刻板印象内容模型的修正与发展——源于大学生群体样本的调查结果

社会杂志 ›› 2010, Vol. 30 ›› Issue (5): 193-216.

刻板印象内容模型的修正与发展——源于大学生群体样本的调查结果

高明华北京大学社会学系

高明华北京大学社会学系

出版日期:2010-09-20 发布日期:2010-09-20
通讯作者: 高明华北京大学社会学系 E-mail:gaominghua1003@gmail．com
作者简介:高明华北京大学社会学系
基金资助:
本文是北京大学社会学系方文教授主持的2008年度国家社会科学基金项目“中国社会转型：转型心理学的路径”（08BSH063）的部分中期成果

Revision and Development of the Stereotype Content Model： Research Findings Based on CollegeStudent Samples

Gao Minghua，Department of Sociology，Peking University

Gao Minghua，Department of Sociology，Peking University

Online:2010-09-20 Published:2010-09-20
Contact: Gao Minghua，Department of Sociology，Peking University E-mail:gaominghua1003@gmail．com
About author:Gao Minghua，Department of Sociology，Peking University
Supported by:
The research was supported by 2008’s National Social Science Foundation of China：“China’s Social Transition： A Path of Transition Psychology”（08BSH063）， which was led by Prof． Fang Wen in Peking University．

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

刻板印象是对社会群体及其成员固定或模式化的看法。对刻板印象形成维度的研究，被系统地总结为刻板印象内容模型（Stereotype Content Model, SCM）。本文对SCM的相关理论进行了简要梳理。作者按照SCM的典范程序，进行了有效样本为115人的试验性调查和160人的正式调查，以问卷的方式要求被调查者对21个社会群体进行分类和评价，建立起了大学生关于21个社会群体的刻板印象类型，并在此基础上进行了理论层面的探讨。本文的研究试图突破以往的SCM研究仅限于发现事实的局限，尝试对形成特定群体刻板印象背后的社会心理机制进行解释。

关键词: 公平世界信念, 刻板印象, 社会认同理论, 刻板印象内容模型

Abstract:

Stereotypes are fixed or generalized beliefs about social groups and their members． The dimensions in stereotype formation studied so far have been systematically summarized into the Stereotype Content Model or SCM． The theory of SCM is briefly introduced in the paper． Following the standard procedure of SCM， the author used a questionnaire to ask 115 college students in her pilot study and 160 college students in her formal study to classify 21 social groups and provide comments on them． The stereotype categories of the 21 social groups perceived by college students were established． A theoretical discussion was then provided． Going beyond the factfinding limitations of the traditional SCM， this paper has tried to explain the psychological mechanisms underlying the stereotypes of specific social groups．

Key words: stereotypes , social identity theory , stereotype content model （SCM）, just world belief

高明华. 刻板印象内容模型的修正与发展——源于大学生群体样本的调查结果[J]. 社会杂志, 2010, 30(5): 193-216.

Gao Minghua. Revision and Development of the Stereotype Content Model： Research Findings Based on CollegeStudent Samples[J]. Chinese Journal of Sociology, 2010, 30(5): 193-216.

