转型时期居委会的社区权力及声望研究

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

在中国城市社会变迁的转型时期，社区居民委员会的权力与声望正在经受前所未有的挑战。对南京BX区61个社区居民的随机抽样调查及分析表明：居委会目前的社区权力结构中仍以政府赋予的行政权为主，而在社区居民对其期待颇多的自治权、协管与监督权、突发事件处理权等的运用方面，居委会并未拥有足够的资源存量；社区其他营利及非营利组织在直接参与社区服务和管理的过程中多少瓜分了居委会的权力，从而影响了居委会的声望，并且随着社区居民群体在经济、社会及文化层面的进一步分化，居委会在不同社区成员中的权力与声望呈现差异化的格局。

关键词: 居民委员会 , 社区权力 , 社区声望, 初婚年龄 , 教育程度 , 职业家庭 , 社会经济特征

Abstract:

In the transformational period of the urban society， residential committees’ community power and prestige are being unprecedentedly challenged. The survey of the random sample from 61 residential communities in District BX in Nanjing demonstrates that the residential committees’ executive power still primarily comes from the government’s designation. Their resources for their residents’ most desired autonomous power， cogovernance and supervision power， and emergency management power are， however， insufficient. Other types of profit and nonprofit community organizations have taken away some of the residential committees’ power during their direct participation in community services and management， and thus have impacted the committees’ prestige as well. With further differentiation in the economic and sociocultural areas among the community dwellers， the power and prestige of the residential committees will also be differentiated among those living in different communities.


Key words: community power , community prestige , residential committee
, age of first marriage , educational attainment , occupation , family socioeconomic characteristics,

闵学勤. 转型时期居委会的社区权力及声望研究[J]. 社会杂志.

Min Xueqin. A Study on Residential Committees’ Community Power and Prestige in the Transformation Period 　　 [J]. Chinese Journal of Sociology.

