社会杂志 ›› 2025, Vol. 45 ›› Issue (6): 183-207.

• 论文 • 上一篇    下一篇

斗争、竞争与选择:价值领域分化的发生学与历史演化机制

王诗瑜()   

  • 出版日期:2025-11-20 发布日期:2026-01-20
  • 作者简介:王诗瑜  北京大学哲学系宗教学系, E-mail: wangshiyu98@pku.edu.cn

Struggle, Competition, and Selection: The Genetic and Historical Dynamics of Value-Sphere Differentiation

Shiyu WANG()   

  • Online:2025-11-20 Published:2026-01-20
  • About author:WANG Shiyu, Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies, Peking University, E-mail: wangshiyu98@pku.edu.cn

摘要:

当下的韦伯研究仍欠缺对价值领域分化的发生学与历史演化机制的论述,而这对于建立韦伯理解社会学方法论的独特性以及理解社会学与实质研究之间的关联来说非常重要。斗争、竞争与选择在价值领域的建构与分化的发生学层面与历史演化层面发挥了重要作用:由于斗争和竞争而充分发展了行动导向中工具理性的一面,且因与经济秩序和政治秩序相亲和而被模仿和传播的现代人格,面对理性化导致的人生意义危机,升华了现代社会政治领域、艺术领域与情爱领域的固有价值,创造了现世内救赎的可能性。对斗争、竞争与选择主导下的价值领域层级化分化以及现代人格塑成的发生学与历史演化机制的论述,充分尊重行动者发挥工具理性在竞争性环境中争取胜利的能动性及其面对危机主动赋予现世秩序以价值的文化创造性,能够回应理解社会学探求从个体行动出发生成超个体的秩序意义的因果—发生关联的内在要求,并服务于行动理论框架下的价值领域分化的理论建构。

关键词: 价值领域分化, 斗争, 竞争, 选择, 现代人格

Abstract:

Grounded in Max Weber's methodology of interpretive sociology, this study investigates the genetic and historical dynamics underlying value-sphere differentiation. It aims to reveal the causal-genetic connections through which supra- individual orders of meaning emerge from individual actions via conscious struggle and competition, as well as non-intentional processes of social selection. On the one hand, conscious struggles and competitions over the acquisition and monopolization of particular values and goods drive the formation of social order through purposive-rational action. On the other hand, supra-individual mechanisms of social selection, operating without the intentional participation of individual actors, filter and reproduce highly adaptive types of action and personality. Through the mechanisms of struggle, competition, and selection, the economic and political spheres, endowed with organizational superiority, have come to dominate the historical process, shaping a modern personality characterized by depersonalization and purposive rationality. The crisis of meaning produced by rationalization had in turn stimulated the sublimation of intrinsic values within responsive spheres such as politics, art, and erotic life, thereby creating the possibility of inner-worldly redemption. Based on the three-stage theory of historical evolution proposed in Intermediate Reflections, it could be argued that the formation of modern personality was rooted in the dualistic worldview established by salvation religions and was profoundly intensified within the highly competitive social relations of early modern Europe. In contrast to the monistic order of the Confucian tradition, Western Christian civilization, through its enduring political and religious tensions, cultivated a competitive personality structure centered on purposive rationality. Within the context of globalization, this personality type has acquired universal historical significance due to its strong adaptive capacity. Thus, struggle, competition, and selection elucidate not only the genetic connections between social order and personality formation but also provide a theoretical framework for extending comparative civilizational studies and for understanding and conceptualizing plural modernities.

Key words: value-sphere differentiation, struggle, competition, selection, modern personality