参考文献

参考文献（References）

Allport， G． W．［1954］1958．The Nature of Prejudice．Cambridge， MA： AddisonWesley．
Bourdieu，P．1977．“Cultural Reproduction and Social Reproduction．” in J． Karabel and A．H．Halsey （eds．）．Power and Ideology in Education．Oxford：Oxford University Press： 494．
Brewer，M． B．1999．“The Psychology of Prejudice Ingroup Love or Outgroup Hate?” Journal of Social Issues 55（3）： 429-444．
Chiu，Chiyue．2008．“Occupational Mobility， Shared Reality， and Social Conformance．” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology．
Cuddy，A．J．C．， S．T． Fiske， and P． Glick．2004．“When Professionals Become Mothers， Warmth Doesn’t Cut the Ice．”Journal of Social Issues60（4）： 701-718．
Cuddy， A． J． C．， S． T．Fiske， V． S．Y． Kwan，et al．2009．“Stereotype Content Model across Cultures： Towards Universal Similarities and Some Differences．”British Journal of Social Psychology（48）：1-33．
方文．2008a．学科制度和社会认同［M］．北京：中国人民大学出版社．［Fang Wen．2008a．Discipline Institution and Socical Identity．Beijing：China Renmin University Press．］
方文．2008b．转型心理学：以群体资格为核心［J］．中国社会科学（4）．［Fang Wen．2008b．“Transition Psychology：The Group Membership Approach．”Social Sciences in China（4）．（in Chinese）］
Fiske， S． T． and S．E． Taylor．1991．Social Cognition （2nd ed．）．New York：：Mc GrawHill．
Fiske，S．T．，Xu Jun， A．J．C．Cuddy， and P．Glick．1999．“（Dis）respecting versus （Dis）liking： Status and Interdependence Predict Ambivalent Stereotypes of Stereotype of Competence and Warmth．” Journal of Social Issues 55（3）： 473-489．
Fiske， S．T．， A．J．C． Cuddy，P．Glick， and Xu Jun．2002．“A Model of （Often Mixed） Stereotype Content： Competence and Warmth Respectively Follow from Perceived Status and Competition．”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 82（6）： 878-902．
高明华．2006．教育不平等与阶层再生产——布迪厄概念框架的应用研究［D］．中央民族大学硕士论文。［Gao Minghua． 2006． “The Inequality of Education and the Reproduction of Social Class：The Practical Research of Bourdieu’s Conceptual Framework．” Master paper from Minzu University of China．］
Glick P． and S．T． Fiske．2001．“An Ambivalent Alliance： Hostile and Benevolent Sexism as Complementary Justifications for Gender Inequality．”American Psychologist 56（2）： 109-118．
Glick， P．2003．“Sacrificial Lambs Dressed in Wolves’ Clothing： Envious Prejudice， Ideology， and the Scapegoating of the Jews．”in What Social Psychology can Tell Us about the Holocaust，edtited by L．S． Newman and R． Erber．New York： Oxford University Press． 
Goffman，E．1963．Stigma： Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity．Englewood Cliffs： PrenticeHall， Inc． 
管健．2007．污名的概念发展与多维度模型建构［J］．南开学报（哲社版）（5）．［Guan Jian．2007．“The Concept Development of Stigma and the Construction of Multiple Levels Conceptual Framework．”Nankai Journal（Philosophy，Literature and Social Science Edition）（5）．（in Chinese）］
Hilton，J． L．and W． von Hippel．1996．“Stereotypes．”Annual Review of Psychology 47： 237-271．
Hong，Y． Y．， M． W． Morris， C．Y．Chiu， and V． BenetMartinez．2000．“Multicultural Minds： A dynamic Constructivists Approach to Culture and Cognition．” American Psychologists 55（7）： 709-720． 
Jost J．T． and M．R． Banaji．1994．“The Role of Stereotyping in SystemJustification and the Production of False Consciousness．”British Journal of Social Psychology 33： 1-27．
Jost J．T．， M．R． Banaji， and B．A．Nosek． 2004． “A Decade of System Justification Theory： Accumulated Evidence of Conscious and Unconscious Bolstering of the Status Quo．” Political Psychology 25（6）： 881-919．
Jost，J． T． et al．2005．“SystemJustifying Functions of Complementary Regional and Ethnic Stereotypes： CrossNational Evidence．”Social Justice Research 18（3）： 305-333． 
Kay，A．C． and J．T． Jost．2003．“Complementary Justice： Effects of ‘Poor but Happy’ and ‘Poor but Honest’ Stereotype Exemplars on System Justification and Implicit Activation of the Justice Motive．”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 85： 823-837．
