社会杂志 ›› 2025, Vol. 45 ›› Issue (6): 117-144.

• 论文 • 上一篇    下一篇

“典型”的困境:资源—任务关系视角下的基层示范创建研究

李振(), 刘洋   

  • 出版日期:2025-11-20 发布日期:2026-01-20
  • 作者简介:李振  山东大学政治学与公共管理学院、山东大学国家治理研究院,E-mail: cuhklizhen@126.com
    刘洋  山东大学政治学与公共管理学院

Dilemma of Dianxing: A Study on Model Construction at Grassroots Governance from the Perspective of Resource-Task Relationships

Zhen LI(), Yang LIU   

  • Online:2025-11-20 Published:2026-01-20
  • About author:LI Zhen, School of Political Science and Public Administration, Institute of State Governance, Shandong University, E-mail: cuhklizhen@126.com
    LIU Yang, School of Political Science and Public Administration, Shandong University

摘要:

“典型创建”是中国共产党从革命战争年代以来一直保有的治理机制,但当下的基层典型却陷入可复制性不足和经验提炼“悬浮化”的困境。本文基于“资源—任务”关系的分析框架,以L县乡村振兴示范创建实践为案例,分析基层典型的创建逻辑及典型陷入困境的发生机制。研究发现:治理资源的选择性分配既未带来组织任务承载力的实质提升,还降低了典型的可复制性,基层难以通过典型创建解决人力资源缺乏的问题;典型身份的获得不仅引发了典型单位及其成员角色的紧张,还带来了大量的派生任务,特别是信息生产的负担。两条逻辑线合并所形成的资源选择性分配和组织任务承载能力的不适配,最终导致典型困境的形成。

关键词: 典型创建, 治理资源, 任务承载, 基层治理

Abstract:

The mechanism of Model Construction(dianxing chuangjian典型创建) has served as one of the pivotal governance strategies for the CPC since the revolutionary era. Relevant academic research has generally approached the topic in three categories. Identifying and nurturing exemplary models has become a key approach for governments at all levels to advance rural revitalization and enhance the effectiveness of grassroots governance. However, the models at the grassroots level, which serve to attract the resources and attentions from local governments, now face the dilemma characterised by lack of the replicability, weakened capacity for experiential exploration, and"suspension" of knowledge production. This paper proposes a framework based on the relationship between"resources and workload". Using the rural revitalisation initiative in County L as a case study, it analyses the logic of model creation and the mechanisms leading to the difficulties in current grassroots governance practices. This analysis is grounded in the field investigation and in-depth interviews with participants in the government. Under the logic of resource allocation, exemplary models have become a crucial foundation for local governments to secure project fundings and attentions from higher level authorities. However, the selective allocation of governance resources has failed to substantially enhance the task capacity of grassroots organizations, resulting in short in representation. Moreover, the shortage of high quality human resources is another challenge that grassroots units struggle to overcome through model construction. Under the organizational task logic, being an exemplary model often brings new role tensions, significant increase of derivative tasks, particularly the burden of information production. The mismatch between resource allocation and organizational task-bearing capacity resulting from the convergence of these two logics led to the formation of the aforementioned model construction dilemma.

Key words: model construction, governance resource, workload bearing, grassroots governance