社会学的想象与想象的社会学:帕森斯、米尔斯社会学研究进路比较论要

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

帕森斯的社会理论和米尔斯的社会研究是“二战”后美国社会学的两条重要且独特的研究路径。帕森斯倡导社会科学中的一般理论研究，核心在于理论和经验的互惠发展的动力学，意在促进社会科学的积累性发展，但确立统一的社会科学无异于建立一种不可能实现的“学术巴别塔”。米尔斯强调的基于社会学想象的社会研究纲领，实质上是一种政治导向的社会研究，最终难免落入学术和政治的双重“想象”困境。研究范式的差异，导致他们对其身处的美国社会作出了判然有别的研究论断。进而言之，这种差异的背后隐含着研究者对现代性问题的不同态度以及政治立场上的深刻分歧。

关键词: 帕森斯, 美国社会, 米尔斯, 经验—理论体系, 社会学想象

Abstract:

Talcott Parsons' social theory and C. Wright Mills' social research represent two important and distinctive approaches in American sociology after World War II. This paper begins with a discussion of the differences between Parsons and Mills in the 1950s in order to make an in-depth investigation into the research orientation of these two sociologists. Parsons' grand theory of social science,referred by himself as his research approach,focuses on the dynamics of reciprocity between theory and experience,attempting to provide social science research with a mutual theoretical base and a common language and thus to promote an accumulative development of social science. However,building a unified social science,much like building an academic Tower of Babel,is an unachievable goal. Meanwhile,Mills' sociological imagination is a different research approach that is guided by political imagination. Inevitably,it introduces a dilemma of double sociological and political imaginations. The two research approaches understandably have resulted in very different conclusions about American society. Parsons insists on a liberal pluralistic interpretation of society and puts forward a comprehensive analysis of an interconnected common American society. In contrast,Mills is a fierce critic of American society,a power concentrated elitist society in his eyes. Nevertheless,his disenchantment never stops Mills' hope for a political "public" that would remake history. The difference in their research approaches reflects the deep political division between Parsons and Mills. As a political liberal,Parsons' views on modernity represent a type of moderate and rational optimism,while Mills' political position can only be described as a peculiar mixture of radical utopianism and nostalgic romanticism.

Key words: sociological imagination, Talcott Parsons, empirical-theoretical system, C. Wright Mills, American society

赵立玮. 社会学的想象与想象的社会学:帕森斯、米尔斯社会学研究进路比较论要[J]. 社会杂志, 2016, 36(6): 97-125.

ZHAO Liwei. Sociological Imagination and Imaginary Sociology: An Outline on the Comparison between Parsons' and Mills' Sociological Approaches[J]. Chinese Journal of Sociology, 2016, 36(6): 97-125.

