社会杂志 ›› 2021, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (4): 1-29.

• 专题: 礼与制:中国社会理论 •    下一篇

一本与一体:中国社会理论的基础

周飞舟   

  1. 北京大学社会学系, 北京大学中国社会与发展研究中心, 北京大学中国传统社会研究中心
  • 发布日期:2021-07-22
  • 作者简介:周飞舟,E-mail:feizhou@pku.edu.cn

Yiben and Yiti: The Basis of Chinese Sociological Theory

ZHOU Feizhou   

  1. Department of Sociology, Peking University;The Center for Sociological Research and Development Studies of China, Peking University;Research Center of Chinese Traditional Society, Peking University
  • Published:2021-07-22

摘要: 本文是对建立中国社会理论基础的一个尝试性探索。近年来,关于当代中国社会的经验研究在处理社会关系、社会结构方面的问题时难以深入,其根本原因在于缺少对中国社会结构的理论认识,这也是建设有中国特色的社会学的瓶颈。本文从中国传统的家庭理论入手,以费孝通提出的“反馈模式”为切入点,深入讨论父子关系的性质,并以此为基础形成对差序格局和中国社会关系的基本理解。本文指出,中国传统社会结构的基础是“一体本位”而非“个体本位”。一体的思想源于“一本”的社会意识,即以父母为本而非以天为本或以神为本,这在中国传统的祭礼中有明显体现。“一体”是指“父子一体” “母子一体”,这种深层的社会意识在中国经典文本中有突出表现,本文对与此相关的儒家典籍进行了细致的分析和阐释。“一本”和“一体”的社会意识构成了以“孝”为本的社会伦理体系,与家国同构的社会结构相互呼应。在这种社会结构下,孝并非一种私德,而是一种具有基础作用的“公德”,孝是众德之本,一个真正的孝子也会是一个忠臣。“孝”背后的一本和一体意识也是我们理解差序格局概念以及当今诸多社会现象的理论基础。中国社会转型的根本取决于这种深层的社会意识以及与此相关的社会结构的转型。

关键词: 差序格局, 反馈模式, 一本, 一体

Abstract: This paper is a tentative exploration to identify a theoretical foundation of Chinese society. In recent years, empirical research has been unable to go further indepth in tackling issues of social relations and social structure of contemporary Chinese society. The fundamental reason of this problem lies in the lack of theoretical understanding of Chinese social structure, the same bottleneck difficulty for constructing sociology with Chinese characteristics. This article starts with the traditional Chinese family theory and uses the "feedback mode" proposed by Fei Xiaotong as an entry point to discuss in depth the nature of the father-son relationship to reach a basic understanding of the differential order pattern(chaxu geju) and Chinese social relations. The paper suggests that the basis of Chinese traditional social structure is an "integration standard" (yiti) rather than an "individual standard". The idea of oneness(yiti) stems from the social consciousness of "one foundation"(yiben), that is, regarding parents, rathan Heaven or God, as one's foundation, a belief that is explicitly reflected in traditional Chinese sacrificial rituals."Oneness"(yiti) refers to "father and son as one" and "mother and child as one". This deep social consciousness is prominently expressed in Chinese classic texts. The paper offers a detailed analysis and interpretation of relevant Confucian classics. The Chinese social consciousness of oneness(yiti) and one foundation(yiben) constitutes a system of social ethics based on "filial piety"(xiao), upon which lies the whole social structure of family and country. Under such a social structure, "filial piety" is not just personal virtue, but "public morality" with a basic social function. Filial piety is the foundation of all virtues, and a true filial son is also a loyal vassal. All this constitutes the theoretical basis for us to understand many social phenomena today. The transformation of Chinese society depends on the transformation of the deep social consciousness and social structure.

Key words: differential mode of association, feedback mode in Chinese family, yiben, yiti