社会杂志

• 论文 • 上一篇    下一篇

群体性事件中的原始抵抗——以浙东海村环境抗争事件为例

*作者1:李晨璐 中国人民大学社会学系
作者 2: 赵旭东 中国人民大学人类学研究所   

  1. *作者1:李晨璐 中国人民大学社会学系
    作者 2: 赵旭东 中国人民大学人类学研究所
  • 出版日期:2012-09-20 发布日期:2012-09-20
  • 通讯作者: 作者2: 赵旭东 中国人民大学人类学研究所 E-mail:zhaoxudong@ruc.edu.cn
  • 作者简介:*作者1:李晨璐 中国人民大学社会学系 作者 2: 赵旭东 中国人民大学人类学研究所

The Primitive Resistance in Group Events: A Resistant Case Against the Environment in Village Hai, Eastern Zhejiang Province

Author 1: LI Chenlu, Department of Sociology, Renmin University of China;
Author 2: ZHAO Xudong, Institute of Anthropology, Renmin University of China   

  1. Author 1: LI Chenlu, Department of Sociology, Renmin University of China;
    Author 2: ZHAO Xudong, Institute of Anthropology, Renmin University of China
  • Online:2012-09-20 Published:2012-09-20
  • Contact: Author 2: ZHAO Xudong, Institute of Anthropology, Renmin University of China E-mail:zhaoxudong@ruc.edu.cn
  • About author:Author 1: LI Chenlu, Department of Sociology, Renmin University of China; Author 2: ZHAO Xudong, Institute of Anthropology, Renmin University of China

摘要:

在农民维权事件愈加复杂的背景下,抵抗的组织性、政治性研究也随之深化。在现实层面上,此种取向有其必要性。然而,抗争是一个过程,在复杂的抗争之前,往往存在着原始的、简单的、农民自发产生的抗争方式。这些抗争手段是过往经验在农民记忆中的映射,出于自卫的本能,如自发形成的打砸、拦路、跪拜等等。作为行动上的表达,村民们通过最直接的方式保护自己,尽管杂乱但也显现了一定的效用,如若处理不当,则会形成极端抗争事件;作为心理上的表达,村民以过往经验躲避灾祸,重构他们对行为的认知和意义。原始抗争方式的实施包涵了抵抗、延续和反思。

关键词: 原始抵抗 , 环境事件 , 农民维权

Abstract:

 As the resistance of farmers becomes increasingly complex, the research on the organization and politics of farmers’ protests for their rights goes more in depth. To be realistic, this approach is necessary. However, as resistance is a process, the form prior to a complex protest is usually primitive, simple, and selfgenerated. This primitive resistance is defined as “resistance in the early stage which lacks careful planning or organization and is spontaneously initiated by farmers with their own volition.” Being “primitive” is relative to being “complex,” it has its own unique fighting ethics. This resistance form has its roots in the farmers’ experiential cognition and is out of their instinct for selfdefense. It is recognized as an effective way to solve problems, focusing more on their own “reason” rather than “legitimacy.”This paper takes a protest in Village Hai, Eastern Zhejiang province, as an example to describe the sea villagers’ initial stage of their protest against the environment during which the farmers spontaneously used resisting forms such as road blocking, verbal abuse, smashing, and worship as their own way to protect themselves. These forms of resistance were somewhat effective in that they had sent the chemical factory warnings, expressed their demands, and showed their own way of thinking and acting. As a behavioral expression, the villagers protected themselves by the most direct way, effective even not so organized. If handled improperly, the event might have evolved into an intense mass struggle, becoming a factor of social unrest. As a psychological expression, the villagers’ primitive resistance was backed up by the value system naturally formed in the village society by the villagers who had avoided disasters and reconstructed their action knowledge with their past experiences. Utilization of the primitive resistance included protest, maintenance, and rethinking.

Key words: environmental events, , primitive resistance, , rights protection