社会杂志 ›› 2021, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (2): 218-242.
• 论文 • 上一篇
吴菲
出版日期:
2021-03-20
发布日期:
2021-03-23
作者简介:
吴菲,E-mail:haniawu@fudan.edu.cn
WU Hania Fei
Online:
2021-03-20
Published:
2021-03-23
摘要: 已有众多研究揭示了社会经济地位与肥胖关系的性别差异:对女性来说,社会经济地位越高,肥胖的可能性越低;对男性来说,社会经济地位越高越可能肥胖。这种性别化的相关关系可能有两种来源:“社会决定假设”认为社会经济地位是肥胖的根本性原因,因果方向由社会经济地位指向肥胖;相反,“健康选择假设”认为劳动力市场会根据人们的身材进行筛选,因果方向由肥胖指向社会经济地位。本文旨在借助CFPS2010、2012、2014、2016数据的成人样本,使用动态结构方程模型检验社会经济地位与肥胖之间的因果关系及其性别异质性,以区分“社会决定”和“身材筛选”两种假设在男性和女性中的相对影响。分析结果证实了社会经济地位与肥胖的因果关系有明显的性别差异:对男性而言,已有研究中发现的正向相关同时来自“社会决定”和“身材筛选”过程;对女性而言,已有研究中的负向相关主要来自“身材筛选”过程。
吴菲. 社会决定抑或身材筛选?社会经济地位与肥胖的性别化因果关系[J]. 社会杂志, 2021, 41(2): 218-242.
WU Hania Fei. Social Determination or Body Shape Selection? The Gendered Causal Relationship between Socioeconomic Status and Obesity[J]. Chinese Journal of Sociology, 2021, 41(2): 218-242.
弗伦奇,保罗、马修·格莱博. 2012. 富态:腰围改变中国[M]. 贾蓓妮、关永强,译. 杭州:浙江大学出版社. 洪岩璧、刘精明. 2019. 早期健康与阶层再生产[J].社会学研究(1):156-182. 胡安宁. 2014. 教育能否让我们更健康——基于2010年中国综合社会调查的城乡比较分析[J]. 中国社会科学(5):117-131. 焦开山. 2014. 健康不平等影响因素研究[J]. 社会学研究(5):24-46. 孔国书、齐亚强. 2017. 影响居民肥胖的社会经济因素:性别与城乡差异[J]. 社会学评论(5):79-96. 梁玉成、陈金燕. 2019. 社会资本研究中的双向因果问题探索[J]. 社会发展研究(3):1-21. 石智雷、吴志明. 2018. 早年不幸对健康不平等的长远影响:生命历程与双重累积劣势[J]. 社会学研究(3):166-192. 王甫勤. 2011. 社会流动有助于降低健康不平等吗?[J]. 社会学研究(2):78-101. 王甫勤. 2017. 地位束缚与生活方式转型——中国各社会阶层健康生活方式潜在类别研究[J]. 社会学研究(6):117-140. 郑莉、曾旭晖. 2016. 社会分层与健康不平等的性别差异——基于生命历程的纵向分析[J]. 社会36(6):209-237. Akee,Randall,Emilia Simeonova,William Copeland,Adrian Angold,and Jane Costello. 2010. “Does More Money Make You Fat? The Effects of Quasi-Experimental Income Transfers on Adolescent and Young Adult Obesity.”Iza Discussion Papers. Allison,Paul,Richard Williams,and Enrique Moral-Benito. 2017. “Maximum Likelihood for Cross-Lagged Panel Models with Fixed Effects.”Socius 3:1-17. Ball,Kylie and David Crawford. 2005. “Socioeconomic Status and Weight Change in Adults:A Review.”Social Science & Medicine 60(9):1987-2010. Ball,Kylie,Gita Mishra,and David Crawford. 2002. “Which Aspects of Socioeconomic Status are Related to Obesity among Men and Women?”International Journal of Obesity 26(4):559-565. Bhaskaran,Krishnan,Isabel dos-Santos-Silva,David Leon,Ian Douglas,and Liam Smeeth. 2018. “Association of BMI with Overall and Cause-Specific Mortality:A Population-Based Cohort Study of 3.6 Million Adults in the UK.”The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology 6(12):944-953. Blair,Steven and Suzanne Brodney. 1999. “Effects of Physical Inactivity and Obesity on Morbidity and Mortality:Current Evidence and Research Issues.” Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise 31(11 Suppl):646-662. Bonnefond,Céline and Matthieu Clément. 2014. “Social Class and Body Weight among Chinese Urban Adults:The Role of the Middle Classes in the Nutrition Transition.”Social Science & Medicine 112:22-29. Braveman,Paula,Susan Egerter,and David Williams. 2011. “The Social Determinants of Health:Coming of Age.”Annual Review of Public Health 32(1):381-398. Buettner,Roland,Jürgen Schölmerich,and Cornelius Bollheimer. 2007.