社会杂志 ›› 2024, Vol. 44 ›› Issue (6): 217-242.

• 论文 • 上一篇    

能力的代价与分化:第三道数字鸿沟中的数字伤害

陈福平, 谢怡景   

  • 发布日期:2024-12-13
  • 作者简介:陈福平 厦门大学社会与人类学院 E-mail:chenfuping1224@163.com;谢怡景 中共株洲市委党校
  • 基金资助:
    本研究为国家社科基金重点项目“数字社会建设中志愿服务团体的能力发展研究”(21ASH018)的阶段性成果。

The Cost and Differentiation of Ability:Digital Harms in the Third-Level Digital Divide

CHEN Fuping, XIE Yijing   

  • Published:2024-12-13
  • Supported by:
    The research was supported by National Social Science Foundation of China (21ASH018).

摘要: 第三道数字鸿沟”研究的关注点在于数字技能产生的效果差异,但实际上更多关注了收益性效果。在与“资源与占用理论”对话的基础上,本研究从“数字伤害”的角度,通过对CGSS2017调查数据的分析发现:年轻、高学历、高收入的群体以及城市居民会有更高水平的数字技能,但进而也使得他们需要面对更大的数字伤害;群体间对数字技能的负面效果会有分化的防范能力,其中,拥有高学历、高收入等位置类型的优势群体更能缓解数字伤害的影响。本研究深化了数字鸿沟研究忽视的对数字负面效果的认识,并提出在未来数字公共服务中应重视群体间对数字伤害的防范性不平等问题。

关键词: 数字鸿沟, 数字技能, 数字伤害

Abstract: The study of the third-level digital divide focuses on the differential effects produced by digital skills, often assuming the benefits of these effects while neglecting the varying capacities of different groups to guard against potential negative effects.With the application of the theory of resources and appropriation, this study analyzes the relationship between digital skills and digital negative effects from a new dimension of digital harm in the Chinese context. It also explores the inequality in the prevention of digital harm.
Based on an analysis of the 2017 data from the China General Social Survey (CGSS), the study finds that younger individuals, higher-educated, higher-income, and urban dwellers possess higher digital skills, but also by extension are exposed to higher levels of digital harm. Digital skills play a crucial mediating role between categorical inequality and digital harm. However, the study also indicates that there is a differential capacity among groups to mitigate the negative effects of digital skills, with those in positions of advantage, such as highly educated and high income, being better able to buffer against the impact of digital harm. The study deepens the understanding of the negative effects of digital skills, and highlights the potential emergence of new inequalities characterized by a widening effect gap between digital benefit and digital harm. Therefore, compared to the previous digital divides, the third digital divide exhibits greater variability and complexity among different groups.

Key words: digital divide, digital skill, digital harm