社会杂志 ›› 2021, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (2): 56-86.

• 专题一:家庭与婚姻观念的变迁与实践 • 上一篇    下一篇

知变又知常:观念是如何转型的?基于浙东屿村婚育观念的考察

张文军   

  1. 北京大学社会学系
  • 发布日期:2021-03-23
  • 作者简介:张文军,E-mail:1801212321@pku.edu.cn
  • 基金资助:
    本研究获国务院参事室重点课题“中国社会变迁跟踪研究”的支持。

Change or Un-change: How Concepts Transform? A Case Study of Marriage and Childbirth Concepts in Yu Village of Eastern Zhejiang Province

ZHANG Wenjun   

  1. Department of Sociology, Peking University
  • Published:2021-03-23
  • Supported by:
    This research is supported by the Key Project of Counsellors' Office of the State Council, " A Longitudinal Study of China's Social Changes".

摘要: 通过对浙江省屿村40年来婚育观念的考察,本文发现,从恪守先婚后育这一传统的规范性观念到先育后婚在观念层面的逐渐“正常化”,经历了一个诸多因素交织的复杂过程,并展现出一条“常中有变,变中亦有常”的路径。在这一过程中,行动主体根据情势的变化对观念的内部结构适时作出调整,并通过重新生成规范助推部分传统内在精神的复位,看似完全破裂的先婚后育观念实质上以新的结构扎根于村庄的道德世界。推而言之,对于观念的讨论应当基于总体、过程和实质意义展开,而非仅根据某一环节、现象和形式作出判断。在此基础上,既需要把握传统在当下的“变异”机理,也需要真正体会变动背后的绵延之流,由此在传统与当下的勾连中理解变与常的意涵。

关键词: 先育后婚, 观念结构, 仪式, 转型

Abstract: An investigation of the concept of marriage and childbirth in Yu Village of Zhejiang Province over the past 40 years finds that the change from the conventional normative concept of "having children after marriage" to the wide acceptance of "having children before marriage" can be explained as a trade-off strategy against the one-child policy to secure the continuity of family name. When the One Child policy ended, some families in the village once again adhered to the norm of having children after marriage. However, with the skyrocketed cost of marriage involving in luxury weddings and new houses, "having children before marriage" came back in fashion again in the village since 2010. Judging from the number of children born before marriage in the village, it seems that the traditional concept of having children after marriage has almost been abandoned. Nevertheless, if one examines the structure of meaning behind the now much expanded engagement ceremony, one can see it essentially redefines the "witness" and "acknowledgement" for marriage and childbearing. The elaborated engagement ceremony helps coping with the moral crisis of childbirth before marriage. In so doing, people adjust the concept structure to suit different situations and reconstruct the norms so as to carry on the spirit of certain tradition. This reflects the old saying of "changing in constant and constant in changing." Therefore, the discussion of concept change should not be simply based on a particular segment, or a phenomenon, or a form. Instead, one needs to look at the whole landscape, mechanism, and substance of concept change. It is necessary not only to grasp the "mutation" mechanism of tradition but also to truly appreciate the continuity behind the change, so as to reach a more fundamental understanding of the social structure in connection between tradition and the present.

Key words: having children before marriage, concept structure, ritual, transformation