“High-Fat Diets:Modeling the Metabolic Disorders of Human Obesity in Rodents.”Obesity 15(4):798-808. Cawley,John. 2004. “The Impact of Obesity on Wages.” Journal of Human Resources 39(2):451-474. Chandola,Tarani,Mel Bartley,Amanda Sacker,Crispin Jenkinson,and Michael Marmot. 2003. “Health Selection in the Whitehall ⅡStudy,UK.” Social Sience & Medicine 56(10):2059-2072. Chen,Chunming and Frank C Lu. 2004. “The Guidelines for Prevention and Control of Overweight and Obesity in Chinese Adults.” Biomedical and Environmental Sciences 17(Suppl):1-36. Christensen,Vibeke and Richard Carpiano. 2014. “Social Class Differences in BMI among Danish Women:Applying Cockerham's Health Lifestyles Approach and Bourdieu's Theory of Lifestyle.” Social Science & Medicine 112:12-21. Conley,Dalton and Rebecca Glauber. 2006. “Gender,Body Mass,and Socioeconomic Status:New Evidence from the PSID.” In The Economics of Obesity. Bradford:Emerald Group Publishing Limited. Du,Shufa,Tom Mroza,Fengying Zhai,and Barry Popkin. 2004. “Rapid Income Growth Adversely Affects Diet Quality in China—Particularly for the Poor!”Social Science & Medicine 59(7):1505-1515. Everson,Susan,Siobhan Maty,John Lynch,and George Kaplan. 2002. “Epidemiologic Evidence for the Relation between Socioeconomic Status and Depression,Obesity,and Diabetes.” Journal of Psychosomatic Research 53(4):891-895. Foverskov,Else and Anders Holm. 2016. “Socioeconomic Inequality in Health in the British Household Panel:Tests of the Social Causation,Health Selection and the Indirect Selection Hypothesis Using Dynamic Fixed Effects Panel Models.”Social Science & Medicine 150:172-183. Franks,P. W. and Atabaki-Pasdar. 2017. “Causal Inference in Obesity Research.” Journal of Internal Medicine 28:222-232. Giskes,Katrina,Frank Van Lenthe,Gavin Turrell,Carlijn Kamphuis,Johannes Brug,and Johan Mackenbach. 2008. “Socioeconomic Position at Different Stages of the Life Course and Its Influence on Body Weight and Weight Gain in Adulthood:A Longitudinal Study with 13-Year Follow-up.” Obesity 16(6):1377-1381. Goldblatt,Phillip,Mary Moore,and Albert Stunkard. 1965. “Social Factors in Obesity.” The Journal of the American Medical Association 192(12):1039-1044. González,Silvia,Oscar Lozano,and Andrea Ramírez. 2014. “Physical Activity Levels among Colombian Adults:Inequalities by Gender and Socioeconomic Status.”Biomedica Revista Del Instituto Nacional De Salud 34(3):447-459. Grundy,Scott. 1998. “Multifactorial Causation of Obesity:Implications for Prevention.” The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 67(3):563S-572S. Hamermesh,Daniel and Jeff Biddle. 1994. “Beauty and the Labor Market.” The American Economic Review 84(5):1174-1194. Hammarström,Anne and Urban Janlert. 2005. “Health Selection in A 14-Year Follow-Up Study—A Question of Gendered Discrimination?” Social Science & Medicine 61(10):2221-2132. Heraclides,Alexandros and Eric Brunner. 2010. “Social Mobility and Social Accumulation across the Life Course in Relation to Adult Overweight and Obesity:The Whitehall Ⅱ Study.” Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health 64(8):714-719. Hoffmann,Rasmus,Hannes Kröger,and Siegfried Geyer. 