社会杂志

• 专题:项目制研究 •    下一篇

项目制与政府间权责关系演变:机制及其影响

作者1:陈家建    西南财经大学社会工作发展研究中心; 作者2:张琼文    西南财经大学社会工作发展研究中心; 作者3:胡    俞    西南财经大学社会工作发展研究中心   

  • 出版日期:2015-09-20 发布日期:2015-09-20
  • 通讯作者: 陈家建 西南财经大学社会工作发展研究中心 E-mail:1983970000@163.com
  • 基金资助:
    本研究受到国家社科基金青年项目“项目化治理与农村公共服务供给机制研究”(15CSH049)资助。

Project System and Its Impact on Relationship between Different Levels of Government

Author 1: CHEN Jiajian, Social Work Development Research Center, Southwestern University of Finance and Economics; Author 2: ZHANG Qiongwen, Social Work Development Research Center, Southwestern University of Finance and Economics; Author 3: HU Yu, Social Work Development Research Center, Southwestern University of Finance and Economics   

  • Online:2015-09-20 Published:2015-09-20
  • Contact: CHEN Jiajian, Social Work Development Research Center, Southwestern University of Finance and Economics E-mail:1983970000@163.com
  • Supported by:
    This research is supported by National Social Science Fund of China (15CSH049).

摘要: 项目化运作是近年来国家治理的重要模式。既有研究已揭示:在项目制下,上级政府控制权增加,而下级政府的统筹治理能力被压缩。本文通过考察国家妇女小额贷款项目的演变过程发现,在项目制下,政府间权责关系的明晰化使下级政府可以通过倒逼机制影响上级部门的行为,维护地方政府利益。这实际上反映出,项目化运作不仅提供了从上至下的控制渠道,也同时增生了由下至上的反控手段。在这种演变中,上下级政府间关系出现了新的变化,双方围绕权责关系展开互动博弈,进而影响国家与社会关系,出现基层治理的“脱嵌”现象。

关键词: 权责关系 , 基层治理 , 项目制 , 倒逼机制 , 脱嵌

Abstract:  In recent years, project initiatives became an important administrative vehicle of the Chinese state governance.Existing literature speculate without documented empirical data that the system has increased the control of higher level authorities over their subordinates,affecting the lower level governments’ ability for overall coordination.To verify such claims this study examines a central government sponsored project of microlending program for women in Sichuan province. The finding indicates that although the project system provides opportunities for more higher level government control,it also allows lower level governments more bargaining power as counter weight. Unlike the institutionalized administrative contract system,in which rights and responsibilities are fixed,the project system permits negotiation on a projecttoproject base,allowing lower level governments to extract terms beneficial to local interests. Therefore,it is not just a topdown one way control. It is a twoway fluid relationship that is constantly in negotiation, clarification and formalization. In our view,the project system has forced local governments to protect local interest by focusing on clarification of rules and regulations,and formalization of rights and responsibilities. This began to have a farreaching effect on local governance,as well as the relationship between different levels of governments, and between state and society.

Key words: relationship of rights and responsibilities , disembeddedness, countercharge , basic level governance ,  project system