参考文献

布劳，彼德．1988．社会生活中的交换与权力
[M]．李国武，译．北京：华夏出版社．
陈文新．2008．中国城市社区居委会直接选举：发展历程与现实困境
[J]．学习与实践（3）．
邓正来，等．1992．布莱克维尔百科全书
[M]．北京：中国政法大学出版社．
高鉴国．2002．美国社区权力结构的研究方法
[J]．社会（7）．
亨廷顿，塞缪尔稰．1989．变化社会中的政治秩序
[M]．王冠华，等，译．北京：生活范潦榉新知三联书店．
吉登斯，安东尼．1998．社会的构成
[M]．李康、李猛，译．北京：生活范潦榉新知三联书店．
姜振华．2007．社区参与：对社区居民与居委会互动关系的透视
[J]．中国青年政治学院学报（3）．
李友梅．2003．城市基层社会的深层权力秩序
[J]．江苏社会科学（6）．
闵学勤．2009．社区自治主体的二元区隔及其演化
[J]．社会学研究（1）．
——．2007．城市社区仿企业化管理的路径研究
[J]．江海学刊（5）．
托夫勒，阿尔温．1991．权力的转移
[M]．刘江，等，译．北京：中共中央党校出版社．
夏建中．2001．国外社会学关于城市社区权力的界定
[J]．江海学刊（5）．
熊易寒．2008．社区选举：在政治冷漠与高投票率之间
[J]．社会（3）．
徐晓军．2005．城市社区自治：权力矛盾及其协调
[J]．广东社会科学（1）．
张虎祥．2005．社区治理与权力秩序的重构——对上海市KJ社区的研究
[J]．社会（6）．
AbuLaban，Baha.1965.“The Reputational Approach in the Study of Community Power：A Critical Evaluation.” The Pacific Sociological Review， 8 （1）.
Charles，Nickie and Charlotte Aull Davies.1988.“Studying the Particular， Illuminating the General： Community Studies and Community in Wales.” Sociological Review， 53 （4）.
Clark，Terry Nichols.1967. “Power and Community Structure： Who Governs， Where， and When?” The Sociological Quarterly， 8 （4）.
——.1975.“Community Power.” Annual Review of Sociology，1 （1）.
Conway，William J.1973.“Economic Dominants and Community Power：A Reputational and Decisional Analysis.” American Journal of Economics and Sociology，32， 3 （Jul.）.
Dahl，Robert A.1958.“Acritique of the Ruling Elite Model.”American Political Science Review， 52 （1）.
Etzion，Amitai.1996.“The Responsive Community： A Communitarian Perspective.” American Sociological Review， 61， 1 （Feb.）.
Gamson，William A.1966.“Reputation and Resources in Community Politics.” The American Journal of Sociology， 72 ， 2 （Sep.）.
Hawley，Amos H.1963.“Community Power and Urban Renewal Success.”The American Journal of Sociology， 68， 4 （Jan.）.
Hunter，Floyd.1953. Community Power Structure. Chapel Hill： University of North Carolina Press.
Jackson，Pamela Irving.1978.“Community Control， Community Mobilization， and Community Political Structure in 57 U. S. Cities.” The Sociological Quarterly，19， 4 （Autumn）.
Koch，Agnes and Sanford Labovitz.1976.“Interorganizational Power in a Canadian Community： A Replication.” The Sociological Quarterly，17， 1 （Winter）
Lyon，Larry，Lawrence G. Felice，M.Ray Perryman and E.Stephen Parker.1981.“Community Power and Population Increase： An Empirical Test of the Growth Machine Model.” The American Journal of Sociology， 86， 6 （May）.
Marwell，Nicole P.2004.“Privatizing the Welfare State： Nonprofit CommunityBased Organizations as Political Actors.”American Sociological Review， 69， 2 （Apr.）.
Michel，Jerry B.1964.“The Measurement of Social Power on the Community Level： An Exploratory Study.” American Journal of Economics and Sociology，23 （2）.
Mitchell，Carey Usher and Mark LaGory.2002.“Social Capital and Mental Distress in an Impoverished Community.”City & Community， 1， 2 （Dec.）.
Pahl，R.E.1973.“Instrumentality and Community in the Process of Urbanization.” Sociological Inquiry， 43 （3 ）.
Parsons，Talcott.1957.“The Distribution of Power in American Society.”World Politics，20 （10）.
Schulze，Robert O.and Blumberg U. Leonard.1957.“The Determination of Local Power Elites.”The American Journal of Sociology，63， 3 （Nov）.
Seiler，Lauren H.1975.“Community Power Structures and Methods’ Artifacts： A Reinterpretation.”The Sociological Quarterly，16， 2 （Spring）.
Stone，Clarence N.1988.“Preemptive Power： Floyd Hunter’s ‘Community Power Structure’ Reconsidered.”American Journal of Political Science，32， 1 （Feb.）
Tastsoglou，Evangelia and Baukje Miedema.2003.“Immigrant Women and Community Development in the Canadian Maritimes： Outsiders within?” Canadian Journal of Sociology， 28， 2 （Spring）.
Walton，John.1968.“Differential Patterns of Community Power Structure： An Explanation Based on Interdependence.” The Sociological Quarterly，9 （1）.

责任编辑：路英浩

[1]	李颖晖. 教育程度与分配公平感:结构地位与相对剥夺视角下的双重考察[J]. 社会杂志, 2015, 35(1): 143-160.
[2]	曾迪洋. 生命历程理论视角下劳动力迁移对初婚年龄的影响[J]. 社会杂志, 2014, 34(5): 105-126.
[3]	黄嘉文. 教育程度、收入水平与中国城市居民幸福感 ——一项基于CGSS2005的实证分析[J]. 社会杂志, 2013, 33(5): 181-203.
[4]	王鹏 \| 吴俞晓. 初婚年龄的影响因素分析——基于CGSS2006的研究[J]. 社会杂志, 2013, 33(3): 89-110.
[5]	闵学勤. 社区权力多元认同中的公民性建构[J]. 社会杂志, 2011, 31(4): 29-48.