］．北京：社会科学文献出版社．［Li Chunling（eds．）． 2009．〖WTBX〗Formation of Middle Class in Comparative Perspective： Process， Influence and Socioeconomic Consequences．〖WTBZ〗Beijing： Social Science Academic Press．］〖WTBX〗
Lipset， Seymour Martin． 1963．〖WTBX〗Political Man： The Social Bases of Politics．〖WTBZ〗New York， Anchor Books．
Lipset， Seymour Martin． 1959． “Some Social Requisites of Democracy： Economic Development and Political Legitimacy．” 〖WTBX〗American Political Science Review 〖WTBZ〗（53）：69〖CD*2〗105．〖JP〗
李路路．2008．中间阶层的社会功能：新的问题取向和多维分析框架［J］．中国人民大学学报（4）．［Li Lulu． 2008． “Social Function of Middle Class： New Issue Perspective and Multiple Analytical Framework．” 〖WTBX〗Journal of Renmin University of China〖WTBZ〗（4）．（in Chinese）］ 
李路路、李升．2009．殊途异类：当代中国城镇中产阶级的类型化分析［G］//李春玲，主编．比较视野下的中产阶级形成：过程、影响以及社会经济后果．北京：社会科学文献出版社：195〖CD*2〗213．［Li Lulu and Li sheng． 2009． “Different Paths and Patterns： Categorical Analysis of Middle Class of Contemporary Chinese Cities．”In 〖WTBX〗Formation of Middle Class in Comparative Perspective： Process， Influence and Socioeconomic Consequences，〖WTBZ〗edited by Li Chunling．〖WTBX〗〖WTBZ〗Beijing： Social Science Academic Press．］
李路曲．2000．东亚的中产阶级、市民社会与政治转型［J］．当代亚太（11）．［Li Luqu． 2000． “Middle Class， Civil Society and Political Transition．” 〖WTBX〗Contemporary AsiaPacific Studies 〖WTBZ〗（11）．（in Chinese）］
李强．2001．关于中产阶级和中间阶层［J］．中国人民大学学报（2）．［Li Qiang． 2001． “On Middle Class and Middle Strata．”〖WTBX〗 Journal of Renmin University of China〖WTBZ〗（2）．（in Chinese）］
刘长江．2006．国家的现代化路径与中产阶级的类型［J］．江苏行政学院学报（4）．［Liu Changjiang． 2006． “Modernization Path and Types of Middle Class．” 〖WTBX〗Journal of Jiangsu Administration Institute〖WTBZ〗（4）．（in Chinese）］
刘欣．2009．中国城市的阶层结构与中产阶级的定位［G］//李春玲，主编．比较视野下的中产阶级形成：过程、影响以及社会经济后果．北京：社会科学文献出版社：147〖CD*2〗159．［Liu Xin． 2009． “Class Structure and Position of Middle Class in Chinese Cities．” In 〖WTBX〗Formation of Middle Class in Comparative Perspective： Process， Influence and Socioeconomic Consequences，〖WTBZ〗edited by Li Chunling．Beijing： Social Science Academic Press．］
C．莱特·米尔斯． 2006．周晓虹，译．白领：美国的中产阶级［M］．南京：南京大学出版社．［C．Wright Mills． 2006．〖WTBX〗White Collar： The American Middle Classes〖WTBZ〗， translated by Zhou Xiaohong， Nanjing：Nanjing University Press．］
Nisbet， R． 1986．〖WTBX〗Conservatism〖WTBZ〗． Buckingham： Open University Press．
Johnston， Alastair Iain． 2004． “Chinese Middle Class Attitudes Towards International Affairs： Nascent Liberalization?” 〖WTBX〗The China Quarterly〖WTBZ〗 179： 603〖CD*2〗628．
Jones， David Martin．1998． “Democratization， Civil Society and Illiberal Middle Class Culture in Pacific Asia．” 〖WTBX〗Comparative Politics〖WTBZ〗（2）．
Jones， David Martin and David Brown．1994． “Singapore and the Myth of the Liberalizing Middle Class．” 〖WTBX〗Pacific Review 〖WTBZ〗7（1）： 79〖CD*2〗87．
Walsh， Katherine Cramer， M． Kent Jennings， and Laura Stoker． 2004．“The Effects of Social Class Identification on Participatory Orientations towards Government．” 〖WTBX〗British Journal of Political Science〖WTBZ〗（34）： 469〖CD*2〗495．
Wright， Erik Olin． 1979．〖WTBX〗 Class Structure and Income Determination．〖WTBZ〗 New York： Academic Press．
Wright， Erik Olin． 1985．〖WTBX〗Classes〖WTBZ〗． London： Verso．
张翼．2009．中产阶级是社会稳定器吗？［G］//李春玲，主编．比较视野下的中产阶级形成：过程、影响以及社会经济后果．北京：社会科学文献出版社：231〖CD*2〗251．［Zhang Yi． 2009． “Is the Middle Class a Social Stabilizer?” In 〖WTBX〗Formation of Middle Class in Comparative Perspective： Process， Influence and Socioeconomic Consequences，〖WTBZ〗edited by Li Chunling． Beijing： Social Science Academic Press．］
周晓虹，主编．2005．中国中产阶级调查［M］．北京：社会科学文献出版社．［Zhou Xianhong（eds．）．2005．〖WTBX〗A Survey on China’s Middle Class．〖WTBZ〗 Beijing： Social Science Academic Press．］
周晓虹．2002．中产阶级：何以可能与何以可为？［J］．江苏社会科学（6）．［Zhou Xiaohong．2002． “Middle Class： What are Possibilities and Capabilities？” 〖WTBX〗Jiangshu Social Sciences〖WTBZ〗（6）．（in Chinese）］

责任编辑：李聆
实习编辑：肖日葵