2019. “Social Causation versus Health Selection in the Life Course:Does Their Relative Importance Differ by Dimension of SES?” Social Indicators Research 141:1341-1367. Jeffery,Robert and Simone French. 1996. “Socioeconomic Status and Weight Control Practices among 20- to 45-Year-Old Women.”American Journal of Public Health 86(7):1005-1010. Jusot,Florence,Myriam Khlat,Thierry Rochereau,and Catherine Sermet. 2008. “Job Loss from Poor Health,Smoking and Obesity:A National Prospective Survey in France.” Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health 62(4):332-337. Kane,Jennifer Buher,Kathleen Mullan Harris,Philip Morgan,and David Guilkey. 2018. “Pathways of Health and Human Capital from Adolescence into Young Adulthood.”Social Forces 96(3):949-976. Kawachi,Ichiro,Nancy Adler,and William Dow. 2010. “Money,Schooling,and Health:Mechanisms and Causal Evidence.” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1186(1):56-68. Kim,Jinho. 2016. “Personality Traits and Body Weight: Evidence Using Sibling Comparisons.” Social Science & Medicine 163:54-62. Kim,Tae Jun and Olaf von dem Knesebeck. 2018. “Income and Obesity:What is the Direction of the Relationship? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.” BMJ open 8(1):e019862. DOI:10.1136/bmjopen-2017-019862. Laaksonen,Mikko,Ossi Rahkonen,Pekka Martikainen,and Eero Lahelma. 2005. “Socioeconomic Position and Self-Rated Health:The Contribution of Childhood Socioeconomic Circumstances,Adult Socioeconomic Status,and Material Resources.” American Journal of Public Health 95(8):1403-1409. Langenberg,Claudia,Rebecca Hardy,Diana Kuh,Eric Brunner,and Michael Wadsworth. 2003. “Central and Total Obesity in Middle Aged Men and Women in Relation to Lifetime Socioeconomic Status:Evidence from A National Birth Cohort.”Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health 57(10):816-822. Lartey,Stella,Costan Magnussen,Lei Si,Barbara de Graaff,Richard Berko Biritwum,George Mensah,Alfred Yawson,Nadia Minicuci,Paul Kowal,and Godfred Boateng. 2019. “The Role of Intergenerational Educational Mobility and Household Health in Adult Obesity:Evidence from Wave 2 of the World Health Organization's Study on Global Ageing and Adult Health.” PLoS ONE 14(1):e0208491. Levasseur,Pierre. 2015. “Causal Effects of Socioeconomic Status on Central Adiposity Risks:Evidence Using Panel Data from Urban Mexico.”Social Science & Medicine 136:165-174. Lewis,Sophie,Samantha Thomas,Richard Warwick Blood,David Castle,Jim Hyde,and Paul Komesaroff. 2011. “How do Obese Individuals Perceive and Respond to the Different Types of Obesity Stigma that They Encounter in Their Daily Lives? A Qualitative Study.”Social Science & Medicine 73(9):1349-1356. Link,Bruce,Jo Phelan,Richard Miech,and Emily Leckman Westin. 2008. “The Resources that Matter:Fundamental Social Causes of Health Disparities and the Challenge of Intelligence.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior 49(1):72-91. Locke,Adam,Bratati Kahali,Sonja Berndt,Anne Justice,Tune Pers,Felix Day,Corey Powell,Sailaja Vedantam,Martin Buchkovich,and Jian Yang. 2015. “Genetic Studies of Body Mass Index Yield New Insights for Obesity Biology.”Nature 518(7 538):197-206. Luo,Ye,William Parish,and Edward Laumann. 