社会杂志 ›› 2021, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (3): 39-62.

• 专题一: 《江村经济》:新视野与新材料 • 上一篇    下一篇

城乡关系及其现代化:对费孝通《江村经济》与《茧》的比较

杨清媚   

  1. 中国政法大学社会学院
  • 发布日期:2021-05-22
  • 作者简介:杨清媚,E-mail:qingmei_yang@163.com
  • 基金资助:
    本文受2019中国政法大学钱端升青年学者项目(项目编号10820730)支持。

Urban and Rural Relationship and Its Modernization:A Comparison Between Fei Xiaotong’s Peasant Life in China and Cocoon

YANG Qingmei   

  1. School of Sociology, China University of Political Science and Law
  • Published:2021-05-22
  • Supported by:
    This article is funded by (2019) Qian Duansheng Young Scholar Program of China University of Political Science and Law.

摘要: 20世纪30年代,费孝通在《江村经济》的基础上写了一部英文小说《茧》。这部小说是费孝通对中国乡村现代化过程的推演。费孝通认为,中国乡村要摆脱城市坐食者的经济控制,必须在经济、社会结构和心态上突破原有的小农经济形态。本文指出,一方面,费孝通认为中国的城市以坐食者为主体,无法产生现代性;另一方面,他承认大学是现代性的发源地,知识分子返乡办工业可以使乡村获得现代性。小说女主人公宝珠,既对传统家庭伦理有所扬弃,又没有彻底抛弃家庭到城市中追求个体主义的自由。这种中间状态正是费孝通希望看到的中国社会现代化的出路。他把乡村作为现代性的载体,同时强调保护农村社会的整体性。市镇成为一个关键的枢纽,它使乡村与现代性充分接触,使走出乡村的人与乡村维系着有机联系。因此,费孝通的现代转型理论基于乡村—市镇—城市的关系,表现为空间上的现代化。

关键词: 费孝通, “家三角”, 市镇, 坐食者, 现代化

Abstract: In the 1930s,Fei Xiaotong wrote Peasant Life in China,an academic publication based on his fieldwork of Jiang village,upon the same work he later penned a story in English called Cocoon. The novel was an extrapolation of the modernization process in rural China. Fei always believed that in order to break away from the economic control of urban “rentners”,rural China must break with the original state of small -scale peasant economy in all the aspects of economy,social structure and mentality. Through a comparison of Peasant Life in China and Cocoon,this paper attempted to argue that Fei Xiaotong advocated an intermediate state of development. He argued that both traditional Chinese towns and trading ports were dominated by “rentners”,from whom modernity could not emerge. However,he acknowledged that universities were the birthplace of modernity (Chinese universities and cities were not of the same origin),and that rural China could modernize through a way of intellectuals going back to their hometowns to start industry. In Cocoon,educated urban young people returned to their hometown and engaged in business ventures with locals. The interaction eventually brought changes to those involved and ultimately reshaped their life. Baozhu,the heroine in the story,presented an intermediate state of this transition. She broke away from the confinement of traditional husband-wife relationship and family duty but remained loyal to family and had no desire to move to the city to pursue the freedom of individuality. This intermediate state was exactly what Fei Xiaotong hoped for as the way to the modernization of Chinese society. He regarded the countryside as a vehicle for modernity,nevertheless,emphasized that the totality of rural society should be preserved to protect it from falling apart. Small towns could act a key hub that brought the countryside into full contact with modernity but kept an organic connection to the rural life for those who had left. From this perspective,Fei Xiaotong’s theory of modern transformation can be seen as spacial modernization based on a ruraltown-urban relationship.

Key words: Fei Xiaotong, “Family Triangle”, town, rentner, modernization