社会杂志

• 专题:行政发包制研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

政治市场想象与中国国家治理分析——兼评周黎安的行政发包制理论

  

  1. 冯仕政 中国人民大学社会与人口学院
  • 出版日期:2014-11-20 发布日期:2014-11-20
  • 通讯作者: 冯仕政 中国人民大学社会与人口学院 E-mail:fengsz@ruc.edu.cn

The Political Market Imagination and the Analysis on China’s Governance:A Comment on Zhou Li-An’s Theory of Administrative Subcontract

  1. FENG Shizheng, the School of Sociology and Population Studies, Renmin University of China
  • Online:2014-11-20 Published:2014-11-20
  • Contact: FENG Shizheng, the School of Sociology and Population Studies, Renmin University of China E-mail:fengsz@ruc.edu.cn

摘要: 近年来,经济学越来越多地介入有关中国国家治理问题的研究。经济学对这一问题的关注始终围绕关于国家的“政治市场想象”展开。该想象有三个核心关切,即国家的市场性、多主体性和政治性。周黎安的“行政发包制”理论在这三个维度的每一个方面都有重要发展,将经济学的中国国家治理研究推进到一个新的高度。但“政治市场想象”重视国家的市场性而轻忽其政治性的倾向,也使周黎安模型对权力问题的分析较为薄弱,以致造成核心概念的界定不够清晰等问题。尽管如此,“政治市场想象”仍为中国国家治理研究提供了一个颇有启发性和整合性的思想框架。

关键词: 国家治理, 政治市场 , 行政发包制

Abstract: In recent years economists have shown great interest in studying China’s governance. Despite differences, their studies share a common imagination about the Chinese state, named “political market” in this paper. In this imagination, three dimensions of Chinese state have been paid special attention to, that is, marketability, multiagencyorientation, and politicalness. Zhou LiAn’s theory of administrative subcontract has made important contribution to all these three areas, and ends up greatly advancing the research on China’s governance from an economic perspective. The political market imagination, however, tends to overemphasize the marketability of the state at the expense of slighting its politicalness. Just in the same vein of bias, Zhou’s article is in a weak position to specify the property and function of the state’s power, and to define the concepts related. Despite this, the political market imagination and Zhou’s theory have still provided the scholars, including those outside economics, with a proactive, integrative, and analytical framework based on which they can build their theorization on China’s governance.

Key words: China’s governance, political market , administrative subcontract