2005. “A Population-Based Study of Body Image Concerns among Urban Chinese Adults.” 2(4):333-345. Luppino,Floriana,Leonore de Wit,Paul Bouvy,Theo Stijnen,Pim Cuijpers,Brenda Penninx,and Frans Zitman. 2010. “Overweight,Obesity,and Depression:A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Longitudinal Studies.”Archives of General Psychiatry 67(3):220-229. Lynch,Jamie and P. T. V. Hippel. 2016. “An Education Gradient in Health,A Health Gradient in Education,Or A Confounded Gradient in Both?” Social Science & Medicine 154:18-27. Malhotra,Rahul,Chetna Malhotra,Angelique Chan,and Truls Østbye. 2012. “Life-Course Socioeconomic Status and Obesity among Older Singaporean Chinese Men and Women.”Journals of Gerontology Series B:Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences 68(1):117-127. McLaren,Lindsay. 2007.“Socioeconomic Status and Obesity.”Epidemiologic Reviews 29(1):29-48. Monteiro,Carlos,Erly Moura,Wolney Conde,and Barry Popkin. 2004. “Socioeconomic Status and Obesity in Adult Populations of Developing Countries:A Review.”Bulletin of the World Health Organization 82:940-946. Morris,Stephen. 2006. “Body Mass Index and Occupational Attainment.”Journal of Health Economics 25(2):347-364. Muraro,Ana Paula,Regina Maria Veras Gonçalves-Silva,Márcia Gonçalves Ferreira,and Rosely Sichieri. 2016. “Effects of Social Mobility from Childhood to Adolescence on BMI.”Public Health Nutrition 19(5):814-821. NCD-RisC. 2016. “Trends in Adult Body-Mass Index in 200 Countries from 1975 to 2014:A Pooled Analysis of 1698 Population-Based Measurement Studies with 19.2 Million Participants.”The Lancet 387(10026):1377-1396. Newton,Suzy,Dejana Braithwaite,and Tomi F Akinyemiju. 2017. “Socio-Economic Status over the Life Course and Obesity:Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.” PLoS ONE 12(5):e0177151. Paeratakul,S,Jennifer Lovejoy,Donna Ryan,and George Bray. 2002. “The Relation of Gender,Race and Socioeconomic Status to Obesity and Obesity Comorbidities in A Sample of US Adults.”International Journal of Obesity 26(9):1205. Pampel,Fred,Justin Denney,and Patrick Krueger. 2012. “Obesity,SES,and Economic Development:A Test of the Reversal Hypothesis.”Social Science & Medicine 74(7):1073-1081. Pan,Jay and Xuezheng Qin. 2013. “The Impact of Body Size on Urban Employment:Evidence from China.” China Economic Review 27:249-263. Patel,Sanjay and Frank Hu. 2012. “Short Sleep Duration and Weight Gain:A Systematic Review.”Obesity 16(3):643-653. Pei,Leilei,Yue Cheng,Yijun Kang,Shuyi Yuan,and Hong Yan. 2015. “Association of Obesity with Socioeconomic Status among Adults of Ages 18 to 80 Years in Rural Northwest China.” BMC Public Health 15(1):160-169. Popkin,Barry and Penny Gordon-Larsen. 2004. “The Nutrition Transition:Worldwide Obesity Dynamics and Their Determinants.” Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord 28(Suppl 3):S2-S9. Puhl,Rebecca and Chelsea Heuer. 2009. “The Stigma of Obesity:A Review and Update.”Obesity 17(5):941-964. Reagan,Patricia and Joni Hersch. 