参考文献

卡尔霍恩,克雷格. 2016. 激进主义探源:传统、公共领域与19世纪初的社会运动[M]. 甘会斌、陈云龙,译. 北京:北京大学出版社.
库隆,阿兰. 2000. 芝加哥学派[M]. 郑文彬,译. 北京:商务印书馆.
闻翔. 2012. 从"大众社会"到"社会学的想象力":理解米尔斯的一条内在线索[J]. 社会 32(4):1-23.
亚历山大,杰弗里·C. 2016. 古典思想的现代重建:塔尔科特·帕森斯[M]. 赵立玮,译. 北京:商务印书馆.
赵立玮. 2015. 世纪末忧郁与美国精神气质:帕森斯与古典社会理论的现代转变[J]. 社会 35(6):1-30.
Bell,Daniel.[1958]1968. "The Power Elite Reconsidered." Reprinted in C. Wright Mills and The Power Elite,compiled by G. William Domhoff and Hoyt B. Ballard. Boston:Beacon Press:189-225.
Brick,Howard. 1993. "The Reformist Dimension of Talcott Parsons's Early Social Theory." In The Culture of the Market:Historical Essays,edited by Thomas L. Haskell and Richard F. Teichgraeber Ⅲ. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press:357-396.
Burawoy,Michael. 2008. "Open Letter to C. Wright Mills." Antipode 40(3):365-375.
Denzin,Norman K. 1990. "Presidential Address on ‘The Sociological Imagination’ Revisited." The Sociological Quarterly 31(1):1-22.
Faris,Robert E. L. 1967. Chicago Sociology 1920-1932. Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
Geary,Daniel. 2009. Radical Ambition:C. Wright Mills,the Left,and American Social Thought. Berkeley:University of California Press.
Gerhardt,Uta. 2002. Talcott Parsons:An Intellectual Biography. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
Greek,Cecil E. 1992. The Religious Roots of American Sociology. New York:Garland Publishing,Inc.
Holton,Robert J. and Bryan S. Turner. 1986. "Against Nostalgia:Talcott Parsons and a Sociology for the Modern World." In Talcott Parsons on Economy and Society,edited by Robert J. Holton and Bryan S. Turner. London and New York:Routledge & Kegan Paul:207-234.
Horowitz,Irving Louis. 1984. C. Wright Mills:An American Utopian. New York:The Free Press.
Kornhauser,William.[1961]1968. "‘Power Elite’ or ‘Veto Group’?" Reprinted in C. Wright Mills and The Power Elite,compiled by G. William Domhoff and Hoyt B. Ballard. Boston:Beacon Press:37-59.
Kuklick,Henrika. 1973. "A ‘Scientific Revolution’:Sociological Theory in the United States,1930-1945." Sociological Inquiry 43(1):3-22.
Lechner,Frank J. 1991. "Parsons and Modernity:An Interpretation." In Talcott Parsons:Theorist of Modernity,edited by Roland Robertson and Bryan S. Turner. London:Sage Publications:166-186.
Lengermann,Patricia Madoo. 1979. "The Founding of the American Sociological Review:The Anatomy of a Rebellion." American Sociological Review 44(2):185-198.
Lidz,Victor. 1991. "The American Value System:A Commentary on Talcott Parsons's Perspective and Understanding." In Talcott Parsons:Theorist of Modernity,edited by Roland Robertson and Bryan S. Turner. London:Sage Publications:22-37.
Martindale,Don. 1976. The Romance of a Profession:A Case History in the Sociology of Sociology. Minneapolis-St. Paul:Windflower Press.
Mayhew,Leon. 1984. "In Defense of Modernity:Talcott Parsons and the Utilitarian Tradition." American Journal of Sociology 89(6):1273-1305.
Mills,C. Wright. 1943. "The Professional Ideology of Social Pathologists." American Journal of Sociology 49(2):165-180.
Mills,C. Wright. 1948. The New Men of Power:America's Labor Leaders. New York:Harcourt,Brace.
Mills,C. Wright. 1951. White Collar:The American Middle Classes. New York:Oxford University Press.
Mills,C. Wright. 1953. "Two Styles of Research in Current Social Studies." Philosophy of Science 20(4):266-275.
Mills,C. Wright.[1954]2008. "IBM plus Reality plus Humanism=Sociology." Reprinted in The Politics of Truth:Selected Writings of C. Wright Mills,selected and introduced by John H. Summers. New York:Oxford University Press:79-85.
Mills,C. Wright. 1956. The Power Elite. New York:Oxford University Press.
Mills,C. Wright.[1957]1968. "Comment on Criticism."Reprinted in C. Wright Mills and The Power Elite,compiled by G. William Domhoff and Hoyt B. Ballard. Boston:Beacon Press:229-250.
Mills,C. Wright.[1959a]2008. "On Intellectual Craftsmanship." In The Politics of Truth:Selected Writings of C. Wright Mills,selected and introduced by John H. Summers. New York:Oxford University Press:43-62.
Mills,C. Wright. 1959b. The Sociological Imagination. New York:Oxford University Press.
