社会杂志 ›› 2023, Vol. 43 ›› Issue (2): 18-53.

• 专题二:观念与制度的近代转型 • 上一篇    下一篇

修身、成圣与革命:五四时期道德主义者的激进化

陈艳楠   

  • 发布日期:2023-05-06
  • 作者简介:陈艳楠,中国政法大学社会学院,E-mail:yannanchen_ac@163.com

Self-Cultivation,Sanctification and Revolution:Understanding the Radicalization of May 4th Moralist

CHEN Yannan   

  • Published:2023-05-06

摘要: 五四运动后“救亡”与“启蒙”、“政治”与“文化”的交织与竞逐是我们理解中国近代史的一条线索。既有研究多将恽代英呈现为一个具有道德主义色彩和儒家伦理底蕴的五四知识分子,然而顺着这一思路,我们却难以理解他为何从温和的道德结社转向革命。本文认为,恽代英精神世界中的心学底色,以及他对青年会社会服务经验的借鉴,使他形成了与共产主义者相通的道德认知;道德结社的困境则促使他走向政党运动,以群众运动实践自己的道德理想。恽代英的早期经历为我们呈现了过渡时代具有儒学底蕴的知识分子面对现代政治秩序时的道德困惑,这有助于我们理解中国共产主义革命对德性的强调以及儒家中国的现代转化。

关键词: 道德, 政治, 心学, 社会福音主义, 共产主义革命

Abstract: The interweaving and competition between “national salvation” and “enlightenment”,“politics” and “culture” after the May Fourth Movement are an important clue for us to understand modern Chinese history. The student societies established by Chinese modern intellectuals during the May 4th Movement provided both the communication mechanism for the spread of the New Culture Movement,and the organizational foundation for the Chinese Communist party,which helped Communism take root in China. The “Liqun(benefiting the society)Bookstore”,initiated by Yun Daiying,was such an organization that played “the linkage”between local society and modern cultural and political ideas. Understanding the organizational principles,structures,ethics,and identities and beliefs of its key members is of great significance to our understanding of the localization of social changes. Existing studies mostly present Yun Daiying as a moralist intellectual influenced by Confucian ethics. However,following this line of thought,it is difficult for us to understand why Yun Daiying turned from a moderate moralist activist into a radical revolutionary. This paper argues that Yun Daiying’s radicalization comes from the combined effect of both Wang Yang-min’s philosophy and Christian socialism,which enables him to develop a moral cognition common with communists,and an inherent affinity with Bolshevism. The dilemma of his moral commitment impels him to go for mass political activities to implement his unfinished moral ideals in a new way. Yun Daiying’s early experience shows us the moral confusion faced by intellectuals with Confucian background when facing the modern political order in the transitional era and their expectations to bridge the tension between “morality” and “politics”. This helps us to understand the moral preferences of the Chinese communist revolution,and the modern transformation of Confucian China.

Key words: morality, politics, Wang Yang-ming’s School of mind, Christian socialism, communist revolution