Kay，A．C．，J．T． Jost， and S． Young．2005．“Victim Derogation and Victim Enhancement as Alternate Routes to System Justification．”Psychological Science 16（3）： 240-246．
Lane，R．E．［1959］2003．“The Fear of Equality．”American Political Science Review 53： 35-51．Reproduced in Political Psychology： Key Readings，edtited by J．T． Jost and J． Sidanius．New York： Psychology Press（Taylor & Francis）． 
Leach，C．W．， N． Ellemers， and M． Barreto．2007．“Group Virtue： The Importance of Morality（vs． Competence and Sociability） in the Positive Evaluation of InGroups．”Journal of Personality and Social Personality93（2）： 234-249．
Lee，T．L．and S．T． Fiske．2006．“Not an OutGroup， Not Yet an InGroup： Immigrants in the Stereotype Content Model．”International Journal of Intercultural Relations 30，751-768．
Levin S．， J． Sidanius， J．L．Rabinowitz， and C．Federico． 1998． Ethnic Identity， Legitimizing Ideologies， and Social Status： A Matter of Ideological Asymmetry， Political Psychology 19（2）： 373-392．
Lerner，M．J．1980．The Belief in A Just World： A Fundamental Delusion．New York： Plenumpress．
Lin，M． H．， V．S．Y． Kwan， A． Cheung and S．T． Fiske．2005．“Stereotype Content Model Explains Prejudice for an Envied OutGroup： Scale of AntiAsian Americans Stereotype．”Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 3（1）： 34-47．
Matsumoto， D． and S． H． Yoo．2006．“Toward a New Generation of CrossCultural Research．” Perspectives on Psychological Science， Vol．1， No．3：234-250．
Moscovici，S．2000．Social Representations： Explorations in Social Psychology．Cambridge： Polite Press．
Oyserman，D．， H．M． Coon， and M． Kemmelmeier．2002．“Rethinking Individualism and Collectivism：Evaluation of Theoretical Assumptions and MetaAnalyses．”Psychological Bulletin 128（1）： 3-72．
Palmore，E．B．1962．“Ethnophaulisms and Ethnocentrism．”American Journal of Sociology（67）： 442-445．
Peeters，G．2002．“From Good and Bad to Can and Must： Subjective Necessity of Acts Associated with Positively and Negatively Valued Stimuli．” European Journal of Social Psychology（32）： 125-136．
Phalet，K．and E． Poppe．1997．“Competence and Morality Dimensions of National and Ethnic Stereotypes： A Study in Six EasternEuropean Countries．”European Journal of Social Psychology （27）： 703-723．
Pratto，F．， D．G．Tatar， and S．ConwayLanz． 1999． “Who Gets What and Why： Determinants of Social Allocationsl．”Political Psychology 20（1）： 127-150．
Ross，J．D．， T．M．Amabile， and J．I．Steinmetz．1977．“Social Role，Social Control，and Biases in SocialPerception Process．”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 35：485-494．
Sidanius J．and F． Pratto．1999．Social Dominance：An IntergroupTheory of Social Hierarchy and Oppression．Cambridge： Cambridge University Press．
Stangor，C． and T．E． Ford．1992．“Accuracy and ExpectancyConfirming Processing Orientations and the Development Stereotypes and Prejudice．”European Review of Social Psychology （3）： 57-89．
Stangor，C． and M． Schaller．2000．“Stereotypes as Individual and Collective Representations．”in Stereotypes and Prejudice： Essential Readings， edtited by Charles Stangor．Philadelphia： Psychology Press．
Tajfel，H．1981．Human Groups and Social Categories： Studies in Social Psychology．Cambridge： Cambridge University Press．
Tajfel，H． and J． C． Turner．1986．“The Social Identity Theory of Intergroup Behaviour．”In Psychology of Intergroup Relations， edtited by S． Worchel and W．G．Austin．Chicago： NelsonHall： 7-24．
Tajfel，H．， M．G．Billig，R．P． Bundy， and C．Flament．1971．“Social Categorization and Intergroup Behaviour．”European Journal of Social Psychology 1： 149-178．
Turner， J． C．，M． A． Hogg， P． J． Oakes， S． D． Reicher， and M． Wetherell．1987．Rediscovering the Social Group： A SelfCategorization Theory．Oxford and New York： Blacewell．
佐斌、张阳阳、赵菊、王娟．2006．刻板印象内容模型：理论假设及研究［J］．心理科学进展 14（1）：138-145．［Zuo Bin，Zhang Yangyang，Zhao Ju， and Wang Juan．2006．“The Stereotype Content Model and Its Researches．”Advances in Psychological Science 14（1）．（in Chinese）］

责任编辑：路英浩