2005. “Influence of Race,Gender,and Socioeconomic Status on Binge Eating Frequency in A Population-Based Sample.” International Journal of Eating Disorders 38(3):252-256. Seubsman,Sam-ang,Lynette LY Lim,Cathy Banwell,Nintita Sripaiboonkit,Matthew Kelly,Christopher Bain,and Adrian Sleigh. 2010. “Socioeconomic Status,Sex,and Obesity in A Large National Cohort of 15-87-Year-Old Open University Students in Thailand.”Journal of Epidemiology 20(1):13-20. Shimokawa,Satoru. 2008. “The Labour Market Impact of Body Weight in China:A Semiparametric Analysis.”Applied Economics 40(8):949-968. Smith,Davey Smith. 2016.“Can Genetic Evidence Help Us Understand Why Height and Weight Relate to Social Position?” BMJ 352:i1224. Doi: 10.1136/bmj.i1224. Sobal,Jeffery and Albert Stunkard. 1989. “Socioeconomic Status and Obesity:A Review of the Literature.”Psychological Bulletin 105(2):260-275. Susan,Averett and Korenman Sanders. 1993. “The Economic Reality of the Beauty Myth.”The Journal of Human Resources 31(2):304-330. Van Gaal,Luc F,Ilse Mertens,and Christophe E De Block. 2006. “Mechanisms Linking Obesity with Cardiovascular Disease.” Nature 444(7121):875-880. Wannamethee,Goya,Alison Field,Graham Colditz,and Eric Rimm. 2004. “Alcohol Intake and 8-Year Weight Gain in Women:A Prospective Study.”Obesity Research 12(9):1386-1396. Wardle,Jane,Jo Waller,and Martin Jarvis. 2002. “Sex Differences in the Association of Socioeconomic Status with Obesity.”American Journal of Public Health 92(8):1299-1304. Xiao,Yuanyuan,Naiqing Zhao,Hao Wang,Jie Zhang,Qingfang He,Danting Su,Ming Zhao,Lixin Wang,Xinwei Zhang,and Weiwei Gong. 2013. “Association between Socioeconomic Status and Obesity in A Chinese Adult Population.”BMC Public Health 13(1):355-364. Yiengprugsawan,V,BL Horta,JV Motta,D Gigante,SA Seubsman,and A Sleigh. 2016. “Body Size Dynamics in Young Adults:8-Year Follow Up of Cohorts in Brazil and Thailand.” Nutrition & Diabetes 6(7):1-4. Zhang,Hua,Hui Xu,Fei Song,Weili Xu,Stephanie Pallard-Borg,and Xiuying Qi. 2017. “Relation of Socioeconomic Status to Overweight and Obesity:A Large Population-Based Study of Chinese Adults.”Annals of Human Biology 44(6):495-501. Zhang,Qi and Youfa Wang. 2004. “Trends in the Association between Obesity and Socioeconomic Status in US Adults:1971 to 2000.”Obesity Research 12(10):1622-1632. Zhou,Maigeng,Haidong Wang,Jun Zhu,Wanqing Chen,Linhong Wang,Shiwei Liu,Yichong Li,Lijun Wang,Yunning Liu,and Peng Yin. 2016. “Cause-Specific Mortality for 240 Causes in China During 1990—2013:A Systematic Subnational Analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2013.”The Lancet 387(10015):251-272. |
[1] | 洪岩璧, 赵延东. 灾后重建中的资源再分配与健康不平等:基于三期汶川地震重建调查[J]. 社会杂志, 2019, 39(6): 214-237. |
[2] | 郑莉, 曾旭晖. 社会分层与健康不平等的性别差异:基于生命历程的纵向分析[J]. 社会杂志, 2016, 36(6): 209-237. |
[3] | 朱依娜, 何光喜. 学术产出的性别差异:一个社会网络分析的视角[J]. 社会杂志, 2016, 36(4): 76-102. |
[4] | 王进,陈晓思. 学校环境与学生成绩的性别差异[J]. 社会杂志, 2013, 33(5): 159-180. |
[5] | 陈云松. 农民工收入与村庄网络 基于多重模型识别策略的因果效应分析[J]. 社会杂志, 2012, 32(4): 68-92. |
[6] | 王甫勤. 社会经济地位、生活方式与健康不平等[J]. 社会杂志, 2012, 32(2): 125-143. |
[7] | 吕涛. 社会资本与地位获得——简单与复杂的因果机制和因果联结[J]. 社会杂志, 2011, 31(3): 200-223. |
阅读次数 | ||||||
全文 |
|
|||||
摘要 |
|
|||||