Mills,C. Wright.[1959c]2008. "Culture and Politics:The Fourth Epoch." In The Politics of Truth:Selected Writings of C. Wright Mills,selected and introduced by John H. Summers. New York:Oxford University Press:193-201.
Mills,C. Wright.[1959d]2008. "The Cultural Apparatus." In The Politics of Truth:Selected Writings of C. Wright Mills,selected and introduced by John H. Summers. New York:Oxford University Press:202-212.
Mills,C. Wright.[1959e]2008. "The Decline of the Left." In The Politics of Truth:Selected Writings of C. Wright Mills,selected and introduced by John H. Summers. New York:Oxford University Press:213-222.
Mills,C. Wright.[1960]2008. "Letter to the New Left." In The Politics of Truth:Selected Writings of C. Wright Mills,selected and introduced by John H. Summers. New York:Oxford University Press:255-266.
Mills,C. Wright. 2008. The Politics of Truth:Selected Writings of C. Wright Mills,selected and introduced by John H. Summers. New York:Oxford University Press.
Odum,Howard. 1951. American Sociology:The Story of Sociology in the United States through 1950. New York:Greenwood.
Parsons,Talcott. 1951. The Social System. New York:The Free Press.
Parsons,Talcott.[1957]1969. "The Distribution of Power in American Society." Reprinted in Politics and Social Structure. New York:The Free Press:185-203.
Parsons,Talcott. 1961. "The Point of View of the Author." In The Social Theories of Talcott Parsons:A Critical Examination,edited by Max Black. Englewood Cliffs:Prentice-Hall:311-363.
Parsons,Talcott. 1963. "On the Concept of Political Power." In Politics and Social Structure. New York:The Free Press,1969:352-404.
Parsons,Talcott.[1937]1968. The Structure of Social Action:A Study in Social Theory with Special Reference to a Group of Recent European Writers. New York:The Free Press.
Parsons,Talcott.[1970]1977."On Building Social System Theory:A Personal History." Reprinted in Social System and the Evolution of Action Theory. New York:The Free Press:22-76.
Parsons,Talcott. 1971. The System of Modern Societies. Engewood Cliffs:Prentice-Hall.
Parsons,Talcott. 1976. "Afterword." In The Social Theoreties of Talcott parsons:A Critical Examination,edited by Max Black. Carbondale:Southern Illinois University Press:364-370.
Parsons,Talcott. 1978. "A paradigm of the Human Condition." In Action Theory and the Human Condition,New York:Free Press:352-433.
Parsons,Talcott. 2007. American Society:A Theory of the Societal Community,edited and introduced by Giuseppe Sciortino,London:Paradigm Publishers.
Parsons,Talcott and Bernard Barber. 1948. "Sociology,1941-46." American Journal of Sociology 53(4):245-257.
Parsons,Talcott and Edward A. Shils. 1951. "Values,Motives,and Systems of Action." In Toward a General Theory of Action. Cambridge:Harvard University Press:45-275.
Parsons,Talcott and W. White.[1961]1964. "The Link between Character and Society." Reprinted in Social Structure and Personality. New York:Free Press:183-235.
Pitts,Jesse R. 1980. "Talcott Parsons:The Sociologist as the Last Puritan." American Sociologist 15:62-64.
Rocher,Guy. 1974. Talcott Parsons and American Society. London:Nelson.
Scimecca,Joseph A. 1977. The Sociological Theory of C. Wright Mill. Port Washington:Kennikat Press.
Shils,Edward. 1960. "Imaginary Sociology." Encounter 13(4):77-81.
Shils,Edward. 1961. "Professor Mills on the Calling of Sociology." World Politics 13(4):600-621.
Trevino,A. Javier. 2012. The Social Thought of C. Wright Mills. Los Angeles:Sage.
Vidich,Arthur J. and Stanford M. Lyman. 1985. American Sociology:Worldly Rejections of Religion and Their Directions. New Haven:Yale University Press.
Wearne,Bruce C. 1989. The Theory and Scholarship of Talcott Parsons to 1951:A Critical Commentary. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.

[1]	闻翔. 以“匠人精神”,写“社会学的诗”:米尔斯的社会学遗产之重估[J]. 社会杂志, 2016, 36(6): 126-154.
[2]	赵立玮. 世纪末忧郁与美国精神气质——帕森斯与古典社会理论的现代转变[J]. 社会杂志, 2015, 35(6): 1-30.
[3]	闻翔 . 从“大众社会”到“社会学的想像力” 理解米尔斯的一条内在线索[J]. 社会杂志, 2012, 32(4): 1-23.
[4]	郑从金. 在现代社会学与后现代社会理论之间——米尔斯的《社会学的想像力》再解读 [J]. 社会杂志, 2007, 27(1): 180-180 .